C.H. asks from Missouri City, TX on February 10, 2011
Need Help with 16 Year Old Son
Here's the situation...I have a 16 yr old son who does not communicate with his family, failing school, is defiant and disrespectful to adults and acts like he is the victim when someone says two words to him. My husband and I have tried everything. And when I mean everything, I mean everything. Counseling for two years, taking video and computer privileges away, having him stay after school for tutoring, the loving approach, the disciplined approach, the leave him alone approach. We entertained the thoughts of depression however, he only acts like this around us and other adults (more so us). He doesn't have many friends, he doesn't go out, play sports nor is he in any extra curricular activities. We have done our best to expose him to all sorts of things, yet he still just stays at home and stares at the computer, tv or sleeps. He seems to have no remorse or accountability for his actions. He simply blames others for his failings. What do we do? We can't afford military school and we don't have any family or friends that could snap him out of this. Short of a near death experience, my husband and I are desperate for some kind of solution. Any advice would be welcomed.
Stumped and Frustrated,
C
Featured Answers
A.S. answers from San Diego on February 10, 2011
Okay 2nd time writing response. Try tough love with a threat of emancipation. Sit down with him and draw up a legal and binding contract about the rules of the house. Get him to a psychologist and have them tell you what he needs. He might also need ant-depressants. Have his doctor do a D3 test on him as low levels can result in depression. More important if he holds you responsible for all his wrong doings I think a contract that is legal and binding would be a great idea, that way you can all come up with the rules and all be held accountable. He might wake up then knowing that he could have severe consequences to his actions. You could take the door to his room away and tell him that when he starts to shape up he gets certain priveleges back such as his door, computer, anything else. Good Luck.
1 mom found this helpful
S.S. answers from Los Angeles on February 10, 2011
Been there (am there). Don't have the answers. Just wondering if he really does have friends. My son has a lot of "friends" at school, but none whose last name or address he could name. No one here he feels comfortable inviting over. That's hard on a kid, too.
More Answers
C.S. answers from Kansas City on February 10, 2011
LOL- your son sounds like my three friends teenagers :) I don't think this is uncommon. My one friend's son and I got a long great and then BAM! He was a jerk :) He has few friends, and the same with the tv and computer. Perhaps you can ask him if he would be interested in becoming a mentor to a younger child...it sounds strange, but my friend had a baby, and since then, he son has REALLY done a 90 ;) he still is crappy around her and some close friends, but he is GREAT with the baby. Perhaps he just needs someone to have a positive affect on. I know when I am feeling like I am a waste of space and no one cares that I live or die, it always helps to know that 'we' are making a positive for someone else. See if he would be interested in volunteering at a zoo or at a humane society. You would be surprised how teenagers, when given 'responsibility' will turn around. Good Luck
3 moms found this helpful
A.S. answers from Boca Raton on February 10, 2011
What would happen if you took all the TV's and computers out of the house?
Believe me, I know what a pain in the butt that would be for you and your husband, but I might be tempted to try it (can't believe I'm saying this because I'm addicted to my netbook).
Seriously, though, what would he do then? At least he'd have to read, or get up and go do something somewhere else.
Feel for you . . . hang in there.
3 moms found this helpful
S.H. answers from Honolulu on February 10, 2011
So even Counseling did not help?
Its not Depression?
Any peer problems or Bullying?
What does his Teacher say/think?
Does he have friends? Even if a few...
What are they like?
How is your relationship, with him?
Is there a relationship?
Or just acting in reaction to him kind of thing?
FIND another Counselor. Or a Therapist.
Or maybe it is a chemical imbalance....
Take him to the Doctor... or speak to the Doctor.
He seems so apathetic.
Was Depression ever considered?
How is his self-esteem?
Why only with adults, is he this way?
Does he feel judged?
Not perfect enough?
Lacking an Identity?
Lacking age appropriate social skills?
Developmental problems?
Was he always this way or only now?
I would seek another, Counselor or Therapist.
Not all are alike, nor will 'click' with a child.
3 moms found this helpful
P.M. answers from Honolulu on February 10, 2011
Oh wow, you must be so tired! First of all you should give yourself a pat on the back. There are so many parents who would have just looked the other way at this point and the fact that you've tried so many different things and not given up on your kid is a testament to your parenting; you should be proud of yourself.
It's always difficult to figure teens out. Do you just have a late bloomer (I mean on a maturity/emotional level) or is it something else? I know, if you knew this would be so much easier! You said you had him in counseling. Was it a psychiatrist or a therapist? He sounds like he could be suffering from clinical depression or some other issue, I would follow up with another psychiatrist if he's already been to one. Some of this just sounds like normal teenage boy stuff. Lot's of teens don't want to talk to their families and are defiant. How are the friends he does have? Are they rebels? Bad relationships with their families? He may be emulating to have common ground with them. Is he bullied in school? He may be rude as a defense.
I wish I had more advice, but it sounds like you are doing everything you can and eventually he will realize that he has a family that loves him and cares for him. Maybe see about summer camps focusing on computers or something else he really likes? Again, I would have him re-evaluated for depression. Keep up the great work momma, keeping a good thought for you!
2 moms found this helpful
P.G. answers from Dallas on February 11, 2011
Re-visit depression OFFICIALLY - the sentence "He doesn't have many friends, he doesn't go out, play sports nor is he in any extra curricular activities. ... yet he still just stays at home and stares at the computer, tv or sleeps." basically describes what happens when you are depressed.
Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
S.N. answers from Minneapolis on February 10, 2011
I don't have an answer to your question but did want to say that my BIL (when he was young) went to military school (trying to correct bad behavior)... and it got him into things MUCH worse that what he was doing before. So if it does ever become an option - please be cautious and REALLY do your research.
1 mom found this helpful
K.N. answers from Boston on February 10, 2011
Oh, sweetie --
I can't offer you any more wisdom, any additional tips or tricks. What I CAN offer is perspective. My second daughter was like your son, only with more drama. Ours is a (*ahem* clears throat) complex family situation. She was a mess for years. After years on the rollercoaster, there was a huge blow-up, she left to live with her "mother". I thought for sure we lost her. But things change, kids grow up and parents still love them. She's come a long way. So have we.
Two months ago we went together to choose her wedding dress. It was such a wonderful, wonderful day. And 12 years ago I never would have guessed we could get there.
I hope the same for you and for your family. One day, you will find yourself out the other side with your son. And you'll cry with happiness at how far you've all come.
Hang in.
1 mom found this helpful
A.S. answers from San Diego on February 10, 2011
Okay 2nd time writing response. Try tough love with a threat of emancipation. Sit down with him and draw up a legal and binding contract about the rules of the house. Get him to a psychologist and have them tell you what he needs. He might also need ant-depressants. Have his doctor do a D3 test on him as low levels can result in depression. More important if he holds you responsible for all his wrong doings I think a contract that is legal and binding would be a great idea, that way you can all come up with the rules and all be held accountable. He might wake up then knowing that he could have severe consequences to his actions. You could take the door to his room away and tell him that when he starts to shape up he gets certain priveleges back such as his door, computer, anything else. Good Luck.
1 mom found this helpful
Email