A.M. asks from Latonia, KY on November 24, 2008
Holiday Gathering Woes
Hello, my husband and I both come from homes with divorced parents. Each side is remarried and they ALL live near us. Holidays are a nightmare as our families think that we should come and visit each side and expect equal time. With the new baby, travleing all day does come easily or lightly but everyone is throwing fits b/c we stated that we would have to split up Christmas and thanksgiving. Does anyone else have this trouble and how did you stand firm. We love our families but the thought of holidays is stressing me out SOO much that I'm worried I won't even enjoy it with the new blessing!
1 mom found this helpful
Featured Answers
S.H. answers from Fort Wayne on November 25, 2008
We do the yearly switching too. One side of the family gets Easter and the other side gets Thanksgiving. We do Christmas Eve at home, just us. Christmas Day at the in-laws, and Boxing day with my family, works great because then my sister and her family travels on Christmas Day when there is no traffic.
1 mom found this helpful
C.S. answers from Fort Wayne on November 25, 2008
I totally understand where you are coming from! The familys need to understand that its not easy to make a presence at all gathering. Let them know how you feel and maybe tell them its this way or no way. Good Luck!!
1 mom found this helpful
K.S. answers from Toledo on November 25, 2008
we go throught the same thing every holiday. I got so tired of going 3-4 places in one day so we now alternate who we actually see on the holiday. I write it down on the calender whose place we visit and the next year we switch. we will visit the other ones around the holiday but not everyone in 1 day ne more.
More Answers
J.C. answers from Cleveland on November 25, 2008
I am a mother of two married children, one with kids and one that has not started his own family as well. My husband and I began having a family Thanksgiving the weekend before the holiday. We make the traditional dinner and each of our kids and their families come and enjoy the day immensly. It is the gathering and family togetherness not a date on the calander that matters. As for Christmas my parents taught me that Christmans should be spent in ones own home, not traveling from parents to parents, children need that holiday to grow and nurture their own memories not grandparents memories. There are enough days in the holiday season to start new traitions and maintain a loving connection with each side of your respective families. I am the mother of sons and so often we are accused of being bullies and get a bad rap often in the media, but I love my children too much to create unnecessary friction in their lives, it is the time we spend together that is important and I can enjoy a Saturday Thanksgiving with out stress far better than A Thursday Thanksgiving filled with tension. Think about this and if each of your parents continue to cause tension in your lives, stand up for your new family and begin all new trations pepper with traditions form each but begin them at your home not some one elses.
4 moms found this helpful
J.R. answers from Toledo on November 25, 2008
Like many, I can relate. But my parents didn't get divorced until I was married. This is how I see it. When my parents chose to get divorced, they chose splitting up grandkid time in half also. Unless they can all be together at our house and get along (they can).
This is YOUR family now: you and your husband and kid(s). You do what's best for you guys. When you have your own family, the holidays are about YOUR family. We say "look, we're having christmas eve-everyone is welcome" and have christmas for us. If the parents don't like it or don't want to come over, then they can come over in a few days.
I remember being stressed out being at my dad's house, where people smoke. I felt so bad having to leave before we had christmas dinner, but it was about doing what's best for the kids. That was hard to say "sorry, but we have to go". But again, you need to make sure you, your husband and kid are doing what's right for YOU GUYS, not your parents. They should know better!
3 moms found this helpful
S.S. answers from Cincinnati on November 25, 2008
My suggestion is to alternate holidays. In the 11 years my husband and I have been married, we have spent the actual day with one family and the next day with the other. Fortunately, it has worked pretty well for us (it was a little shaky in the beginning for part of my side of the family). Now that we have a daughter, it's nice to know where we're going for the holidays. And everyone knows they'll get to see us at some point. Last year we celebrated Thanksgiving Day with my husband's family and then had a full Thanksgiving meal the next day with my family. You'll find something that works well for your family (you, your husband, and daughter). Everyone else may grumble and complain, but they'll just have to learn to share. :)
2 moms found this helpful
M.V. answers from Cleveland on November 25, 2008
Yeah, I think we all can understand where you are coming from. First thing's first - let go of the guilt. You can only do what you can do and that's it. Your main priority is your child. Traveling all day with a 4-month old would be miserable...for everyone involved. One way to combat the issue is to have Christmas at your house...or do Christmas Eve with one family...Christmas morning at your home with another...Christmas afternoon with another...and then the day after Christmast or one day the weekend after Christmas with the final one. Bottom line, you have to do what's best for you and your family. You can't be 4 places at once and no one should expect that of you. If they want quality time with you and your family then they'll need to concede and respect the distribution of the holiday.
That being said, we do our Christmas with my BF's mom on Christmas Eve, and with the rest of his family on Christmas Day and then with my mom on the day after Christmas. That way we aren't having to rush anywhere. We can relax and enjoy our time with everyone.
Good luck.
2 moms found this helpful
R.B. answers from Toledo on November 26, 2008
Hi A.,
The holidays are really stressful for a lot of people. Too much activity in too short a time. I give you permission to do what is in the best interests of you, your baby, and your husband. Visiting all those people in one day I imagine would result in exhaustion and bitterness, rather than in peace and joy and good will to all relatives! A couple of years ago, I wanted to start our own traditions, so my husband, toddler and I stayed home for Christmas. While this didn't go over well with my mother, my parents did come to my house a couple of days after Christmas, and we had a lovely visit! My sister also came on another day. In January we travelled to visit extended family. If you feel overwhelmed with just the thought of it all, don't put yourself through it. Christmas can be celebrated over a few days, or a couple of weeks, or a month. It doesn't all have to happen on this one day. A good response to those who are negative toward your decision would be, "I understand that's how you feel." Tell them you are starting your own family tradition for Christmas day, and that you will look forward to seeing them on such and such a day. It is perfectly reasonable to rotate seeing different relatives for each holiday, and don't forget Easter as a possible time to also get together. You can't please everyone, so please yourself first. Just politely but firmly express your decision, and don't worry about the response you get. Tell whoever is on the phone nagging you that you have a pot boiling on the stove or are about to have a bowel movement, and get off the phone before they can stress you out. Enjoy your holidays!! R.
2 moms found this helpful
M.M. answers from Dayton on November 25, 2008
oh this sounds just like my childhood!
my family realized a long time ago that not everyone can make it on christmas day (this even includes easter and thanksgiving too) because of the size of the family (one side has 30 one side has 28 with all the aunts/cousins/etc)
thanksgiving/christmas day is saved for my mom's. we have thanksgiving/christmas at my grandma's the sunday before. and the otherside is the sunday after that way everyone has time to go to all of the get together's and not feel rushed/stretched/etc. it has made sooo much more sense and more time to actually enjoy getting together with the families.
i hope this helps!
2 moms found this helpful
R.E. answers from Mansfield on November 25, 2008
Hi A.,
I can relate to your situation! My parents are divorced and have been for many many years but still can not seem to be in the same room as each other. My dad is also remarried so we have step family that has always treated me and my sisters like family (for 22 years). Then we have my in-laws who have learned to be flexable because of my disfunctional family. Even for my childrens b-day parties my dad will not attend because my mom and my sister (who he is not talking to) is there. It gets so frustrating because they are adults and it is the kids who really suffer.
What my husband I did for the holidays is split it up as evenly as possible. If your family lives close it should help. Christmas eve we go to my in-laws and the kids open up their presents then. Christmas mid morning we go to my dads and christmas day night we do something with my mom and that side. We used to go to my step-grandmas christmas morning but it is way to much so this year we are having it the saturday before christmas.
My advice to you is to talk it over with your husband and figure out what you are willing to do and plan accordingly. Maybe see some family christmas eve and others christmas day. If you have family members that can stay in the same room together without fighting...kill two birds with one stone and have them all there at once. I know you feel pulled in many different ways and you do not want to hurt anyones feelings, but you have a family now and it is time for you to make your own traditions. If your family really wants to see your family they should have no problem complying to your standards. Stand firm...and let them know exactly the way you want things to go during the holidays! If you start this early on in your childs life it should be easier as the years go by. I wish you luck and happy holidays!
2 moms found this helpful
B.B. answers from Indianapolis on November 24, 2008
There have been a few family gatherings we "got out of" because one of ours wasn't feeling too well.
I know it's a lot to consider, but maybe have it at your place, and everybody brings a dish and don't be afraid to "assign" dishes.
Otherwise, stick to your guns, and just let everyone know, "It isn't that we don't love you, but we are POOPED! We hope you understand that having a newborn is a lot of work. We would rather spend a lot of quality time with everyone and feel the best way to do that is to split Thanksgiving and Christmas this way."
Now that being said, there are things you can do to make traveling a little easier. (We live 2 hours from my family.) Let the people who's places you're visiting know that arrival time might be a little tricky because you'll need to time it around baby's feeding's. Feed her, then once she dozes off - put her in the car seat and go. Be willing to sit in the back seat during the trip in case she wakes up and needs a pacifier or something.
Take her normal diaper bag with you, but make another one that will actually be the one you take in with you.
We have what we call a "booty bag" that we keep in the car to take into places with us. When our girls were younger, we had it stocked with: a package of wipes, a few diapers, a couple of empty plastic grocery bags for diaper changes (to put the dirty diaper in), Ready to feed formula (they have 8 oz. bottles, and 2 oz. bottles at the stores), a container for some dry baby cereal (that could be put into the formula if we needed it), gas drops, tylenol, booty balm (bag balm, desitin, aquafor, whatever), bottles, bibs, pacifiers, 1 or two extra change of clothes. It sounds like a lot, but it worked out very well for us. If you don't have an extra diaper bag, a backpack will work, or a small carry-on size travel bag will work too.
ALSO, bring a cooler and any snacks & drinks you want for the trip.
It really doesn't take that long to put those things together, and it's amazing at how much it makes the trip more tolerable.
ANyway - just a few thoughts....good luck!
2 moms found this helpful
Email