47 answers

Husband Can't Soothe 6 Week Old - Mom Has No Break - Any Ideas?

Hi Ladies,

I am writing to find out your experiences so that I can share them with my Husband. I stay at home with our new six week old daughter whom I adore beyond belief. I am at her beckon cry because that is what you are supposed to do when they are this little :)
I breastfeed but pump a bottle every couple days so that my husband can feed her once in a while.
She is still waking up at night on average every 2.5 to 3 hours, sometime a little longer or shorter, we got our first 4ish hours stretch a couple of nights ago - yeah! But then the next night she's back to every 2-2.5 hours and then I'm up for 45+ minutes each time.
So I am very tired, as we all are, and I do try to steal a little nap during the day when I can. At the suggestion of a magazine article I asked my hubby to get up and do one changing/feeding during the night last night. He comes back an hour and half later, about in tears saying "I've tried everything," which he really did, and he couldn't get her to calm down and back to sleep. He said "I really want to help I just don't know what to do any more." I told him he did help, because I on the other hand slept like a tired Mom with no baby to worry about for that hour and half. But he and the baby not so much. They have some happy time when he get's home from work, and some time together on Sat-Sun but it's usually only for a while and then it's back to Momma because she needs to be fed or something. He's a great diaper changer which helps, but despite all his genuine efforts, in general he just can't seem to soothe her too well.
Sometimes I can take her and do the same thing and she's fine. This is very frustrating to him and feels like a bad Daddy. I told him she has her bad times with me too and I can soothe her better because I nurse her and we are with each other all day. Have any of you dealt with this issue with your husbands? What can I say/do to help him? Does anyone have any ideas how we can get our baby to respond to him more ? I don't want him to get discouraged and give up hope.
Maybe this just gets better as she gets older?
Also, I will be going back to work very part-time in October - she'll be older then and hopefully that will help but I am worried that she won't be soothed by the other people caring for her besides me.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Wow..Moms and even one Dad. Thanks so much for all the encouragement and advice. We are already feeling much better and trying some things out. I do have the "Happiest Baby on the Block" book that many of you suggested and will share it with my husband. Thanks again. K.

Featured Answers

Sounds like my daughter did the same thing. We found out that she liked hearing the heart beat. Husband was a good one. She would lay on his chest and was soon sound asleep. Hope that this works for you. It did for us. Good Luck

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

Sometimes my husband did better than me (unless I was nursing) because of a DVD they have at the Houston libraries called "Happiest Baby on the Block". Lot's of tricks. I recommend you and your husband checking it out.

2 moms found this helpful

My husband and I went through a similar experience with our 2nd child. We discovered that for our son the issue was with my scent. He was so use to it that that is what he perferred. So my husband quit wearing his cologne around the baby and then he tried my perfume (lol). It worked though. To work away from that we stopped wearing perfumes and colognes all together and I just made sure all of our clothes smelled the same by using laundry detergent and softner. I don't know if this will work with your little one, but it might be worth a try.

2 moms found this helpful

This same thing happened with both my children. The only way I could get a decent night sleep is to do the co-sleeping. My oldest slept with us until she was starting kindergarten, while she was small, the entire night and then we started carrying her to her room once she fell asleep and then eventually got her to go to sleep in her own room. My youngest now 4 still sleeps with us. But I know it's only for a short time. They are both momma girls and I did all the things you are trying, I only wish I had found this site when they were small. There are some great suggestions. My husband, felt horrible that he couldn't soothe them, now they are becoming "Daddy girls". But they still want me when they are sick or hurt. I know this isn't much help, but just wanted to let you know you aren't the only one and for your hubby the baby will grow to love him, just hang in there!

1 mom found this helpful

Hi----I know this may not sound like great advice, but I have found that sometimes men have higher energy even when they don't feel like they do....and that can be overstimulating your baby. In other words, it's not him!
In time the baby will respond to other people besides you and be soothed. Just don't give up! they don't stay this little forever and then you are going to wonder what happened to the baby content to sleep on your chest. (cliched, but true)
Good luck, hang in there and ask for help when you need to sleep!

1 mom found this helpful

My husband bonded with both of our children as infants at bath time. I set every thing up for him, the baby tub etc and he would bathe them and talk to them. They loved it, the eye contact and what not. This worked for him b/c bath time was more of a "rowdy", fun time and he does that well.

When mine were teeny tiny and breastfed they wanted Mommy comfort--which can be hard and exhausting at 2 am. But they really bonded with Daddy at play time and to this day they love playing with their Dad. But he didn't have much success with the night time soothing either. And it will get easier as she gets bigger and sleeps through the night. Hang in there!

1 mom found this helpful

Hey K.,
My daughter was the same way when we first brought her home she usually only wanted mommy. When my hubby took care of her she would be ok sometimes and then other times she cry like crazy till i got a hold of her.The when she got older she started to become a daddys girl. She got to where she didnt want me sometimes. Its just a phase she is going through. Just hang tough and you all will get through this. If u need to talk just write me.

J.

1 mom found this helpful

unfortunately my son was like that for a loong time. it got better over the year but it wasn't until after his first bday that they truly bonded and didn't need me around. now he's two and when he gets hurt he still just wants me, but he gets SO excited when dad comes home so now my husband gets to be a "real" dad. just tell him to hang in there! :)

1 mom found this helpful

We had a similar problem. The only thing that worked was me just leaving the house for a little bit. They really need the chance to figure each other out without my interference. It took a few times, but eventually my husband figured out what worked for him. Now they are very close (she is 6 months) and she is equally happy with her Daddy as she is with me. I know you're breast feeding, but maybe you could pump more and he could give her a bottle during the day?

1 mom found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.