S.M. asks from Springfield, VA on May 12, 2009
How to Help a Teen Accept a Daddy's New Girlfriend
My brother has been grieving the loss of his wife for six months. Now he is developing a long-distance relationship with a girlfriend. Aside from two in-person visits, all the "dating" happens over the phone, and that includes a phone call every evening from just before my nieces' bedtimes until midnight. My brother's oldest girl, 13 years old, has been having a very hard time adjusting to my brother dating. Any advice for him to help my teenage niece in such a painful situation? He and my two little nieces really need the love and support of this new lady.
1 mom found this helpful
So What Happened?™
Well, I guess I forgot to mention that the new girlfriend is well accepted by the little ones, and the reason that the phone call starts just before bedtime is so that she can read good-night stories to them. They crave the mommy-like attention they get from her. The only trouble is that there's nothing in it for the teenager, I guess. Of course my brother is still grieving, and my sister-in-law was a tremendous phenomenon that no one who met her will ever forget. My brother and his girls are going to grief counseling. I do suspect that attention is part of the difficulty of the teenager's acceptance, but I worry that time is not the issue, and that she may never warm up to a new girlfriend. I worry that she may become distanced from her father and may feel alone. So, can you think of something a new girlfriend could say or offer that could make her useful (or at least not distasteful) to a teenager? Or a way to structure an increase in a father's attention for a teenager, who is busy anyway with homework and sports and friends? I appreciate all of your responses, and I will pass on to my brother that the attention consideration may be key in this. I also like the responses about making sure the teenage daughter understands that my brother still loves his late wife, which I know he makes clear regularly, but I might pass along some of that wording!
Featured Answers
B.C. answers from Norfolk on May 17, 2009
My Mother's friend (she had/has no biological kids of her own) married a widower with three kids. Two boys one girl. He had been widowed several years, one of the boys was older (middle school age), the other two were a little younger. There were times when everyone got along, and times when things were not so nice. The girl in particular was very difficult as a teenager. It seems with many teens (no matter when they lost a parent), they resent anything that takes attention away from them. Difficulties are worse when the Dad and Step Mom do not make a united front. Situations when kids disrespect the Step Mom ("You're not my Mother!" every time an issue comes up, and then a Dad that does nothing about it when it happens (and this happens with some parents even without Step relations) can be very stressful. The kids eventually grew up, moved out, got married and my Moms friend and her husband are enjoying their retirement and grandchildren now. If the girlfriend is in it for the long haul, she's got to expect ups and downs over time. The kids might grow to love or hate her and a lot depends on the individuals involved.
More Answers
K.B. answers from Washington DC on May 13, 2009
The new g-friend is a salve to the father. I understand. It's devestating to lose someone. A quick replacement actually helps to ease the pain because his attention is not on his loss. It's a form of denying his emotions, and it will actually take him longer to heal becasue he isn't dealing with his feelings now.
His daughters need his full attention at this time. They are not ready to accept a new "mother-figure". It takes quite a bit of time to mourn, especially since they are so young. I lost both my parents as an adult, and it took me a while to put my emotions in proper perspective.
So, gently let him know that his daughters need him, and how his hours away from them affect them. He should talk to the women after they go to bed. The daughters shouldn't even know about the new women anyway. You be there for the girls. Dad may need to do what he needs to do for the moment. It's his way of coping.
L.M. answers from Norfolk on May 13, 2009
I remember how difficult it was for me when I was 13 years old and I don't know how I would have handled the loss of my mother...not well I am sure.Six months may feel like enough time for your brother to move on but obviously it is still an open wound for your niece.She is probably wondering why dad can even think about having a girlfriend so soon.Everyone grieves in different ways but the most important thing is to keep communicating.She may need a third party to share her feelings and get some advice that is objective.Myself personally, I would not be conducting my personal business around my kids until I knew the person I was seeing was serious.Kids can form attachments to new people after the loss of a parent quickly, only to be devastated again when the relationship ends.It is a very tricky subject that could benefit from some professional grief counseling.
K.H. answers from Dover on May 13, 2009
I don't understand why your brother doesn't wait for the "date" to start until the girls are both in bed and asleep? Even though talking on the phone is very innocent, your brother seems to be placing a lot more on these phone calls than just talking with someone. If you see that enough to call it dating, imagine what the girls think being in the thick of it? Emotionally, it probably is coming across as your dad moving on right in front of them...when they aren't ready yet. It is fine and great if your brothe ris ready, but he should try to at least keep that to himself so that the daughters can get to that point.
K.
B.C. answers from Norfolk on May 17, 2009
My Mother's friend (she had/has no biological kids of her own) married a widower with three kids. Two boys one girl. He had been widowed several years, one of the boys was older (middle school age), the other two were a little younger. There were times when everyone got along, and times when things were not so nice. The girl in particular was very difficult as a teenager. It seems with many teens (no matter when they lost a parent), they resent anything that takes attention away from them. Difficulties are worse when the Dad and Step Mom do not make a united front. Situations when kids disrespect the Step Mom ("You're not my Mother!" every time an issue comes up, and then a Dad that does nothing about it when it happens (and this happens with some parents even without Step relations) can be very stressful. The kids eventually grew up, moved out, got married and my Moms friend and her husband are enjoying their retirement and grandchildren now. If the girlfriend is in it for the long haul, she's got to expect ups and downs over time. The kids might grow to love or hate her and a lot depends on the individuals involved.
R.D. answers from Washington DC on May 13, 2009
Wow...I can't imagine being ready to date someone in 6 months after losing my husband, even if we were to split I can't imagine that. But everyone is different. Maybe he does need someone to talk to, and she is who he needs to talk to, but can he not talk to her once the girls are in bed? If every night he is on the phone with her before they go to bed, he is not giving them what they need after just losing their mother. They need their dad to be 100% committed to them, not another woman. He should not be allowing his daughters to know he is dating someone else at all, in my opinion. I know that sounds harsh, but your kids should be the first priority...and they need him more than he needs this other lady right now. I hope it all works out for the best.
S.M. answers from Washington DC on May 13, 2009
6 months is too soon. He needs to process his feelings and allow his daughter to do the same while talking to him and bonding over this with her Father. The dust hasn't settled yet and won't for some time. He is foolish to think that he OR his daughter needs a new woman in their lives at this point.
My experience with loss is that when I was 16 my older brother was killed in an accident. My parents handled it the only way they were equipped to - which unfortunately was badly. I needed THEM - but I sought out comfort from boyfriends cos my parents weren't available. It set me on a troublesome path. Had they been there for me all those years ago - I am convinced that life would have been different for me. I had decades of junk to sort out and finally at 47 have a great life and have sorted it all out.
One of my BIG mistakes before I did get it sorted out was to marry a man who was recently divorced - his wife had cheated on him and they had 3 kids. To shorten the story - in retrospect he was trying to ease his pain by getting involved with me and providing a new Mom for his kids - it turned out a HUGE disaster and we divorced. Thank God that's in my past.
So in closing - get your brother some REAL help. This phone calling/internet stuff is just a bandaid. It will heap on more pain added to the loss of his wife in the longrun. They both need help with this. Blessings, S.
S.T. answers from Washington DC on May 13, 2009
no one can tell someone else how long they 'should' grieve or when they are ready to love again. this young widower deserves sympathy and support, not judgment and condemnation.
that being said, his girls need him badly, and it would certainly behoove him to wait until they're in bed before he talks to his new love. how can they NOT resent her when during this precious, intimate time of day for daddy/daughter bonding *she* is taking him away from them?
as someone who lost my mother at 10, my perspective is that any woman who comes into their dad's life will be resented, it's a matter of degree and how tactfully it's handled. his new lady needs to be graceful at being kept to the periphery for a while, and the girls need to be constantly assured and reassured that their dad is always there for them, that they are his first priority, and most of all, how very much he loved their mom. that's not to say that discourtesy is acceptable, but resistance on their part needs to be met with compassion and understanding.
and seriously.......no phone calls at the girls' bedtimes.
khairete
S.
J.B. answers from Washington DC on May 13, 2009
Im sorry but they do not need the love of this lady. They need EACHOTHER! He needs to get off the the phone and into his daughters life!! It is a painful time, but six months.... come on! I would not be ready for or want a relationship if I had just lost my husband!! His first responsibility is to his daughter to make sure that she is mentally recovered from this tragedy. There are too many cases of little girls daddy's ignoring them and those little girls searching for male appreciation elsewhere.
Email