14 answers

Leeching Friend

One of my best friends has an out of control 3 year old who spits, pulls hair, pushes, screams and cusses. The disipline factor isnt there, & I'm not sure how to tactfully tell her, her child can be an extreme menace, without her taking offense. (She's sensitive to any percieved negativity toward her child no matter how nicely you explain it)
Whenever there is an incident, she manages to find an excuse everytime for her son. "He hit because he felt threatened." "He's trying to be nice he's just such a big kid" etc. etc.
How can I approach this topic with her so I can keep my girls safe, and keep my friend ?

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

I have spoken to my friend. I was sympathetic but firm, explaining that my job was to look out for the safety & best interests of my family first & foremost, and that her son was basically endangering them everytime he was around us. She did understand, but was more than slighty defensive, however she has agreed that something needs to be done & that she will (and I'm welcome to) cut playdates or even visits short at the first sign of aggressiveness until her new disipline tactics and his behaviour improve. I used bits & pieces from everyones advice & am SO relieved that this issue has worked itself out the best I think it could have short of dissolving the friendship. MUCH LOVES to all the moms who were so helpful & took the time !!

More Answers

I certainly understand the desire to keep the friends you have - I make so few myself that I hate to see any friendship fail. But my children's safety, both from physical threats and poor influences, comes first. I would be very honest, being careful to speak the truth in love, and let the chips fall where they may. If she's a friend worth keeping, she'll be understanding of your position and respectful of your children. And it might just be the wake-up call she needs to take action with her own child. (She's not doing him any favors by simply making excuses for him!) If the boy is three already and no one has dared to mention the reality of the situation, she probably doesn't have too much more time before someone does. Better to be told by someone who loves and values her.

All the best to you and to her and to the kiddos on both sides!

~ R.

2 moms found this helpful

J.,
If I were in your shoes I would have to agree with the other mom. There probably is NO Gentle way to talk to your friend... I would remove my child as soon as the other child started acting up or even tell the child that you don't appreciate how he treats your girls. If your friend can't disipline her child for being abusive to your girls than why would you want your girls to be around him? At least that's how I feel. It kinda sounds to me like this might be a way of wanting attention! Maybe ask her about getting him involved it some kind of activity before you come over or during your visit. So he might not be as compelled to misbehave. Ask her to PLEASE explain to him that the way he treats your girls is NOT OKAY.
I wish you luck with this! I hope I was able to help at least a little!

1 mom found this helpful

Hi,
I am a teacher for 3 year olds and I know the games they try to play. They are very good at getting their own way, but they need very strong boundaries also. It is a worse offence for your friend to not give her boundaries than to "be firm". Without strong limits, she will be a very lost, frustrated little girl. She is begging for someone to take charge. She may revolt at first, but the end result will be a confident, self motivated, loving child.

A little about me: Mother of 5. Loving husband of many years. Preschool teacher, own a children's video title and new host for a baby show coming in January.

1 mom found this helpful

J.,
I had a friend who's 3 sons were the same way. Well they still are but after just dealing with it for so long like you are, I noticed MY kids picking up some bad behavior from them so that's when I had to draw the line. It was hard but I was very blunt. "Either your kids start behaving or our kids can't be together anymore. We don't allow bad behavior of any kind and if your kids aren't going to be required to behave then we can't be together anymore." Believe me that was the hardest thing to say to a good friend but I have since moved on and now I have better friends with better kids. You are the only advocate your kids have and if your friend's son is a danger and a bad influence on them then you have to think about them first and draw a line. Be blunt someimes sugar coating keeps people from actually seen the real problem. DOn't be nasty and use mean words but say, "your son is mean and hurtful and you allow him to get away with too much wrong behavior and I can't deal with that anymore." Cause there really is no excuse for bad parenting. Good luck!

C.

1 mom found this helpful

I don't know how you can go about actually saying anything to her overtly. If the little demon started acting up around my kids, hitting them or spitting on them, pulling their hair, I would get them out of the room and away from the demon child. Keeping your girls safe HAS to be priority #1. I might even be the one who stepped in and told demon child they are NOT to pull my daughter's hair, etc. if the mother is just going to sit there and make excuses. Yes this will start conflict but otherwise you will be sitting there for years while her kid becomes more physically aggressive toward your kids.
If I were visting, DemonSpawn tantrum time would be the time I made my goodbyes and I'd keep leaving/removing my children from harm's way until the mother learned to teach her child to behave.

It's hard, but you may end up ending the friendship you have with this person over this.

You can try to talk to her and say "I don't like it when DemonSpawn pulls Tiffany's hair" and see what goes from there. More than likely, she'll make excuses.

I wish you luck with this - I know it's particularly tricky to be friends with someone that you think is great, but the parenting styles don't mesh and it ends up being a conflict.

1 mom found this helpful

If she makes an excuse for all things I feel you should keep your children away from hers and just talk on the phone or IM alot to keep your friendship with her. This will keep your kids safe and not picking up bad habit.

1 mom found this helpful

I agress with the others, just keep your distants for now.
She will probably get the message when her kid is constantly in trouble at school. Hopefully before he is in trouble with the law.

1 mom found this helpful

There's realy no way to tell her. She will get upset or give you another excuse. You need to be firm with her and let her know that your only saying this because you care.Because You love her son and her you feel she needs to hear you out. Since you can see things she may not see. Let her know your concerns about what her son is doing. then let her know that when he starts school teachers want let this behavior happen. So she needs to put him in time out when he's doing wrong. Other wise he want be able to fit in at school. You don't want to see that happen.
I know I have a friend that is the same way. I tell her I'm only telling you from past experience. Because my son is older than hers and then my daughter is older than her youngest son. But she feels like people are putting her down or her kids down. So I finaly learned I had to do what I felt was best for my kids. If that meant they couldn't play then I'm sorry. But I half to do whats best for my kids too. We are still good friends. Her kids know when I'm around with my kids they can't cuss or do certain things or we will leave. Same with my kids they know they half to behave too. That might be what you half to do. If he's not trying to be nice then you leave or ask her to leave. Then maby she'll see what she's doing.
I don't know if this helps. But I hope it will help you.
M.

1 mom found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.