L.M. asks from Meriden, CT on June 25, 2008
Invitation to Bff's Daughter's Wedding
My best friend, BF (for the last 17 years) has a 19 year old daugher, D. D has been like a niece to me and my husband. We were close before she hit her teen years.
A little history... BF got divorced about 7 years ago, and is currenlty married. D never adjusted to the divorce or the new man in her mother's life. D never did well in high school, barely got by, mostly because she was lazy. D didn't do the work and frequently cut school, missed the bus, etc. D manaaged to get accepted at an out-of-state college. The only reason she wanted to go there is because her boyfriend had moved there with his family. D dropped off after the first semester, didn't tell her mom, and moved in with the boyfriend and his family. D got pregnant and had a miscarraige. D's grandmother co-signed the college loan, and D stuck her with the bill as she refused to make any payments. D then moved back to CT with her boyfriend to her mother's house. BF set down the rules, pay rent $50 per week, contribute to the weekly grocery bill, both of them get a job or go to school (the boyfriend is a drop out), and do chores around the house. D and boyfriend didn't follow any of the rules. D also decided she wanted a baby, and got herself pregnant (the boyfriend didn't even know). BF them they had to move out. D, boyfriend, and baby and now living with D's father - and are quickly wearing out their welcome. D asked BF if she, boyfriend and baby could move back in with her - NO. The boyfriend and D both have part-time minimum wage jobs. BF and D get along well. BF is always babysitting.
A few weeks ago BF had heard from her other daughter that D was engaged. Two days ago BF confronted D about the engagement, BF called me with the news. The wedding is Thurs. 7/10 and they want a picnic reception at BF's house. BF did not give them an answer.
Today my husband gets a call at work inviting our family (hubby, me and 2 girls) to the wedding (we don't know where) and by the way can hubby make ribs for the reception. He said he was really busy and asked her to call us at home later tonight.
OK here's my dilema. Do I go to the wedding? What about the ribs? Hubby and I will both be working on Thursday. It would be extremely difficult for hubby to take time off work. It wouldn't be easy for me either, but I could use 1/2 vacation day, which I was saving to use to spend an afternoon with my kids. I don't want to go. I don't support this marraige. Hubby is not going to a reception and standing over a grill. We would cook the ribs ahead of time and they could warm them up. Who pays for the ribs? BF and I have always been there for each other, and I want to support her.
So What Happened?™
Thank you all so much for the advise.
I'm getting together with BF tomorrow. We'll have a chance to talk. After I have more info., I'll make my final decission.
D never called us that evening and still hasn't called. Hubby checked his schedule at work and there's absolutely no way he can take off work that day, he also said "there's no way in h---, that I'm going to a wedding to stand over a grill". We both know the only reason D called him, is because she wants a cook. Hubby and I talked, he would be willing to cook the ribs on Monday, his day off and then freeze them. Everyone loves hubby's rib, they're his specialty.
My work schedule isn't that much better. I have a meeting at 2:00 that afternoon, by the way the wedding is at 4:00. It's a 30 minute drive home and then another 30 minute drive to BF's house. Another person in my department is already scheduled off that day. My employer likes us to schedule time off at least 2 weeks in advance.
Here's what I'm thinking of doing. Explaining to BF that hubby can't take time off and it's very difficult for me to take time off on such short notice. However, my girls and I would like to join you for cake and coffee later that evening. Yes, my daughter's do want to attend.
If D wants the precooked ribs, a card with a note "I hope you enjoy the ribs" will be our gift. Otherwise, it's a gift card probably to Walmart (it's close to dad's house) where they can by things for the baby or some necessities. (Note: for the baby shower I gave a gift, my 12 year old gave a separte gift, and my 11 year old make D a fleece blanket and a matching pillow with the baby's name embroidered on it. My daughter worked really hard on it and put a lot of effort into it. I thought it came out really nice and other guest at the shower also thought so. It wasn't appreciated. I could tell when she opened it and all my daughter got was a generic thank you for the blanket.)
Featured Answers
P.N. answers from Syracuse on June 26, 2008
What a mess! The way I'm reading this, the daughter is asking you to bring the ribs - right? Rather a rude request since it sounds like you haven't been close for awhile. Maybe she thinks you're a nice person and she can get you to do this for her. So, I would talk to BF and see if she has decided to host this picnic thing after all, and if it would really help her (BF) out, I'd do it. Otherwise, why should you bring the main dish?? As someone else wrote, let hubby stay at work, and go to the wedding if you want to and BF needs the support. Again, if BF is not even going, follow her lead. If you really need to save that half day of vacation for something more important BF will understand as well, and I doubt hold it against you. I would give a small gift whether you go or not, and since she's pregnant and broke, the gift should definitely be functional - sheets, cookware, giftcard to Target or some other practical place. Good luck!!
More Answers
R.C. answers from New York on June 26, 2008
You have some decisions to make....How large of an investment do you want to make in being supportive of BF?
In order to decide this, you will need more information.
Call BF and tell her you need more information so you can figure out what you can and can't do. Ask where the wedding is going to take place, the time it starts, and how many people are going to attend and then tell her you will get back to her....
Talk it over with your husband....see what you are both willing and not willing to do....
If you can afford to buy the ribs to feed her guests, and want to pre-cook them or cook and serve at the wedding, either way can be your wedding gift.
If she doesn't want the ribs pre-cooked, ask her if she has someone attending the wedding who would do the cooking for her as your husband wont be doing this. If he can't get time off from work to attend the wedding, tell her so. If he can attend the wedding but just doesn't want to cook and serve at the party, tell her so.
If you can't afford to pay for the ribs to feed her guests, tell her so. Ask for the money up front so you can shop for what is needed.
If you decide you don't want to or cant take time off from work to attend the wedding but still willing to pre-cook the ribs, tell her so and make arrangements with her in terms of getting the ribs over to the party.
L.S. answers from Buffalo on June 26, 2008
Your BF needs your support. Give it to her in the form of pre-cooked ribs. Save your vacation and your husband's time for your own family.
H.W. answers from Philadelphia on June 26, 2008
Hi L.,
Your story is heartbreaking and frustrating I'm sure. I was a lot like your "niece" when I was 19. I had a bf, decided not to go to college where I was accepted b/c of his location and (in my case) accidentally got pregnant at 19.
THERE IS HOPE!!! (I'm reconciled with all my family now and have managed to finish a degree, get married and have 3 children :o)
The good solid boundaries that some people are holding are going to pay off in the long run. Just remember that along with good boundaries, sincere love and affection are also good. So ABSOLUTELY go to the wedding.
It can sound something like this: "Jane Doe, I love you and will always be here to talk. Marriage is hard and I expect you will work at it because you and him have stuck by each other for these 2 years. Sometimes, I won't be able to say yes to you because it goes against my good sense - but it doesn't mean I don't love you like a daughter etc..."
As far as the ribs go, it sounds like you have an honest time conflict and it would not be exagerating to say - we're so sorry but we actually can't - but we hope we can still come to the wedding because we would really like to enjoy it with you.
Lots of love, lots of solid boundaries -
Just out of sensitivity I would also talk to her mom and just explain your thinking so that she understands that you support her as a mom. She probably feels like everyone is "rescuing" her daughter when she knows that she needs boundaries. Just lots of open, honest communication with both.
Wishing you the best outcome,
-H.
P.N. answers from Syracuse on June 26, 2008
What a mess! The way I'm reading this, the daughter is asking you to bring the ribs - right? Rather a rude request since it sounds like you haven't been close for awhile. Maybe she thinks you're a nice person and she can get you to do this for her. So, I would talk to BF and see if she has decided to host this picnic thing after all, and if it would really help her (BF) out, I'd do it. Otherwise, why should you bring the main dish?? As someone else wrote, let hubby stay at work, and go to the wedding if you want to and BF needs the support. Again, if BF is not even going, follow her lead. If you really need to save that half day of vacation for something more important BF will understand as well, and I doubt hold it against you. I would give a small gift whether you go or not, and since she's pregnant and broke, the gift should definitely be functional - sheets, cookware, giftcard to Target or some other practical place. Good luck!!
M.K. answers from New York on June 26, 2008
Wow talk about some stuff LOL!!!
I would ask how many people are going to the wedding?
and where will it be?
a pack of ribs at costco's are 25 dollars for 3 racks
, NO BIG DEAL!
tell them that you and your ribs wouldn't be able to make it til after work.
Cook the ribs in the slow cooker they are delicious and basically cook themselves siding right off the bone .
Sugggest that the happy couple collect welfare.and get a place of their own.
be there for your friend in anyway you can.
just tell her your broke and have no money.
wish you could but its just not an option at this time.
As for the daughter well time for tough love,
the girl needs to grow up.
If she asks for favors just say NO!!
tell the same to your BF.
Offer alternative solutions that don't include your friend having to put herself out there.
like getting their GED, going back to school, supporting themselves thru working , tell them where to look for a job.
but going to the wedding is about supporting your friend, NOT supporting the marriage.
ask DD and her new Husband how they plan to change their lives now that they are married.
DO NOT give a wedding gift.
Good luck in whatever you decide.
M
K.K. answers from Hartford on June 26, 2008
my thought, if she is your BF, you need to be there and support her. I am sure she is not thrilled with this "last minute" deal and calling people to ask favors, etc. but this is her daughter and she is probably trying to do the best she can with what she has. I say it is only an afternoon/evening out of your life for your best friend and this is what best friends are for. Go and have a good time.
J.G. answers from New York on June 26, 2008
WOW. That is a big delima. I think that you should attend for your BF. Even if you don't support the wedding, that is what a good friend would do. Regarding the ribs, ask your BF to buy all the ingredients and your hubby will make them this way you won't get stuck paying for the ribs.
Good Luck!
D.D. answers from New York on June 26, 2008
Call your friend for any details on the wedding such as time and place. Explain that since it's last minute your hubby and his ribs won't be attending but you'll be there. If you have some time offer to help. If not then just be there so she can vent. Sometimes being a friend means just being there.
Email