E.W. asks from Winter Park, FL on September 24, 2007
My 10Yr Old Is Failing School and Will Not Read Books at Home
I need some advice. Recently my 10 yr old step son cam to live with us full time. He is a great kid and he came from a very happy home- he just decided that it was time to come live with his dad and I. He was on Stratera for ADD until this school year when my husband and I decided to take hime off of it. He was a total zombie on it. He was doing so well until recently. He started to forget his homework at school and forget to do projects. Now he is failing social studies and reading. Until his grades are better we have restricted everything. The thing is he will not read any books that we buy him to occupy his time after school. He cries and says that he doesn't like to read. There is no particular reason why- he just hates it. Getting him to read is a huge ordeal. I really don't want to put him on ADD medicine. Is he just a typical 10yr old boy or does he need to go back on his meds?
-Liz
Featured Answers
J.J. answers from Orlando on September 25, 2007
Hi,
Unfortunately, I do understand what you are going through. My ten year old stepson has been battling ADHD since I met his dad five years ago. My husbands family has basically denied there was a problem until I took him to the doctor to be screened and he verified he does ave it. He has barely passed school so far because my husband didn't want him on medication. We had no choice but to start him on Ridlin. It is amazing the difference. His personality hasn't changed at all, but he can focus on school and get his work done. I don't like to medicate him , but I think we were unfair to him not to. He has a medical problem that needed to be treated and we were denying him that and getting upset with him for not getting school work done. That was more unfair to him, I think, than giving him the medicaton and letting him do his best.
More Answers
J.P. answers from Orlando on September 25, 2007
E.,
Talk to a doctor and then talk with a councelor. Both private (tutoring) and at his school.
I HATED reading when I was younger and still find myself struggling with books. I'm 26. I lose thought. It takes to long. I can't clear my mind long enough to focus on the words. I get confused on the characters. ect. Some may find this silly or think less of me but you know, it's true. I had to work 3 times as hard in school as most others because of reading. Especially in college.
Perhaps he is feeling some of the same stuff without saying it. Maybe he can't pinpoint why he doesn't like it. I liked my mom reading to me, but not being left with a book. It was boring and unstimulating. If he is unstimulated, this will cause negative feels to flurish.
Maybe don't punish him so much and set times for things so he understands his place. He comes home from school, has a snack, does his homework. Goes and plays outside. Comes in. Reads a few chapters of his book until dinner. Gets to watch tv after dinner. (just a for instance) _ i know easier said than done.
Also, something that bothers me:
My husband had ADD and his parents were told he probably wouldn't graduate high school. So, they never expected anything from him and basically treated him as a disappointment (not that you would ever do that)and tried to force him to do things he didn't want to.
He did end up graduating by a night program, but the fact of the matter was he stunk in english and excelled in science and math, therein was the problem. He is now a firefighter paramedic! He does complex math equations in his head on a regular basis to administer drugs and to use the fire truck.
He is a wonderful and brilliant. He knows everything about computers (he fixes plenty of them) builds websites, can cut a hole out of a solid wall and install french doors with no manual nor having done it before, ect.
So, you step son will have to fight himself, and the negativity that may surround him with the ADD issue.
Just know, the more you force it, the less he's likely to do, unless you are there reading it with him.
Best of luck,
J.
p.s. does he like writing? I love writing and still hate reading. Odd eh?
1 mom found this helpful
D.E. answers from Fort Myers on September 25, 2007
Dear Liz,
I would suggest that you and your husband find time to read to him. Whatever book you've purchased or even what his required reading may be for school can be used to spend quality time while you read to him aloud. He may have some unknown difficulty getting through the pages (so many kids have trouble in that area and it goes undetected for years) while continuing to excel in school. Be enthusiastic and find work that truly builds his/your foundational truths while entertaining his soul, which will cause him to look forward to more READING! Let him express his thoughts, concerns, emotions, etc., as you journey through the pages of some delightful reads and throw your own perpective in to guide him along his way. Children need closeness and conversation to keep them opened up and as they head toward the teen years, so this may be a wonderful avenue to keep it going!
Another idea might be to have your stepson read aloud to your little girl each day. Let him pick a cute book for her so he'll feel highly involved. It's a quiet, interactive discipline that expands the imagination and builds closeness. Hope you are encouraged as things improve.
1 mom found this helpful
C.M. answers from Melbourne on September 25, 2007
Hello!
My 10-year-old boy does not have ADD, but doesn't like to read either. That is, until you put a comic book in his hands. They actually have very big words, that he figures out on his own cause he wants to get to the end of the book. And he reads them over and over again. Maybe you could buy one at the bookstore, just to see, then order him a subscription if he likes it. You know, as a treat for something. Every month he'll be waiting by the mailbox. (They have that soap-opera continue-on thing.)
Hope this helps.
C.
1 mom found this helpful
A.A. answers from Orlando on September 24, 2007
I have a 6 year old that has ADHD. Before he was diagnoised with it, he had some of the same issues. He did not want to do his work, having issues with listening in school, etc. His teacher actually suggested we take him to the doctor, which we had a clue what was wrong anyways. My husband has ADHD and has had it since he was little. When we put him on meds(which we didn't want to do but did it for him) he turned around 100%. We are still worried about the meds and what might happen, but it helps him so much. He's on Adderall right now. I did try a new medication this summer, that is supposed to be better than Adderall and Stratera and not supposed to make them drowzy. I loved the medicine, but since it is new, my insurance did not want to cover it at a price that we could afford every month, so we went back to the Adderall. The other medicine last all day(well pretty much up until bed time and is not as much as a stimulant than Adderall and the others). If you do decide to put him back on the meds, ask your doctor to give you a trial month of the new medicine, they gave us the 1st month totally free to see if it worked better. Its called Vyvanse(Vi-Vance). Like I said its a little pricy as it is still a non-prefered drug since it just came out in June, and its close to $200 a month without insurance :( With my insurance it was like $50 a month, compaired to his Adderall at $10 a month. I plan on getting him back on it though as soon as I can get some more income coming back on. Its hard to take care of a family of 6(well almost) on one income, but it was so worth the spending the extra money for it. Just a thought if you decide to try meds again :) Good luck!
S.S. answers from Fort Myers on September 25, 2007
hi Liz:
i also have a ten year old whos been diagnosed with ADD i took him off his meds when we moved to here its a rough road but i also have ADD (undiagnosed till i was 12 also had a slew of other learning problems to go with it that fortunatly he didn't get) but i have noticed down here that the teachers while willing to accept that the child does have ADD dont really know what to do with an unmedicated child. as far as the reading goes i would give him a broad choice mabey take him to the library and see what happens he may surprise you my son is easily bored with the reading matterial offered to him for kids his age he tends to read fifth and six grade books right now hes into the hardy boys. i really never had a hard time getting him to read (cause its an escape for him) just trying to get him to focus all day at school i had to teach him little tricks...like if he does all his class work before the other kids he has a special note book just for drawing. my biggest problem is writing he hates it more and more every year he barely writes anything and for the state test theres a 45 min writing test...so now were working on that...just take a deep breath and enjoy him for the wonderful little soul he is he may need more hands on with reading good luck.
S.
J.J. answers from Orlando on September 25, 2007
Hi,
Unfortunately, I do understand what you are going through. My ten year old stepson has been battling ADHD since I met his dad five years ago. My husbands family has basically denied there was a problem until I took him to the doctor to be screened and he verified he does ave it. He has barely passed school so far because my husband didn't want him on medication. We had no choice but to start him on Ridlin. It is amazing the difference. His personality hasn't changed at all, but he can focus on school and get his work done. I don't like to medicate him , but I think we were unfair to him not to. He has a medical problem that needed to be treated and we were denying him that and getting upset with him for not getting school work done. That was more unfair to him, I think, than giving him the medicaton and letting him do his best.
A.L. answers from Melbourne on September 24, 2007
I agree with everything that Tammi said and would add one thing. Although he came to live with you as his own choice, it is still a big change in his life. Transition and change are harder for these children and going off meds would multiply that. It is important to help him find reading material thagt he likes and can find relevence. Also, there are lots of books in the library about parenting children with ADD/ADHD. You will need a consistent routine, a reward system, opposed to removing priviliges. Their self esteem is lower and restricting everything could have more of a negative impact. Also, remember to pick your battles. My daughter has bipolar disorder and ADHD, so I know how difficult it can be. Keep a journal on behaviors and moods and patterns of grades to help you find triggers that you might be able to remove. Putting a child on medicine does not make you a bad parent hen it is truly for thier well being. (I had a hard time accepting that, but it's true). Okay I said I only had one thing to add, sorry.
A.S. answers from Melbourne on September 25, 2007
I agree he probaly does not need medication. He is just having trouble reading. My friend has a business that can help him through fun learning on the computer. Its called advantageU learning. Her name is Bonnie Brooks and she is so kind and patient. Her number is ###-###-#### ____@____.com
Tell her A. recommended you.
Email