S.Y. asks from Milwaukee, WI on April 28, 2008
Is More Servere Punishment Needed?
My daughter is 13 years old and seems to be the class clown in her English class. She is has not been doing her work, in class or at home and she dancing, talking with her classmates and not listening to her instructor at all. All the girls in her "group" have not passed this pass marking period, she claims she just didn't get what was going on. She has excellent grades otherwise. I have taken away her phone, tv, computer and music privilages. But, there is a loop hole with this; I leave for work before she does and return home after, I am not sure if she is doing these things at this time or not. I have also been told she is suppose to call herself talking to a 16 year old boy/man. He is living his life as a man, not a boy. I am on the verge of getting her the shot. I don't want to take any chances. I have talked to her about this and the dangers of it also. Can someboday please give me some advise.
1 mom found this helpful
So What Happened?™
Going bk over what I previously wrote. My daughter DID make it to school, I followed up with all her instructors (phone and emails), the school bus was late. So now I can finish saying thks to everyone for all the advice and concern I have taken it all to heart and followed through to some websites. As I was attempting to say, she has been moved from her friends and doing much better. We have continued our talks about what is appropriate and aspected of and for her. My daughter can be silly at time but usually when needed she is responsible. My daughter attends a school for the gifted. I have come to relize she was having trouble and no one was listening, myself and every other adult involved in her life included. She had never had trouble with a subject before that after a little struggle she did not graps. No one was listening, she couldn't get it, she acted out. I LEARNED THIS LESSON THE HARD WAY. Unfortunately so did she, because of her acting out and not even trying to get something done, she has dropped from a B+ to a C average. This is not sitting well with her. She is now doing her work, they are now on poetry, something she likes. As far as the "boyfriend" think, this one is taken care of though my guards are not down. I am looking into some after school programs for her and finding a veterianrian's office she can volunteer at, she wants to be a Veterianrian. I am hoping these things will help.
Featured Answers
J.S. answers from Minneapolis on April 29, 2008
Hi S., I do have teenagers and I know what a struggle they can be. I think you have gotten some great advise and I just wanted to add something. If you go from being a lenient parent to strict mom overnight you are going to start having problems with running away. She is not going to know how to properly handle the situation so her fight or flight response will kick in. You both should go to family counseling. You will learn how to implement the advise that you are given and she will learn the proper way to respond to it. As a spritual coach I have seen it happen over and over. Life is like a baby mobile. If you hit one of the hanging toys it will eventually balance back out. You need to change both parts at once in order to create a new balance or it will go back to the same thing, but worse. I don't know where you live but there are great clinics all over the Twin Cities that do work on a sliding fee scale. If you would like I could get you a couple of recommendations. ____@____.com
T.S. answers from Minneapolis on April 28, 2008
Is it possible, she's not understanding the subject. Possibly she needs a tutor. Sometimes when kids don't get what's going on, they act out like that. Just a thought.
More Answers
B.H. answers from Minneapolis on April 28, 2008
Well we all the know the only thing that 16 yr.old boy is interested in is sex. I know alot of my friends lost their virginities in middle school-freshman year around age14. So the likely hood of your daughter becoming sexually active if not already is really high. If you can get her on birthcontrol or the depo shot and have lots of conversations on sex.
2nd When you take away her things you really have to take them away like lock them up somewhere, take the house phone to work with you. Hmmm when I was a teen and grounded I totally did whatever I wanted after school before my dad got home. Kids are sneaky I was very sneaky.... I would pretend to go babysit or pretend to take my baby brother or our dog for a walk and go over to my 17 year old boyfriends house.
Find her loopholes, be one step ahead of her.
Put your foot down hard.
1 mom found this helpful
N.S. answers from Minneapolis on April 28, 2008
Sounds like she has a couple of big issues going on here. One, she has more than likely begun a "performance career" to cope with peer pressure. She's obviously trying to get acceptance and approval from her peers both female and male at the expense of her academic career. Unfortunately, this click probably has a pecking order and it sounds like the only spot left in the "group" is as "court jester."
She's obviously still to emotionally immature to see how this behavior will negatively impact her in the next 2-3 years. She needs to understand from now until her Junior year in High School is "do or die" academically speaking. I don't know how involved you are in her day to day school work, but I think it is imperative that you make your presence known at school, and schedule a meeting in person if possible, with her English teacher and all of her teachers, to come up with ways to help her improve her grades before the year is out and to distance her from her so-called friends during class.
If this were earlier in the school year, I would even go so far as to have her switched to a different class period for the same class if possible, so that she won't be tempted to be distracted.
I would also encourage you to make your daughter show you her school work for ALL of her subjects every night. Help her if she needs it. If you feel you can not trust her to tell you what her daily assignments should be, get a teacher's syllabus for each class so you know what her daily assignments are, and what she learns each day. Do not let her go to bed until you check off her assignments each night. If you find her struggling academically, and you discover it might be more than an issue of her applying herself, now you will have a starting point for getting the appropriate academic help she needs and before its too late.
As for this "group" or "friend" issue, if all or some of these "friends" are in any of her classes other than English, I'd suspect this is a common theme in all subjects, but for whatever reason, her teachers aren't reporting anything to you. Once again, getting to know her teachers will put them on notice and let them know you're involved in her academci welfare. If you don't have time for one on one meetings, regular phonecalls can be just as effective. Besides, if you make your daughter and her teachers accountable by being involved in her day to day assignments, she'll be less likely to fool around in class, knowing that she'll have you (the provider of her food and creature comforts) to report to, and teachers will be less likely to let her get away with it.
You're right that there is no way to find out if she's keeping her word and staying out trouble while you're at work. I'd guess with an older boyfriend, he's probably been to the house without you're knowing it. Or, she may not even be coming home afterschool like she is supposed to. Plain and simple she's proven she's not mature enough to be on her own without adult guidance. And its clear she has too much freedom and freetime on her hands. To remedy this, I'd first and foremost work on the boyfriend issue. I personally think she's too young for a relationship let alone with an older boy. Her focus should be on academics if she has any aspirations of doing more with her life than being someone's "girlfriend" or "momma".
I'm from the school of thought that strict parental involvement and open communication are the best prevention of teen pregnancy. I think relying on contraceptives to help control a youngster is the "easy way out" of parental responsibility and the quickest way to invite to unwanted trouble.
IMO taking your daughter to the doctor to get contraceptives is the same giving her the green light to get into sexual experimentation. This solution doesn't protect against disease, nor does it protect her from the mental stress that relationships too young can cause, it does not ensure she will perform academically, nor will it ensure that she will stay out of trouble at school or away from home.
You also risk sending her the message that relationships at this stage of the game are equally as important as academics. In reality, her being allowed to be in a relationship this young can only have one certain outcome, no academic future. With time, if you allow her to indulge in a boyfriend, she will put all of her energies into this person and less and less into her own needs. Now is HER time to become the person she's meant to be, and the time for you to reap the satisfaction of helping to develop into that person. It would be a shame to allow some boy to rob this from her, and YOU. In short, forget the shot, and get rid of the boy. Especially one who is too old for her. You're asking for trouble. If necessary, call his parents,or confront him. Tell him you have expectations and that official dating is not a possibility. Only supervised visits if any. If he's the trouble you seem to imply, perhaps more serious action is needed. Maybe threats of a meeting with a police liason from school if he's real trouble? Without more information, I have no better advice except to forbid his presence in her life!!
In this situation, I'd forbid any dating until she's much much older. If you pay the bills, you can forbid dating and effectively enforce this by not making "creature comforts" so easily available. Make her earn her keep and give her chores around the house if she wants a new jacket, shoes, or video game. Until she's old enough to get a job, she should be expected to do chores around the house and make herself useful. She will not respect you or value anything you give her if you don't help to her to understand that in life if you want good things, you have to work for them, and if she wants to coexist happily under your roof, she's going to have to respect your rules and value-system.
Instead get tough on her, talk to her about expectations and consequences. If necessary, maybe its time to talk to her about who she chooses to make friends with and most especially about boys since this goes hand in hand, and set her straight on expectations. Tell her what age you will allow dating. Limit exposure to boys to parent chaperoned group only situations.
If she has male friends, don't allow her to hang out with them until you've had a chance to communicate with the parents of the boy and the boy about expectations. And as I mentioned already, in parent chaperoned situations.
The same expectation should go for new female friends too. It is not a crime to "help" her select friends, and for you to get to know them and their parents. You are her mother out for her best interest. She may not like it, but This way you will have a network of parents who hopefully will help you watch out for your daughter and vice versa. If they won't help, then you don't want your daughter hanging out with their kids. Invite these potential friends to your house on weekends, and make yourself present. Get involved in her activities and with her friends. Do not make the mistake of leaving her to her own devices.
Bottom line I think She still needs supervision and probably until she's much older and has proven that she can be responsible and trusted. I'd suggest finding a way to keep her occupied or "chaperoned" until you get home from work.
It sounds like resources may be a challenge, but I'd strongly encourage you to see if there is an afterschool tutuoring program offered at your daughter's school or within your school district and get her enrolled immediately.
Since it is the end of the school year, availability of district run programs might be slim. Don't forget community ed programs in your area as well, while not free, they're very affordable. There are also similar afterschool programs sponsored by area churches also often free or low cost, run by teacher/tutor volunteers that do the same thing.
If you can't find an afterschool program that is geared academically, get her involved in volunteerism for an hour or two afterschool, she is not too young to put in some constructively spent hours helping out younger kids at a church-run daycare/afterschool program herself.
Last but not least, it is not too late to get her enrolled in intramural/ community sports, arts, dance and music programs. These programs are also very affordable, and run all year round. Perhaps this would also be a great option to keep her out of trouble for a few hours until you get home.
Whether she needs the academic support an afterschool tutoring program would provide or not, or whether she's interested in "volunteering" or not, these are all free/low cost solutions to your soon to get worst problem...all of which will encourage her to be accountable, learn skills that will help her in the future, and possibily keep her out of trouble if she's in an environment with people who care until you are able to be with her.
If this is not an option, I'd consider enlisting a grandparent, or a responsible adult you can trust to help "chaperone" her after school. Maybe a friend from church, a community role-model? This person should be someone who can enforce rules, but not undermine your authority or values. I know this is a big challenge, but I think you're already thinking correctly. Go with your gut, and hopefully some of these ideas can help.
1 mom found this helpful
P.S. answers from Lincoln on April 29, 2008
Hi S.! I have no real advice to give to you, I just wanted to tell you that you are doing a good job, what you are able to do, and you need to hear a few encouraging words. You ARE doing what you can do, any more punishment will really turn her off to you and send her to her 'friend'. Let her realize that her use of her cellphone, the computer, her music, TV, are all privileges, not her right, too many teens especially forget that. He is not a real friend to her, but she doesn't want to hear that. You just have to keep on being accepting of her and just keep on 'boring' her with: you need to do your homework, you need to clean your room, you need to try harder with your grades, etc. And be there for her; don't give her permission to do what she wants to do. She is afraid of the responsibilities of parenthood, but sometimes they (teens) think that it won't, couldn't happen to them. She is only 13. I have a 15 year old and so far she listens and has her goals in front of her so that she can see what she shouldn't do. Ask your daughter what her goals are, then ask how her 'friend' fits in. Try to do this on the spur of the moment, like it isn't stressing you. Let her realize that living the real life depends on how she does growing up, grades, friends, trust. Good luck.
T.C. answers from Lincoln on April 29, 2008
You asked if more severe punishment is needed. You can't really enforce no tv and computer if you aren't there for a few hours each week day. Don't punish more, spend more time with her. If I know 13 year olds, and I do, she will consider that more of a punishment than anything else (at first) then who knows? She might start to open up about what is going on in that class, i.e. the instructor reminds her of someone she's mad at... there's a boy in there she's performing clownish acts for... peer pressure from the other girls... And yes you should get her the shot! I used to teach high school and middle school. You should be talking to her about the dangers of STD's. I read last week online (either newsweek or time) that 1 in 4 girls has an STD.
J.S. answers from Minneapolis on April 29, 2008
Hi S., I do have teenagers and I know what a struggle they can be. I think you have gotten some great advise and I just wanted to add something. If you go from being a lenient parent to strict mom overnight you are going to start having problems with running away. She is not going to know how to properly handle the situation so her fight or flight response will kick in. You both should go to family counseling. You will learn how to implement the advise that you are given and she will learn the proper way to respond to it. As a spritual coach I have seen it happen over and over. Life is like a baby mobile. If you hit one of the hanging toys it will eventually balance back out. You need to change both parts at once in order to create a new balance or it will go back to the same thing, but worse. I don't know where you live but there are great clinics all over the Twin Cities that do work on a sliding fee scale. If you would like I could get you a couple of recommendations. ____@____.com
A.N. answers from Minneapolis on May 03, 2008
13 is a little old for punishment. If you think she is thinking about sex already, she is almost a woman and deserves honesty and respect. I have a problem sometimes thinking my teenage daughter is dishonest, but that's because my mom treated me that way. I am embarrassed at times to find out my suspicions were totally unfounded. Don't let your fear for your daughter's future ruin your relationship. Maybe her teacher doesn't know how to reach her, maybe she feels it's more important to be funny than to be good at English.
B.W. answers from Milwaukee on April 29, 2008
Is she an only child? It sounds like she has too much time on her hands to goof off while you work. Is she in any activities? My daughter and son have both recently tried to pull the "I don't get it" in one of their classes and we set up extra help for them with a teacher we know....there's no excuse.
13 is too old for a babysitter before you get home but is there anyone you can ask to check in on her unannounced? I had my 11 year old "babysit" for my 14 year old and his girlfriend when we couldn't be home one night so I got all the details of what went on from my little "babysitter"!
K.H. answers from Sioux Falls on April 29, 2008
I sympathize with you. I have a 14 year old son who has challenged me as a parent for the last two years. I tried everything but nothing seemed to make our relationship any better. I was on line one day doing some research for another project that I was working on and found a parenting program that seemed like it might have the answers. The program is called "The Total Transformation Program" by James Lehman- www.thetotaltransformation.com , 1-800-460-2235. It has 7 cds and a couple DVD programs. I learned so much from it. How I was handling situations, putting too much emotion into my sons reactions, but mostly how I hadn't defined rules,boundaries and expectations properly. This program has been a life saver for me. My stress levels are down and my son is actually motivated to be a better person. The program was worth the investment. If you have any questions let me know. I would be more than happy to help you out. Parenting is fun isn't it? Have a great day!
K.
Email