M.D. asks from Crowley, TX on September 08, 2007
My 6 Yo's Mouth and Attitude Is Driving Me Crazy!
Hi moms! Lately my 6 yo has an attitude that is out of control. If she doesnt get her way she flops in the floor screaming and yelling at me. She tells me no all the time! If sent to her room, she stomps and bangs things the whole way there! I dont know what to do. I feel bad when its the weekend and she could be out playing with friends, instead, (like right now) she is in her room crying. (and complaining that her bed feels weird and she cant lay in it) What punishments do you use and at what point? Take away tv, computer?? At this age how long should the punishment last? I try to ignore it sometimes but I dont think thats the right thing either. I will not allow her to talk to me this way- but I dont know how to control it. If my husband is home he steps in and straightens her up, but I need to be in control of this. (He is not home most of the time) She wouldnt dare talk to him this way. Any advice is greatly appreciated!
3 moms found this helpful
Featured Answers
B.H. answers from Dallas on September 09, 2007
Have you heard of the book: "Love and Logic"? As a teacher, I know it is well respected and I know parents of young children that also use it.
More Answers
A.H. answers from Dallas on September 09, 2007
My 7 yo son has attitude and a mouth, but I do not tolerate it one bit. We talk a lot about respect in our house, and I think putting it back on them sometimes makes them see it more clearly. Sometimes I'll mimic the way he just spoke to me, and ask if he likes hearing it, like being on the other side of the fence. Kids are so self-centered that they have to be told how ugly they sound! It's such a shame we mothers have to put up with so much.
I have realized that when things get ugly, however, it's actually time to step up the love. Often times my son is just acting out because we haven't spent much quality time together. Have you and DD done anything special lately? Plan something FUN, or just spend some time being silly with her, letting her know that you have 2 sides - the fun, loving side and the parental, authoritative side. Sometimes kids push back simply because they don't want to follow our rules ("just because") but when they know and feel our genuine love, then they understand that there are boundaries to their behavior. If you are constantly reminding her of her negative behavior, then that's all she's going to play in her head, that she's bad and you're mean. She'll resent you, you'll resent her, and the groundwork for some real mental issues are laid. Have you tried rewards, instead of punishment? Sometimes a simple play on words is like magic. Instead of telling her she can't play outside because she misbehaved, tell her she CAN play outside if she shows improvement in her attitude. Whatever you do, don't forget praise and love.
1 mom found this helpful
D.W. answers from Dallas on September 09, 2007
My daughter is 5 going on 20 too. When she gets out of line:
1. If we are in public, whatever it is we were doing stops right there. It can be disappointing and inconvenient but she gets the message real quick.
2. At home, she goes to her room to cool down. Usually about 5 minutes. I'll check on her and if she's calmed down we talk about what happened. I ask her "Why did the fun stop?" or "WHy are we here?" If she's not ready or give an in appropriate answer and starts to throw a fit all over again, I let her cool down some more.
3. Then we talk about punishment. She knows the drill so well that she can now tell me what's going to happen. She'll say, "I thew a fit so no kid show" or computer or whatever. I have 3 or 4 things that I take away depending how big the fit was dictates how much I take away. Usually, I take it one day at a time on punishment, allowing her to start fresh the next day. Or if I took away more than one thing, she can earn them back with respectful behavior (not everything just one thing).
4. If I already know that a transition is going to be difficult (i.e. stopping the computer and going to the bath), I will talk about it before hand. "When I tell you its time to get off the computer, what are you going to do?" She is to say,"I will say yes Mama and do it." This helped immensely with things that, in the past, had been guaranteed to cause a tantrum.
I agree, also, that you should spend a lot of time doing fun things with your daughter. Usually misbehavior in our house happens for a couple of reasons. Either one or both of us is tired and not communicating well. Or my little girl is spending too much time with the TV and computer and not enough time with me or playing outside. Usually when she is punished, I take away the computer and TV. This not only makes her sad, it also forces me to spend some time playing pretend or a board game with her and that will almost always fix a communication breakdown for a long time.
Good Luck (I know you have your hands full)
M.W. answers from Dallas on September 09, 2007
This book has helped me:
http://www.amazon.com/Your-Six-Year-Old-Louise-Bates-Ames...
R.M. answers from Dallas on September 08, 2007
I acted like this until I was 16. My mom tried the whole grounding thing, she said it made me worse and started some form of depression in me. I would be careful with that. Thats all I can really give you on it. I know that I was out of control until I was 16. Then my mom gave up and let me do whatever. I had rules like, if you come home drunk and puke on the floor, clean it up yourself. I wouldn't suggest giving up. I was pregnant a year later. I like the idea of supernanny. I've watched her show and that woman does amazing things. I wish my mom would have done something like that with me. Haha! My mom and I are best friend's now and I love her to death but thats because I was forced to grow up and I started to understand that everything she was doing was for a reason. Maybe talking it out with your daughter could help? Try to put her on a level with you. "Would you appreciate me talking to you like this?" Good luck, I feel for my mom all the time for putting up with my attitude for 12 years and I'm sorry you're having a hard time! Hopefully its a faze she'll grow out of!
L.A. answers from Dallas on September 08, 2007
My child isn't that old yet... but I love to watch the Super Nanny (Jo Frost) and how she handles these same situations. She has written some books that I hear are wonderful, they were both New York Times bestsellers.
"Supernanny: How to Get the Best from Your Children"
"Ask Supernanny: What Every Parent Wants to Know"
I understand your frustration to a small degree... my son listens to my husband, but not me! I definately think she is old enough to know better and have tv and computer taken away from her. I teach 6 year olds, and sometimes, you just have to be firm and unmovable in your discipline.
L.N. answers from Dallas on September 10, 2007
Another good book is The 5 Love Languages. I believe they have one for marriage and children. But they are all the same. It helps you learn what your child reacts to. Do they like materialistic things, hugs, compliments, time with you, etc. Everyone responds to discipline differently. Where one of my children really does not care if I take his toys away, but if I don't hug him and show I am dissapointed in him it hurts more. If I have learned anything it is that every child is different. My sister and I where raised the same but acted out very differently because of the outcome. I hope you figure out what works for you. L.
B.H. answers from Dallas on September 09, 2007
Have you heard of the book: "Love and Logic"? As a teacher, I know it is well respected and I know parents of young children that also use it.
A.W. answers from Knoxville on September 09, 2007
She dares to talk to you this way because she gets away with it. My daughter went through the same thing not too long ago. We tried the positive reinforcements, sticker charts, etc. Worked for a day, maybe. Then right back to it. So...
She got grounded to her room. The length of time varied with the behavior. Lots of times, it was just for the morning, but a few times, she earned all day long. And that's how I put it to her...you have now earned X because of your behavior. And I made sure to go in and talk to her so that she understood why she was there, and that if she is going to choose to speak to people that way or treat people that way, then she just can't be around people. That's not how people treat each other.
It lasted a few weeks. And she is now a joy to be around. She occasionally regresses a touch, and she goes straight to her room, no questions, no comments -- for about 5 minutes to get her back on track.
It's worked for us, and we're all much happier -- even though, yes, it was really, really rotten going through it. There were several days that I just went into my room and cried. But -- seeing her now, it's worth it.
Good luck.
Email