Jury Duty - Unusual Situation PLEASE NO MORE RESPONSES

You call this an unusual situation but it's not. Maybe to you but not to the rest fo the world. Someone is sacrificing their jobs everyday to serve on a jury. And I am sure they all think they are the exception to the rule. Sorry! :)

2 moms found this helpful

I know you asked for no more but I did not read the others and got the gist of what you were asking, for advice not judgement. I always get out of jury duty. How? Because I write down "Yes, I would like to be on a Jury" in the place they ask whether people want to or not. I think it would be so interesting. They refer to me when they're talking to everyone saying "We even have a nut case who wants to be on a jury in here". And I've never gotten to serve. :-(

1 mom found this helpful

I use a shipping store regularly and the couple have a gated area to the back (baby gate) and the toddler and dogs go with them daily. They have a "safe" area for the little one.

Just my opinion.

I'm sorry you have found the responses so frustrating. I have served on a jury and learned a LOT and I am very glad I took the time to do it.

Couldnt he check that he is a caregiver to children who would be left alone? Sounds like that is the case

Amen !!! i hope everything turns out ok for you. You should be excused from Jury Duty if you ask me.

As for a deferral to the next jury cycle, usually you can get at least one deferral approved.

Of note, I was asked to serve jury duty here in our very small town and simply told them that I had no one to watch my children during that time frame since my husband works in Plano. I was excused. I think if you explain your situation that you have to keep your business open and have no one available to work during those hours as well as no one to watch your children, you may be excused.

Tough call and yes I understand all about our duties..but as someone said during these times when every penny counts the government should understand why we can't always do what they ask.

J.

There is an exemption for caretakers of children under 10.

Unfortunately work and economic considerations alone do not qualify as an exemption. Oddly enough, however, if worrying about the economic impact of jury service would make someone too anxious to properly focus on the trial, they can be excused. It's a matter of framing :)

As a teacher they've always moved mine to the summer. He might be able to postpone until his employee is done with school in May.

The exact same thing happened to us. I am the primary caretaker of our children, so I was exempt; however you cannot claim that for both of you. If he claims that he is the primary caretaker, you will have to go if you are ever called. My husband had to go, even though he didn't have anyone who could cover the office for him at our business and I was about to have another baby and was unable to do it. (It is a kennel so at 9 months pregnant is not advisable to be running around with large dogs!) Due to the nature of our business, we couldn't even shut down because we had animals there in our care. He did ask and they said there is no exemption for self employment no matter what. With any luck, your county or city will be different. (Ours was Denton Cty.) It is absolutely not fair and a huge detriment to those of us with small businesses. They did offer a postponement in order to get someone in, but even that was just for a few weeks and he would still have to go. Best of luck to you.

Hi there :) Unfourtantly... no, they won't let him be excused for that.. Do you have anyone that can either watch the little ones for the day, or sit in the store?

You could take the girls to open it - leave the friend there - and then close it at the end of the day :)

Unfortunately, the courts do not look favorably on people with real problems like the one you describe. The judge is left with the difficult situation such that if he allows one person an exemption for an economic hardship, then he would have to allow exemptions for anyone with such hardships. Not only might the judge have problems finding enough jurors, but at some point someone would come along with a class action lawsuit claiming that all people going though that court were having their consitutional rights trampled on because the jury pool was being manipulated by people claiming exemptions that were not specifically authorized by law. My suggestion would be that your husband try hard to find a friend or someone that could come and hold the store open and just hope that he does not get picked to serve on a jury. Postponing the service would seem to make the matter worse since you are close to delivery. Good luck, and remember that jury service is the price you pay for having a driver's license, the right to vote, etc.

I feel your pain, but unless they have a massive amount of jurors show up, he probably won't get off. There should be a number on the card for him to call with any problems. He can discuss the situation with the judges' office and they might be sympathetic.

I personally feel that it is our duty to serve. If we want a judicial system that is balanced by peer juries, we need to participate.

Good Luck!