S.F. asks from Keego Harbor, MI on December 07, 2008
Looking for a Humidifier
Looking to purchase a humidifier to help with coughs and colds. Someone recommended a cool mist, I had one last year but it didn't work very well and left white residue all over stuff. I looked today and not sure what I really need, warm vs cool mist, filter vs no filter, germ free...Any recommendations? Thanks
More Answers
J.B. answers from Detroit on December 08, 2008
An awesome one is by Venta. It's expensive, about $130, but doesn't need cleaning, is cool mist and works great.
S.S. answers from Saginaw on December 13, 2008
I highly recommend the VICKS brand cool mist, as did a few others I see. They come in a few price ranges, all depending on how big of water resevoir. Our last one lasted about 3 years, being run 24/7 in our bedroom from November-April. I just refilled it once a day and bought additive stuff [ KAZ- which is specially formulated for VICKS humidifers] to keep mold/mildew out of water tank, ya add a capful each time ya refill, or in my case I did this once a week. [ bottle cost approx $6.00]. Filters can be bought anywhere they sell the humidifer. The motor runs quiet enough to provide white noise. I bought a Huntington brand from Walmart and HATED IT about 2 weeks ago as a 2nd humidfer for another bedroom and that did not even make it 3 days. It was noisy [ had water dripping sound constantly]. I highly recommend VICKS and only vICKS!!!!! Just my 2 cents.
E.W. answers from Detroit on December 08, 2008
I went through about 5 humidifiers before I found one that I loved. I had 2 different kinds of Holmes cool mists and three kinds of Vicks cool mist. The Holmes barely worked - it took them almost a week to empty the water tank. And the Vicks ones did not work at all - even after working with customer service and adding salt - nothing!
Then I got a Crane ULTRASONIC Humidifier (the froggy one:) from Target (they sell them other stores too). It worked perfectly right out of the box - you can see the mist right away. We've been using it for a month now and I love it.
***By the way - the ultrasonic humidifier mist is cool to the touch.
S.C. answers from Detroit on December 08, 2008
We have a Vicks warm mist (~$35), and it works well and helps with conjestion/coughs. It also holds enough water for all night in a small to mid-sized room. It requires weekly cleaning, but has no filter or anything - just soaking to remove scale and disinfect.
We had a Duracraft that did not work well, and we returned.
We just purchased a more expensive ionic (~$90) that requires less cleaning (baby #2 is on the way). I can't comment on how well it works yet!
M.D. answers from Detroit on December 08, 2008
I purchased for $30. the vicks cool mist vaporizer from Rite Aid along with three filters for $6. My now 15 month old has used it on and off since he was about 3 months old. It's still working very well and seems to do the job. I just rinse it out every other night and make sure to keep changing the filter every 4-5 weeks.
I initially was unsure about cool vs. warm mist too. Especially since I felt that warm would make sense in the winter. Apparently cool mist is the better way to go, I forget why though.
Hope this helps.
Email