32 answers

Kids and Sweets- Healthy Mom Wants to Know If Its Realistic to Hold off on Sugar

When I pictured being a mom, I pictured being one of those mom's who kept all sugar and junk food out of the diet until they were three of four. Possibly going vegetarian and having the healthiest children who didn't even whine for soda or treats because they scarcely knew what they were. But today I pulled a mango/cream Popsicle out of my freezer and ate it (I try not to have sweets in the house, it was from last summer and I'm still trying to loose the last 7 lbs from pregnancy!). My 8 month old is just expressing interest in our food and we are having a blast giving her little tastes and watching her face. Not only was my diet shot, I forgot all my big health nut plans when she reached for the Popsicle and there we sat on the floor sharing licks of the cold sugary goodness.
Now I'm kicking myself remembering my big plans of not even introducing sugar into the diet. Should I get back on the wagon or change my unrealistic goals?

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

I'm glad to hear that SO many of you have successfully kept sugar out of the picture for the first few years of life. I was fishing for that and hope to keep on that track for as long as we can. I know it won't last forever, and when they become more exposed to sweets, I'll work on the moderation aspect. I feel that there was a little too much sugar in my upbringing and I struggle with a sweet tooth. I guess it can go sour either way: too much exposure, too much restriction. Now I just need to get that fellow sweet tooth of a grandpa to see it my way!

Featured Answers

I did not give my kids any sugary stuff until they got it elsewhere (grandma, playgroups, etc) and I don't stock it in the house - mostly because I WANT TO EAT IT!!!! I don't think that sugar is the antichrist, but my kids don't get dessert every day, don't expect it and don't really crave it. I have a 6 & 3 yr old. They get candy from parties & goody bags, etc. we put it in a bucket and give it out as rewards (one piece of candy) for doing household jobs one time a day. I really don't mind when my kids get sugar, and it is part of parties and celebrations, but I'm not going to give it to them, I let the Easter Bunny do that!

1 mom found this helpful

First off, you're the mom, so do what you think is best. My personal opinion is that it's better to expose children to a little sugar when they're young and their bodies can easily handle it, so that by the time they're teenagers they aren't obsessing or longing for it because it's always been denied them. I think that by teaching them from an early age to balance healthy and sweet and to make their own decisions and control their own diet, they will be far better prepared to make those choices as adults.

i think that sweets here and there in moderation is fine. as long as they are getting LOTS of the healthy stuff and the sweets aren't replacing the nutrition that the healthy stuff provides. my daughter has the worst sweet tooth in the world, so i really have to watch her intake, but she also will plow through a plate of veggies and has a lot of whole grains in her diet. so knowing that, a treat here and there is better than an uncontrollable binge down the road. good luck!

More Answers

Real, lasting satisfaction, as you know, comes from things that are wholesome. If you work towards a majority of healthy eating at home, your kids will be blessed. Thankfully the human body functions as a democracy. That means if the majority of what they are getting is healthy, then grandma offering a cookie shouldn't be devistating. And even if grandma watches them for a week straight and serves macaroni and cheese every meal, the worst they will be slotted for is getting crabby and sick, not cancer.

So, in support of the awesome job you are doing, some good books to read are Kids Are What They Eat by Betty Kamen (another of hers that is AWESOME is New Facts About Fiber).

Getting kids to eat healthy is a test of creativity, yet those who have the guts and determination to be hopeful and creative get the blessings. Junkfood can really blind people from the goodness of wholefoods, so keep doing the great job of keeping on your toes!

1 mom found this helpful

Hi H.:
I have to agree with Michelle on this one. The earlier you begin teaching your children healthy eating habits, the better. I had to giggle,when you spoke of sitting and sharing that popsicle with your your daughter. You know...That (pardon the pun) SWEET MOMENT you had together wouldn't have been half as enjoyable,had she been use to eating things like that,on a daily basis. Theres nothing wrong with treating yourselves once in a while. Heck, thats why they call it a (TREAT) right? They make great natural juice popsicles.Orange juice,or grape-juice.My grandkids ask me to make them slushes,with real juice. They love it. Keep up the good work H.,your children will adore you for it by the time they reach middle school.I know my grandaughter has a few friends, that have a terrible time with their weight and putting up with ridicule because of their unhealthy eating habits.I wish you and yours the very best.

1 mom found this helpful

I did not give my kids any sugary stuff until they got it elsewhere (grandma, playgroups, etc) and I don't stock it in the house - mostly because I WANT TO EAT IT!!!! I don't think that sugar is the antichrist, but my kids don't get dessert every day, don't expect it and don't really crave it. I have a 6 & 3 yr old. They get candy from parties & goody bags, etc. we put it in a bucket and give it out as rewards (one piece of candy) for doing household jobs one time a day. I really don't mind when my kids get sugar, and it is part of parties and celebrations, but I'm not going to give it to them, I let the Easter Bunny do that!

1 mom found this helpful

WOW, how terrible, YOU shared a Popsicle with your kid, what a dilemma and crossroad you have come to......

I'm a mom of 3 kids ages 14, 4, and 5 months. I never set out to give my kids all healthy foods, and my kids are fine. Wish I had introduced veggies to my son earlier as now he won't touch them. With my 6 mo old I will do better. My 14 year old eats sweets and a lot of fruits and veggies. My 4 year old I didn't give sweets to him till he was 1 yr. He got his b-day cake and after a few bites he got down from his high chair and proceeded to run back and forth between the couch and table for a good five minutes. A little sugar buzz. I think sodas should be kept away from kids (even though my 14 yr old gives my 4 yr old some of her soda. At Halloween I limited them to a certain amount of candy a day. Sometimes by Easter I would throw away the halloween candy (which was a lot)and put the easter candy in a bag. I did hear you should introduce them to fresh fruits around 6 months. I found a mesh feeder that you can put fruit and veggies into and you don't have to worry about them choking on the seeds. Try that. They're going to get sweets from school and friends houses so trying to keep it away from them won't work. Limiting it is probably more realistic but introduce them to a variety of fruits and veggies at a young age.

Hope this helps.

First off, you're the mom, so do what you think is best. My personal opinion is that it's better to expose children to a little sugar when they're young and their bodies can easily handle it, so that by the time they're teenagers they aren't obsessing or longing for it because it's always been denied them. I think that by teaching them from an early age to balance healthy and sweet and to make their own decisions and control their own diet, they will be far better prepared to make those choices as adults.

Don't set unrealistic goals and try to keep all sugar out of the house; just try to keep the sugary treats to a minimum. There are lots of healthy alternative sweeties available for baby that are made by Gerber and Beechnut and if you're going to have popsicles and ice cream, go for the lite versions or even sugar free. Our family has tried them and everyone loved them; we didn't really notice a difference. And as long as your brushing your baby's teeth and gums daily, a little nibble of whatever you're eating every now and then is not going to create a health problem for your baby. Our toddler sees us eating and drinking different things and is always curious for a taste and I really don't see the harm in it as long as we keep it in moderation. Good luck!

I'm late in responding to this, but I wanted to say GOOD JOB on wanting to teach your daughter healthy habits. I was just at a birthday party and watched a mother feed her 8 month old an entire cupcake, then give her sips of soda. With my daughters, I try to stick to a healthy diet of fresh organic fruits and veggies, small amounts of organic meats, organic dairy, and lots of water. They each tasted sugar for the first time on their first birthday. We don't keep soda in the house, and the only time my oldest is allowed it is on airplanes. For a long time, when we were grocery shopping and my kids would ask for Lucky Charms or Trix or whatever sugary cereal was placed at their eye level with toys in the box, I'd tell them that those cereals are for kids whose parents don't love them. In a way I'm kidding, but in a way I'm not. Who would purposely feed their children junk when there are healthy things available? I'm not a food nazi, more a food fascist. People have thought we were vegetarians, or health nuts, and are surprised to find out we're neither. My girls can have Halloween candy - we even leave it out for them, but they lose interest in it after a day or two, and then a week later I toss it out and they never ask for it. They both like sweets, but they know it's a once in awhile kind of treat. My oldest craves grapes, tofu, and sushi. My youngest wants bananas, oatmeal, chicken, and hummus. These are their comfort foods. So much different than the way I was raised, when I had to ask for milk instead of soda at dinner. I've seen too many kids with rotted teeth carrying around cans of soda, too many adults eating Fruity Pebbles and Snickers bars, too many cases of obesity, early on-set puberty, and diabetes to think that having a laissez faire attitude regarding their diet is okay. My kids know what junk food is, know that McDonalds and Burger King and all the other fast food places are not for them, and actually like eating healthy foods. We took them to a McDonalds once - they hated it. My oldest was invited to a party at Chuck E. Cheese, took one bite of the pizza and wouldn't eat it because it didn't taste good. Our main challenge - french fries. After reading about a link to deep fried foods in childhood and breast and other kinds of cancers as adults, we cut them out of our diet. Unfortunately, we all love them. But we have them only occasionally, right before we have big chocolate sundaes with whipped cream. Moderation, leaning heavily toward healthy. Your daughter is lucky to have a mother who cares so much about her diet!

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.