A.P. asks from Olathe, KS on February 10, 2008
Make 7 Year Old Clean Her Room?
Hi,
I'm wondering if I should make my 7 year old daughter clean her room. She's a compliant kid, very mature for her age (only child), and I have taught her a sense of family belonging in that she pitches in with household chores--inside and out. I give her an allowance to teach her money management, but I don't tie her allowance into her chores. She knows she has to help simply because she's part of the family. The only thing I've been doing with her room, is saying that she can't have playmates over unless her room is clean. When she's okay with no friends over, she leaves her room a mess. I was just wondering if I should get more strict on her personal space. Outside of her room, she's neat, organized and helpful. What do you guys think?
So What Happened?™
Thank you everyone for your advice! I really like the daily schedule with a 10 minute timer for room cleaning. (She's so compliant, I thought, "Why not?") It has kept her room from turning into the disaster zone she's use to working with, and she loves that her room is so quick and easy to clean now. She sees the advantage, and I thank all of you smart moms who helped me with this decision. Advice for you all: do something nice for yourself today--we moms deserve it. :)
Featured Answers
A.V. answers from St. Louis on February 11, 2008
I think she is old enough to clean her room. If you are thinking of having her do this, here is a neat tool that may help with not only her room but introducing other responsibilities around the house.
I've never personally used it, but have heard a lot of good things about it.
1 mom found this helpful
S.H. answers from Wichita on February 11, 2008
Go for it! Everyone should learn (in my opinion) to maintain a clean and tidy personal living space. It creates a feeling of self worth and discipline. If you feel that she can do it without argument and is responsible enough, which it sounds like she is, then you have nothing to lose and everything to gain. Good luck!
--S.
More Answers
A.V. answers from St. Louis on February 11, 2008
I think she is old enough to clean her room. If you are thinking of having her do this, here is a neat tool that may help with not only her room but introducing other responsibilities around the house.
I've never personally used it, but have heard a lot of good things about it.
1 mom found this helpful
A.M. answers from St. Louis on February 11, 2008
Hi A.!
I second A. V's suggestion... I actually DO use www.housefairy.org and my children LOVE it! I love it too, because I don't nag AT ALL, and they actually WANT to clean their rooms!! Go check it out... it's been life-changing for us! :-)
Good luck!
A. M
K.D. answers from Columbia on February 11, 2008
With my boys, 6 & 10, I treat their room as their personal space...with a few requirements. 1) They are required to make their beds every morning, 2) The path way on the floor from their bed to the door must be clear for safety reasons (think middle of the night trips to the bathroom), 3) They need to do a "10 minute clean up" every weekend. We set the timer for 10 minutes and they spend the time cleaning up as much as they can before the timer goes off. Sometimes I will ask them what they hope to get clean in that time. Sometimes not. This seems to work well with both my "neat freak" kid and my packrat/disorganized child. Hope this helps!
J.C. answers from Kansas City on February 11, 2008
By all means, she should be responsible for a clean room. But make sure it is not overwhelming for her. Simply saying "clean your room" isn't enough. You need to either make a list for her or specifically state what you expect. For example, put toys away, books need to be on shelf, make bed, or put clothing in drawers. Breaking it down into manageable "tasks" will make it a whole lot easier for her. I have older daughters and having a list has helped alot(even since they were younger). I set saturday aside for the day to tidy their rooms. They can keep it how they want during the week(and I don't nag-this takes much self control on my part) BUT they know that one
day a week, they need to clean.
C.S. answers from St. Louis on February 13, 2008
I think you're handling everything wonderfully! Telling her she can't have friends over if her room's a mess is, I think, the way to go. It would become a battle, perhaps, to keep insisting if she's okay with no friends over. Should a big event arise -- major extended family coming over -- I'd explain well in advance that she'll need her room super clean by such-and-such a date and time, and then set up consequences IF that doesn't happen. Otherwise, I'd let her keep her personal space the way she wants it and avoid power struggles. I haven't been that wise and ended up with major power struggles on my hands by insisting my 10-year-old (a defiant child) keep her room clean. And why??? It's only caused the whole household nothing but grief, and I'm losing the war. So, please don't turn it into a war the way I did.
S.H. answers from St. Louis on February 11, 2008
I see nothing wrong with asking her to keep her room clean. It doesn't have to be spotless at all times. But keeping the bed made, dirty clothes picked up, no dirty dishes in the room, etc is a good idea.
R.R. answers from Topeka on February 11, 2008
Yes, she needs to know that if she does not clean her room there will be no allowance at the end of the week, or no house guests, or priviliges. You have to make it clear to her what you want from her and the rest will be up to her.
I was a single parent and never got my daughters dad to agree with me on anything, but here is what I did with my daughter. I would deduct money out of her allowance for each task she did not complete at the end of the week. This worked very well. When you start taking her allowance away maybe, just maybe, she will realize that if she does not clean her room (along with her other chores)she will have no allowance or priviliges.
S.H. answers from Wichita on February 11, 2008
Go for it! Everyone should learn (in my opinion) to maintain a clean and tidy personal living space. It creates a feeling of self worth and discipline. If you feel that she can do it without argument and is responsible enough, which it sounds like she is, then you have nothing to lose and everything to gain. Good luck!
--S.
Email