11 answers

Humidifier or Vaporizer?

I have a humidifier in my 9 mo old daughter's room that I run every night. It seems that I am buying a new filter for it every other week because it turns yellow & moldy, even though I empty the thing out every morning and clean it regularly. Is a vaporizor any better? Which models are people using?

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

I use a Vicks Vaporizer for my 2 yr old due to allergies. I like this one the best because you use cold water and it heats it up. The only maintinance I do on it is just rinse it out.

More Answers

Always always always put a cool mist humidifer in a child's room for the potential of burns to the ever curious child! Hope this helps.

I got a humidifier for my son's room. It's a Vicks and it is really quiet but I don't like how it comes apart. I also got the Vicks waterless vaporizer and it is ok. The little vapo strips are any where from $4-$6 for a 6 pack of them. Unfortunatly neither seemed to help my son with his constant stuffed up nose this past winter:(

But something you might want to try with the humidifier (even if you get one that is filterless) is use distilled water in it. Doing that cuts out the chemicals used in your local water supply (yellow filter) and any bacteria that is left in the water or that gets picked up along the way from water teatment to your sink (mold growth). I used my son's for 2 months straight and did not replace the filter or have mold growing. Heck, I didn't give it a good cleaning till I put it up for the year!

Is your little one still getting stuffed up at this time of year?

S.

I use a Vicks Vaporizer for my 2 yr old due to allergies. I like this one the best because you use cold water and it heats it up. The only maintinance I do on it is just rinse it out.

Why do you have a humidifier in your daughters room? Has she been sick?

I have a Holmes and found the same problem with that. I did find though that if I left it running during the day even when I didn't have water in there that the filter would dry out instead of sitting wet all day and getting musty. Then at night, I would fill it back up with water. I was worried about running it without water but was told it wouldn't hurt b/c it is just a fan. Hope this helps

We have five children and use the humidifier everynight during winter too. I hate those filters!! I am looking now at some models that have no filters for the humidfiers. They are running around $45 but to get rid of the filters is so worth it, and I won't have to spend money on the filters! Aren't vaporizors a warm mist instead of cool misting? I have never used one but wanted to let you know about the non-filter humidifiers! Good Luck!

my old vaporizer had no filter. i dont know about the new ones. it may be well that the filter gets changed it may be helping your baby have cleaner air.

we use them in the house because of the dry air here in NC and the fact that we all have allergies, and it cuts down on our bloody noses to have the humidifier. we went to filterless because of the problem you are talking about. BUT, with the filterless, you have to clean it out every day...really clean it, or it gets black stuff in the water. you just have to be on top of cleaning it,,and works great.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.