37 answers

How Do I Deal with Feelings About Other Moms Who Let Their Babies Cry?

I'm embarresed at all the negative posts I've recieved and I know better than to word it they way I did. So I'm rewording this to try to make peace. I didn't mean to sound Self-righteous, trust me, I make mistakes every day!

I'm sorry that so many of you were offended. It was not my intention to cast judgement or attack you. I do believe that 99.99% of mothers love their children with all they can and they want what's best. It society that bugs me. It's all the books that make it ok to "train" your babies to sleep better by letting them cry. Were you at first a little upset by letting your baby cry, did you have to ignore at least a bit of natural instinct?

So I'm not judging you, please don't judge me either for being bothered by it. Babies crys are meant to get our attention, God made it that way on purpose. I can't help it if I'm bothered by it. I'm not going to get into why it bothers me because I don't want to offend anymore than I already aparently have.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

PLEASE you can stop posting now. :) I get it, I understand now! All of the posts were helpful, even the negative ones. It actually has helped me work through my feelings. All I can do is mother in the way I feel appropriate for my family and forget about what other mothers do. Really, it has made me feel better about it, but please, I can't take it anymore, i'm regreting ever posting this in the first place, no more posts. Let's all just get along, I'm sorry if I made anyone feel bad. Thanks! :)

Featured Answers

Sorry B., I just got my email. But, after reading these posts, I had to say something. I've been on this site for a couple of years & it seems to be changing directions. If someone touchs on a "contraversial" issue, there is a lot of judging & telling what "has" to be done. Co-sleeping & CIO are only 2 of those issues. These things are not black & white as some people seem to think. Children "do not have to CIO" to learn to sleep on their own. I also read someone say that CIO works because the child learns that crying will not get his/her needs met. That person suggested that she? didn't want her children to learn that lesson. Why not? In some cases, how else are they going to get met? How else are we going to know? I want my kids to know that no matter how old they are, their parents will be there when they cry. Yes, I also want them to learn how to meet those needs on their own, but what is a parent for?
How many people told B. not to judge how others raise? Most of you. Yet, how many people were judging B. by how she decided to raise hers? She shouldn't have felt the need to apologize for her question. Maybe she didn't use the "correct wording", but not all of us can say exactly the right thing so as not to offend anyone. I believe that this site was established for parents to come on & get advice from others parents on a variety of issues. If you don't like what someone has to say, you don't have to reply.
The bottom line is what some were saying. Everyone has different parenting styles & what works for me might not work for another. But, I'll tell you what works & ir you try & it works, GREAT. If not, it wasn't meant to be. Move on.
I know this might sound preachy, but I just couldn't sit back & let another post go.

1 mom found this helpful

I totally understand! I like to help those moms who are receptive. Perhaps getting involved in La Leche League? I know there are those who don't get it, but then I spend my time with those who want to learn. Sometimes you just have to let some people go (even though it's hard!)

1 mom found this helpful

Hi B.. I think cosleeping is a personal decision and if it works for you that is great. I have a 2 year old, and the only time he sleeps in my bed is at naptime when we can enjoy snuggling. That being said, when Chance is in his crib at night, it doesn't mean we ignore his cries. I rock him until he is almost asleep and put him to bed. When he wakes up and cries, we attend to his needs. There have only been a few occasions where I have let him cry, and he will soothe himself to sleep. I guess what I am trying to say is just because he is not in my bed, it doesn't mean I am ignoring his needs. I believe I am teaching him to be independent by giving him his own space.

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

I absolutely agree that letting a small infant cry, unattended, is unreasonable and unfair. I realize that some children are inconsolable, or are dealing with conditions that make crying more of a prevalent reality for some mothers, but I don't think that's to what B. is referring.

Correct me if I'm wrong, B., but I assumed you were talking about crying-it-out as a form of disciplining or "training" a child, i.e., the child is left alone to more or less sort out his/her own issues within a time frame conceived by an adult. Unattended crying-it-out is cruel, and you don't need to change your opinion on that. The reason that CIO works is because the child eventually learns that crying will not get his/her needs met. I don't want my children to learn that lesson, so I respond appropriately when my children cry.

I also cosleep, which naturally mitigates any potential nighttime stress for my children, making it much easier for me to meet their needs. I don't believe that CIO has any merit for young babies. Consequently, as a child gets older, any purpose that CIO could serve can be easily achieved with other, more humane, methods.

At any rate, I like your intuition, B. & you and your kids can hang out with us any time :)

ETA: co-sleeping v. crib sleeping is one debate, CIO is another. I wouldn't judge another parent for not co-sleeping, it's not an arrangement that works for everyone & safety is the top priority (although I do think parents are often wrongly advised about this issue.) However, CIO is a fairly black-and-white concept that has no place in intuitive parenting.

2 moms found this helpful

Please do NOT feel bad for what you wrote! You do not need to apologise...I was very encouraged as a result that there are so many moms who feel the same way I do about CIO. It is one thing to let a toddler who understands things when they are explained to him/her cry it out but I fear that it could be traumatic to an infant, not knowing why Mommy is not coming to help when this is the only way I have to let her know I need her or just want to be held. What's wrong with enjoying our babies when they are little and not trying to make them grow up too fast? Does an infant NEED to be independent? Why not wait til the child actually understands why he's being allowed to cry? Sounds more like detachment disorder than healthy independence. However, if you're attempting to TRAIN them and they're just fussing a little, NOT screaming their head off, that does'nt sound as bad. Don't let all these defensive responses keep you from speaking what you believe is true! I didn't think you worded it badly. What's wrong with honestly sharing how we're feeling?

2 moms found this helpful

This is going to sound harsh, but really, you need to just deal with it. I'm very glad that you're able to be a SAHM and have found a parenting style that works for you, but I assure you that there are other means of parenting that can rear beautiful, well-adjusted children. I work full-time, but my children are sweet, respectful and learning to be open to the many different (unique/special/interesting)ways that people are instead of judgemental because they are not just like us.

1 mom found this helpful

All I can say to help you deal with your feelings about how other mom's raise their kids...which I can understand to a certain extent why it bugs you....is this...everyone does the best they can and does what works for them. I'm sure you want your daughters to get along in the world & accept people that have different ideas from them, & I'm sure your strength in conviction that you are instilling in them is a good thing :)

1 mom found this helpful

My advice is to relax. Your children are very young and you have much to learn. You will find that as your kids get older, you will have many, many issues and feelings to deal with that make this issue seem like a cake walk and these issues will come from not only other people's habits and kids, but from your own. I have five beautiful, really good kids. And from what I can tell from you, you feel probably much like I did as a young mother in that I consider myself a really good mother. I still do. My world revolves around my family. I always felt like my love and respect for my kids would save me from many of the challenges other parents have with kids. Now, with pre-teens, I can no longer live in that fairy land. My kids are very well behaved and do great in school, but as they get older, they will test you and push you. They need to do that to grow. That's when you must be consistent. Especially girls. Yes, even your little angels will have mood swings and fall, at least a little, under the influence of the pre-teen mouth. Also, you have to learn tolerance. That doesn't mean you have to agree with other parents methods, but there's nothing you can do to change it and you may be surprised at how well some people's kids turn out in the end and that some of these "unlikely" methods really work. Good Luck.

1 mom found this helpful

I can relate. It is difficult to be respectful\tolerant of things that we find so opposite of our personal values.

The only way I can reconcile this (and this isn't just in parenting...) is to a) remember that other families make different choices and I don't know all the factors they used to make those choices and b) try to be a good example of why/how I feel my way works. And I bite my tongue a lot. ;)

The only time I would make an overt move to intervene in any way was if I saw something I felt was actually legally abusive. Then I feel a moral conviction to say/do something. Several years ago I had a neighbor who I saw beating her children (I'm not talking about spanking, she was *beating* them) and I called CHild Protective Services. That was an awful feeling, but I felt like I had to do it...

Best of luck!

1 mom found this helpful

I feel exactly the same way as you do! There is NO WAY that I could listen to my baby cry and do nothing about it!
But, everyone's parenting styles are different. You just have to do what feels right for you and your family.

1 mom found this helpful

wow it seems this post came at a conventient time, there was another post that specifically mention CIO just yesterday or today. I'm an AP momma and i get a ton of grief for it but it's my choice, just as every other parenting choice is the choice of the parents. Judging those that don't think as we think really only causes all the problems we are trying to prevent with our parenting style. nad isn't there scripture somewhere about judging others.... I guess my point is that you can only control your small little corner of the world and if your parenting style raises great kids who can then in turn make a differenec in their own little corner then you are doing something right, and isn't that what truely matters? it isn't so much the path we take to get their that matters but the end result, we all want to raise good kids, maybe if we spent more time educating those that want to be educated and less time judging the world could be the place we want it to be, but none of us are faultless, and co-sleeping is great if it works for your family, but there are kids that won't co-sleep or parents that jsut can't do it, there is no right or wrong, it's all subjective and untill someone can come alone and say I'm the PERFECT parent and have the PERFECT children i say to each his own, and then offer my advice to those that listen and want help, and teach my children that while your way may be right for you it might not be right for someone else.

1 mom found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.