K.S. asks from Clifton Heights, PA on October 23, 2006
How to Change a Bad Sleeping Habit Before It Gets Worse.
I have a 6 week old baby boy who wont sleep in his basinet or crib. He likes to sleep in his car seat, but I am not comfortable knowing he is sleeping in that. Also his crib is in the room he will be sharing with his older brother who is 3 years old, and I am worried about putting him in the room alone so soon. Also because his big brother likes to climb in the crib even though I tried to teach him that the crib is for his baby brotherand that he has his own big boy bed. So I am worried he will climb in at night when every one is asleep with the baby in the crib. So I am looking for advice on a safe place for my 6 week old to sleep so we both can sleep soundly.
Featured Answers
S.E. answers from Washington DC on October 24, 2006
My son had trouble sleeping at all unless I swaddled him. I also always had to let him "cry it out" for about 5-10 min and then he would go to sleep.
Have you thought of getting a crib tent? I got one because my son learned to climb out of his crib at too young of an age and wouldn't stay in and I would find him sleeping on the floor. Also sometimes the cat would get in there and I had a 5 year old step daughter as well that slept over occasionally in the same room.
Oh, another thing, he would NEVER sleep on his stomach, always would roll on his back. He is almost 4 now and still does to this day.
The crib tent was very useful though.
More Answers
R.S. answers from York on October 25, 2006
Hi Kristi. Both of my kids slept in their car seats until almost 5 months old. They both had severe GERD reflux (my daughter had Sandifer's Syndrome the "slient reflux" bad!) For the first few weeks they would sleep in their seats on the floor while i slept on the couch or bed so i could nurse... then after that i moved their seats into the crib and they both were about 5 months old when i transitioned them into their cribs w/o the seats... first i started with the naps during the day to get them used to sleeping on their backs with no seat... i had to use stuffed animals and a down feather pillow with them though b/c they were so used to the comfort of the car seat!... then eventually we started laying down in the crib at nights and it took a few days but they did great. now we have no problems at all (my daughter is currently 10months). both actually outgrew their infant seats around 6 months old (big babies!!). but the car seats saved my insanity for both sleep and knowing they weren't "choking" on their reflux. i thank my mom for that (she suggested it!)
when my daughter was just born (for about 2 months) i couldnt go up the stairs often b/c of csection and my 2 yr is LOUD so for her (short) naps i would put her (in her car seat) in our bathroom on the floor (our downstairs bathroom) and turn the exhaust (sp??) fan on (ours is super loud!!) and she slept soundly!! when someone would come to visit they'd ask where the baby was and when i'd tell them everyone thoutht it was funny but it WORKED! Yay for trying anything!
as for your 3 year old... just be consistent with him. sometimes you tell them a million times and it doesn't matter! but he's only 3 and like i said just be consistent. And i agree with the other moms about getting a crib tent. Never had one but i know some who did b/c their kids climbed out of the crib! good luck!
R.E. answers from Philadelphia on October 26, 2006
With him being so little I would try to keep something in your room for now, the crib if possible. I would be afraid that your older son would end up asleep on top of him.
G. answers from Philadelphia on October 23, 2006
Hi K. - my son did the same thing with his car seat at that age...believe me you'll know if he's not sleeping! I think they feel really secure in it because there's no room to move around...kinda like why they like to be swaddled.
Would definitely be careful with the older brother who likes to get in the crib...that could be very dangerous. I would recommend a bassinet for your room until the baby is old enough to roll over & lift himself up. Believe me...when the time is right he'll get use to his crib. It may take a few nights, but he'll get use to it. Hope this helps.
S.E. answers from Washington DC on October 24, 2006
My son had trouble sleeping at all unless I swaddled him. I also always had to let him "cry it out" for about 5-10 min and then he would go to sleep.
Have you thought of getting a crib tent? I got one because my son learned to climb out of his crib at too young of an age and wouldn't stay in and I would find him sleeping on the floor. Also sometimes the cat would get in there and I had a 5 year old step daughter as well that slept over occasionally in the same room.
Oh, another thing, he would NEVER sleep on his stomach, always would roll on his back. He is almost 4 now and still does to this day.
The crib tent was very useful though.
K.W. answers from Philadelphia on October 25, 2006
Have you read "The Happiest Baby on the Block?" It gives great advice on sleep for newborns. Have you been swaddling your baby before he goes to sleep? Sounds like to me that he likes the closeness of the car seat. I bet swaddling him would help!
H. answers from Pittsburgh on October 23, 2006
I'm not sure now even how it started - maybe a cold? - but my son slept well in the car seat. Since I also had a 17 month old and needed to be functional during the day so we let him sleep in the car seat. Actually we put the car seat in the bassinet and the car seat sat reclined enough that his head never fell forward or sideways. He seemed warm and cozy and happy in the car seat for a few months. When he started to move around a bit more when on the floor, we found he was more comfortable laying in his crib - he was too big for his bassinet...maybe 3-4 months. The bassinet was in our bedroom so we didn't move him from our room until that point. He still nursed a time or two at night and it was just easier having him close. Plus I wasn't ready to have him far from me. Since he was able to wiggle and roll, he could get himself into a position that made him feel comfortable for sleeping in his crib which he wasn't able to do earlier when he slept best in the car seat. For my son it was an easy transition. Ocassionally when he has a cold, we still put him in the car seat to sleep better at night. He's 20 months now so we use a reclining convertible car seat now instead of the infant seat. And we put it in our bedroom with the buckles attached loosely just to keep him safe. Good Luck finding something that works for you.
L.W. answers from Scranton on October 23, 2006
I would love to help but my son slept in the bed with me until he was 10 months because he had RSV and asthma and i was afraid if he was alone he would stop breathing again ( ti happened at 6 months old) and i wouldn't know, But when i went to put him in the crib at 10 months i started by letting him fall asleep witth me or in your case in the carseat and then switched him to the crib after he was asleep. Then after a week i put him in the crib and let him cry himself to sleep it took some getting used to on my part because listening to him cry and not do anything is my weakness and i can't bare to do it unless its nessecary but i think the carseat is fine for now keep the baby in your room so his brother won't "play" with him while he is sleeping and when you think he is old enough to let him cry for a bit then switch him is the best that i can say i hope it works out for you.
A.H. answers from Harrisburg on October 23, 2006
Hi K.!
I think it's OK for your baby to sleep in a carseat (for now). My youngest did. Honestly, I felt better with him in that because he would vomit frequently. I'm sorry but I don't believe in placing a sleeping baby on their back. When they vomit, the only place for it to go is back in their throat. My first two were belly sleepers and my last two were side sleepers. Each day, try making the transition to the bassinette or crib. Maybe let him cry a bit...he'll eventually exhaust himself and fall asleep. My babies slept in the same room as me till about three or four months old (when they can firmly lift and keep their head up).
Another suggestion...for day-time naps, put them in the living room or kitchen with you with a little noise. Night-time, along with night-time feedings, were in the bedroom with lights off and no sound. By two months my babies were sleeping all night!
As for your 3-yr old climbing into the crib?...I don't know. I never had that problem. At 3, you'd think he would understand when you tell him that is not allowed and it would wake the baby up by doing that. Hopefully another mom might have some good advice on that.
I hope I have helped you. Have a great day!
Email