K.W. asks from Anchorage, AK on October 27, 2006
Mother of 9 Month Old and Also 2 Months Pregnant
I just want a little advice on handling my 9-month-old daughter's potty training. I would really like to get her potty trained before baby #2 is born in June. She doesn't walk yet so I guess it's too early to start? Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated!
So What Happened?™
Thank you everyone for all your advice and thoughts. I have read all of the responses, and I agree with all of you. I will wait until she starts showing some signs. Hopefully it's sooner rather than later. :) I will buy her a potty chair just so she can get used to it and I will also buy that book that was recommended. Thanks again!
Featured Answers
Y.G. answers from Las Vegas on October 29, 2006
I have 16 month old twins. Having two in diapers is a breeze. I'm definitely waiting until THEY decide they want to potty train, because although diapers are expensive, to me, they are so much easier than potty training and accidents.
C.B. answers from Provo on October 29, 2006
That sounds like a fairytale! I have heard stories of babies being potty trained at 14 to 18 mos, but gosh I dont know, that sounds great but eeekkks... I had one that wasnt ready till he was 3! Some babies are ready for stuff like that early but not always. You will have to see if she is ready, if so she will train well and if she isnt ready she wont.
All children train different; rewards, grown up, mommydaddy does it, what ever method you decide to use, the thing that has worked best for me and all my friends that had kids when I did was consistancy, remember accidents happen and they are not a dicipline issue.
Receintly I was in the mall bathroom and the mom was asking a girl why she pottied her pants withiout asking mom to take her to the bathroom and the little girl very sweetly and consideratly of her mom said you were busy and I didnt want to bother you!
More Answers
H.J. answers from Pocatello on October 28, 2006
K.-Most children potty train at age three. Fortunatly girls do train easier and sooner. BUT..consider this. It really is easier to have two children in diapers at first...think about taking a stroller into those little stalls with your potty trainer, think about having to rush everything to get to a toilet for a potty trainer, think about all the extra laundry you are already going to be faced with...relax and let her take her time. Two in diapers isn't really so bad.
H.
1 mom found this helpful
K.O. answers from Portland on October 30, 2006
I have to agree with others on this... It's too soon. I know diapers are expensive, but if you try to push your daughter into doing something she's not ready for you're just going to prolong the process.
C.S. answers from Las Vegas on October 29, 2006
Hi K.,
My feeling is 9 months is way to early to expect her to potty train. Most babies potty train at about 2 years old when they have a better understanding of what they are doing and can appreciate your positive response. I tried to potty train my daughter at exactly two and she just screemed everytime I put her on the toddler pot, so I waited 6 months and she trained with little problem. Good luck.
C.B. answers from Provo on October 29, 2006
That sounds like a fairytale! I have heard stories of babies being potty trained at 14 to 18 mos, but gosh I dont know, that sounds great but eeekkks... I had one that wasnt ready till he was 3! Some babies are ready for stuff like that early but not always. You will have to see if she is ready, if so she will train well and if she isnt ready she wont.
All children train different; rewards, grown up, mommydaddy does it, what ever method you decide to use, the thing that has worked best for me and all my friends that had kids when I did was consistancy, remember accidents happen and they are not a dicipline issue.
Receintly I was in the mall bathroom and the mom was asking a girl why she pottied her pants withiout asking mom to take her to the bathroom and the little girl very sweetly and consideratly of her mom said you were busy and I didnt want to bother you!
J.S. answers from Salt Lake City on October 30, 2006
Well, I've heard rumors of the "New Age Diaper less Living" but only rumors, I dont know, I felt strongly for my son to wait until he was ready, I didnt know what the signs of being ready looked like, but I bought a trainer toilet, set it in the hall just to store for a while until I saw "the signs" and one day around his second birthday, there was a poop in the toilet, I bought the book "Potty train your child in Just One Day" almost as a joke to see what they had to say, I followed the directions and No Joke, He was potty trained in Just One Day, He never ever had an accident, but that was just our case. I had a friend who bragged about his son being potty trained when he was 9 months old, he said his child goes potty and poop in the toilet but just kept having accidents, hummmmm, doesnt sound trained to me, mom & dad just didnt hold him over the toilet in time, I think it was the parents who were trained really, now the child is 12 yrs old and still has accidents, maybe they have expected too much out of him in all areas of life. So when ever you feel is time for your child to start, good luck, but when you do, that book did work for me. I would suggest if you do get the book, read it cover to cover and follow the directions fully, there are prep days before the "Big Day"
Congratulations on the new arrival.
Happy Training.
Y.G. answers from Las Vegas on October 29, 2006
I have 16 month old twins. Having two in diapers is a breeze. I'm definitely waiting until THEY decide they want to potty train, because although diapers are expensive, to me, they are so much easier than potty training and accidents.
H.J. answers from Los Angeles on October 28, 2006
while I admire your enthusiasm. Honestly a nine month old, can't get herself on the potty in fact she can't even tell you she has to go... there is hope, both my kids took an interest in potty training around 16 months an were almost totally done by 2 so there is hope. I had 2 in diapers for a while too, but it's not so bad, you'll survive.... And most likely it'll only bee for a few months anyway. By the way congratulations on both your littel girl, and your new baby to come...
A.N. answers from Portland on October 29, 2006
I think I agree with most of the women below. My daughter turned two in July, and we've just started wearing "big girl panties" all day long... I have another baby on the way, and actually wish they were going to both be in diapers! Potty training her was a breeze, because we didn't push it, we waited until she was ready, and now she is and there is never a fight about it. She hardly ever has accidents and the experience has just been gradually pleasant for all of us. However, if we had tried to get her potty trained at 9 months, even one and a half (for my daughters case), it would have been a total nightmare. I would suggest just following your daughters lead. Take her to the bathroom with you, "show" her that you're going "pee-pee" (or whatever you want to call it, and have her show you when she's ready. You'll know she's getting close when she wants to flush the toilet for you, or try's to climb up on the potty herself. My daughter even started telling us she was going "poo-poo", we knew then she was getting really close, as she was associating her bowel movements.
Hope some of this kind of helps, don't worry about two in diapers, worry about one small one and rushing off to find a bathroom at a grocery store, and then one having an accident in the cart all over your groceries....it happens ;)
Email