J.W. asks from Saint Louis, MO on September 27, 2012
Lets Talk About Sex Baby!.....
Okay, I really didn't expect in this day and age that the cow milk theory is still accepted but after reading a few responses last night I guess it is.
To see comments like women who have sex after a few dates don't value themselves is shocking. Last time I checked it takes two people to have sex, both have chosen. Does that mean there are countless men out there that don't value themselves either? Poor men, all us women using them. :p
So my question is how many people actually buy into the idea that we do not control our bodies?
Ahh the cow milk theory was my moms idea of sex ed, a man will not buy the cow if he can get the milk for free. In other words the sum of a woman's value is her ability to hold sex over a man's head.
So What Happened?™
Victoria, I think she was more about I will control my body but you flip the bill.
Heather, the idea that a woman cannot choose to sleep with a man when she wants to sleep with a man. It seems that people want to attribute the choice of when we have sex on something other than free will. Like people that "value themselves" wouldn't choose to have sex?
Molly, I am not saying there is nothing wrong with one night stands, it is just we chose not to. If you for some reason chose to have a one night stand, for whatever reason, would it be because suddenly you have low self esteem or because that particular guy didn't make your skin crawl?
Theresa, it does come from both sides. I think it is frustrating because for whatever reason each side feels they should demean the other side to defend theirs. Like the "don't value" comment, could it not equally be thrown at those that wait as in the carrot stick? What does any of that gain for women in general.
Featured Answers
B.K. answers from Chicago on September 27, 2012
For Alexis..
Why buy the cow when you can get the milk for free (in reference to marriage). I like the pig sausage theory.... Why buy the whole pig when all you really want is a piece of sausage?
11 moms found this helpful
D.F. answers from Boston on September 27, 2012
Ha!!! I could not wait to get my husband......he wanted me too!! I did not think he was easy or a slut. Ya he got the milk for free because I gave it to him! Been together for over 17 years. I think I fell in love the first time I looked at him. I let him know he was wanted!
3 moms found this helpful
☆.H. answers from San Francisco on September 27, 2012
The trouble is that there are guys out there who were raised believing the cow milk theory. They still want sex just as much as the next guy and will seek it out, but then lose respect for the woman/talk about her in the locker room etc. It can give a girl a bad rep.
The cow and milk theory is and has always been a myth. People still had sex outside of marriage in the olden days. It's just that back then there was the "You broke it you bought it" theory. (you know, shotgun weddings!)
3 moms found this helpful
More Answers
S.T. answers from Washington DC on September 27, 2012
well, i think there's a substantive difference between a strong, healthy confident woman who enjoys sexual relationships because she's honoring her own libido and fully in charge of what and who and how goes on with satisfying it, and a woman who is depressed or insecure and desperate to do whatever she thinks necessary to trap some love into her life.
i have been both of those women.
i do think the paradigm is changing, and it's so important that we keep the conversation alive and active with girls and young women, so that they DON'T buy into antiquated cow/milk theories, or that sexual desire is somehow inappropriate for females.
khairete
S.
20 moms found this helpful
B.. answers from Dallas on September 27, 2012
It's my opinion that a man dating a woman who is not even divorced yet, is not looking for anything but sex. (Are there exceptions to the rule, of course. However, there is the rule for a reason.) I DO think many woman (and men) who have sex so quickly, don't value what sex REALLY is. It's sharing, it's intimacy. Well, it's supposed to be. I think it's sad that we've devalued sex to an act with a stranger. I DO think sex should mean more then that. It should mean more then a little score, because it feels good. I DO think it's a little disrespecting to ones body and person, to give sex to someone who you don't share something significant with. I DO think it's sad that people give away the most intimate act a human can give, to someone because they look good. I think sex as a physical act within a loving, and respected relationship...is completely different. I think there IS a reason for so many unintended pregnancies, STDs, and sexual hangups. And, I think a lot of that comes from the disappointment and disillusionment that can result from sex being handed out like a business card. Do some people go on to have healthy relationships after sleeping with a person right away? Sure! Again, exception to the rule. Most are left alone (again.) Most people move on and don't share anything significant with a person.
I updated my answer to that question, to include I would say the same thing to a man. It just so happens, that it was a woman asking this time. YES, we Do have control over our bodies. The thing is, people rarely use that control. They usually do NOT control their bodies, and do whatever the heck they feel like doing, or sounds good at the time. That doesn't sound "in control" to me. That's reducing something to some feelings here and there, and justifying it with "empowerment" cliches. We love sex, I know I do. That doesn't mean it should become this thing, that's fun to do, so hey...let's give it up to just anyone, I mean it's fun...right? It has nothing to do with marriage. it has everything to do with placing VALUE on something that should HAVE value.
I guess I feel like sex SHOULD mean something. No, I don't feel like it can mean a whole lot with a person you hardly know anything about. And yes, I would say all of this to a man. I don't care about gender.
Just my opinion, and I realize I might be an island.
12 moms found this helpful
B.K. answers from Chicago on September 27, 2012
For Alexis..
Why buy the cow when you can get the milk for free (in reference to marriage). I like the pig sausage theory.... Why buy the whole pig when all you really want is a piece of sausage?
11 moms found this helpful
R.J. answers from Seattle on September 27, 2012
Oy!!! I had the opposite be true back when I was catting around: marriage proposals left and right. Never got the cow thing.
I valued myself as much when I was a total slitch sleeping with anything that moved / could trip a man and beat him to the ground.... As I do now that I'm (deep sigh) frustratingly celibate for the foreseeable future. I'm just doing things differently.
The ONLY places respect fall into (for ME) are:
- Not breaking my vows (vows are super important to me, as are other lesser promises. For ME the vows are about me, not him. I couldn't respect myself if I broke them).
- Whether I'm tomcatting or waiting... That my choice be respected as the sovereign / CEO of me' own self!!! My body. My choices. My rules.
(Inverse is true as well. I've dated men who were waiting when I was catting. I needed to respect that or not date them. Ditto if I dated men who were catting when I'm waiting. Mutual. Respect. If we can't honor both Pur own and our partners choices... We shouldn't be together.)
Just the way I see it.
My body, my choice.
Your body, your choice.
Aretha Franklin.
10 moms found this helpful
H.P. answers from Houston on September 27, 2012
I want to participate here, but I don't understand your question, J.. What does "we do not control our bodies" mean? Maybe I'm just still asleep this morning.
By the way, I was just reading that post about the almost-divorced mother wanting to have sex. I have always been a person who did it because I wanted to do it. I know me, though. I don't get all caught up emotionally unless I want to. Sometimes--even with my husband--it is strictly physical...and then back to business. When I was single, I was the one saying, "Hey, wait a minute--we're not a couple; don't change the rules on me."
ETA: Sex is what it is for the person/people having it. As long as they are consenting adults, we don't get to say what it SHOULD BE for others. We don't get to say what somebody else's marriage should be. The sexual experience is a journey in that it is different for everybody and at different stages of our lives. Sex for me today is not what it was when I was 20...or 28...or 35. Hell, today's sex for me isn't the same as last year's sex. My point is that NO ONE can tell us what it should be for us. The most that our loved ones can do is to encourage us to have HEALTHY sexualities, and that will almost always mean going against someone's grain to get a handle on it. How many of us could have become good and confident parents if someone were standing over us directing our every move? There probably aren't many GOOD drivers who haven't had to slow down from a (relatively) high speed. This whole life is a journey, and where we are sexually at every turn tends to reflect how things are going. This doesn't necessarily include intercourse at every turn, but...our thoughts and feelings, confidence.... It's all connected, and the best that we can do for each other is help each other to be healthy individuals and avoid presuming the right to determine whether it is good/right or bad/wrong.
I've had one-night stands. You wanna know why? I wanted to, period. It wasn't a lifestyle, and some I would undo. That's part of life. I learned from those experiences. I never looked down on myself. I always used condoms and stayed up on my check-ups. I also stayed on the pill as back-up. Oh, I enjoyed my 20s...getting to know myself and a good handle on how the world works. Some stuff you don't recognize or know how to navigate through unless you've stepped right in it once or twice. Journey.
Oh, and PPS: I refused to commit BEFORE sex because I didn't even want to get that far without knowing if we were at least compatible.
10 moms found this helpful
T.S. answers from San Francisco on September 27, 2012
Suz T said it perfectly!
And for what it's worth, I had sex with my husband on our first date. I didn't know he was going to become my husband I just knew he was hot! We will celebrate our 20th wedding anniversary this November :)
10 moms found this helpful
M.F. answers from Portland on September 27, 2012
I don't think it is a case of not having control or not valuing yourself.
To me, having sex with someone you hardly know is just gross.
You have no idea if the person is actually healthy (people lie).
You have no idea what their hygiene is like, just cause they shower for dates doesn't mean anything.
You have no idea if they are seeing anyone else, maybe even married.
I just think before I get naked with someone and allow them to touch my most private and personal areas, I want to know a LOT about them first.
I am not a wait until marriage kind of person, I believe in taking the car for a test drive before you buy it.
I am not a old fashioned person.
But, I do get skeeved out by people jumping into bed with people they don't know very well.
And I am talking about women AND men.
10 moms found this helpful
E.T. answers from Albuquerque on September 27, 2012
I'm with you. I don't see a correlation between having sex on the first date and not valuing ourselves. We're all adults. If someone wants to have six on the first or ten millionth date, it's her decision. Who am I to say it indicates how well she values herself, or whether the man will stay with her? I think it devalues women more to say that once a man has had sex he'll wander away. There's a lot more to a relationship than sex!
8 moms found this helpful
Email