M.L. asks from Raleigh, NC on August 24, 2009
Help with Friendship Dilemma
First I need to give everyone a little background....I have a friend, who I have been close with since college and she and I have girls the same age. Our friendship has had some bumps along the road, as do many, and we are mostly phone friends even though we live in the same neighborhood. We parent differently and our children socialize less than 1 time a month outside of school.
Well it turns out my just 3 yo daughter bit her daughter( also 3) in the face at camp the other day (no broken skin but a bite none the less). It was over not sharing crayons. Apologies were said (in the presence of my friend and I and during the school day and following the incident) Additionally, I punished my daughter by removing some of her favorite things, like dresses and not allowing her to socialize with her afternoon play-date. We (my husband and I) expressed to my daughter how wrong she acted and what could have happened to her friends face and how she would not want to be bit either (btw, my daughter bit another child 6 months ago at the same school).
This is the good part....My friend calls me not 5 minutes after I return home from camp and it crazy upset over this incident. I guess the 5 minute car ride stirred up some anger. She starts by stating that my daughter has problems and maybe should not attend camp or preschool in the fall and she is going to call the school and let her concerns be known. Than she starts recapping some interactions with our children that validate her point of view. Which in my view have more to do with her child having been an only child until recently and having poorer sharing abilities than most, if not all, of my daughters friends ( BTW, her daughter is taught that she does not have to share if she does not want to). And the fact that my daughter has an older (4yo) brother she deals with which makes her more assertive. I stated that biting is a common but unpleasant way some 2-3 yo express frustration and sometimes over stimulation...not to belittle the incident but to try and help give her some perspective. Of course, I apologies again to her and ask her and even ask her what she thinks I should do because I obviously am not doing my job ( I did not say that last part tho) She stated "no" she did not but to make her stop and I said, I can not make her do anything but I have done what I think is appropriate. She also said that kids should not go to preschool if they bite and I said noone would be in preschool if that was the case (except her daughter) and than I said I could not wait to have this conversation when her son was 2 and daughter was 4. Anyway it was not a very pleasant conversation but my husband said I was very calm and handled myself well. ( he was their when I was talking on the phone)
A little info on my friend....My friend is very protective over her daughter and does not have play-dates at her home and really does not attend many play-dates with anyone at all( maybe once every 2 months). Most of her daughters interactions are with her parents or grandmother but she does attend preschool and summer camp which started last september.
My question is, what do I say to this woman at this point...She and I have not spoken, except the hello at camp, since the incident ( last wednesday). I did write her and say lets talk when you get home (she is on vacation this week). I want very badly to try and help her understand that 3 yo sometimes are not so nice and it is not all my daughters fault for what happened because she daughter is a poor sharer and my daughter is not a social reject and is very lovely 80% of the time..which in my book is great!!! But my gut says just say "listen I am sorry you are so upset but you have to understand that our kids are still very young and this happens sometimes and hopefully our kids can continue to be friends because they do like each other". I know I am sounding like a 5 yo but this is really eating at me and I want all you moms out there to tell me if I am not thinking correctly about this biting business.
So What Happened?™
So this is what happened... we did not really speak for 4 week and she finally called and the flood gates opened and it turns out things are in a much better. We agreed that we need to work together for our friendship to continue and that we have not been very good to each other and in turn this will allow us to help our children to interact better. We are making a better effort not to judge each other but to be open and help each other. we are actively trying to make play dates and I am very pleased hat we are still friends. Thanks to all, good bad and the ugly responses alike. M.
More Answers
S.A. answers from Raleigh on August 24, 2009
EDIT...
I just wanted to add that I'm a mother of an only child but grew up with multiple siblings (5 brothers and sisters and a niece the same age as my youngest brother) and this stuff DOES happen, and fairly often, especially with 2-3 year olds!
ORIGINAL:
I think with your daughter you handled it appropriately - both you and your husband communicated that it's not okay to bite and why (because it hurts her friends when she bites them). Punishing her showed her that there are consequences to her actions when she does things that aren't okay. You might also want to teach her other ways of dealing with her frustrations since she does have a history of biting.
I used to work in a daycare as a teacher for the Toddler room and as assistant teacher in the 2-3yr old room, and biting is VERY common behavior - for the very reason you pointed out - frustration! It's such a tough time at this age sometimes.
I'm a fairly "old-school" parent, despite being one of the (if not THE) youngest mothers in my son's class (I'm 28, he's 8 and in 3rd grade). When my son bit me for the first time out of frustration, I bit him back right away - and hard enough to leave a mark. He had bit before while playing and I had told him "No biting, that hurts mommy!" but this time was different. After that, he NEVER bit again (and he was younger than 18 months when this happened). Maybe your daughter doesn't realize how much biting hurts? Has she ever been bit by another child? If that happens (or happened), make sure to make the connection between her pain when she gets bit and the kids that she bites. At three, she might not grasp that on her own yet.
As far as the friend, she doesn't sound like a very good friend. From what you've said, it seems like you handled it well - you accepted responsibility for your daughters actions (some parents try to deny that their child would ever do such a thing!) and you apologized. This other mom seems to be over the top. Personally, if I was in your situation, I would discontinue this friendship because it's not healthy for you to feel like you've got to defend your parenting to this mom. Her threatening to call the school and make sure they know about your child's biting habit is too much. You should make them aware of it yourself if she is already enrolled but also make sure they know it's a behavior that's not acceptable in your house and it's something you are working on with your daughter.
If the other mom apologizes for over-reacting and you want to continue the friendship - go for it. Personally I evaluate friendships on what I get out of them - if I don't get some sort of happiness out of having a friendship, then what's the point? Evaluate this relationship with this woman and determine if it's one you really want to keep having, then act accordingly.
I wish you the best of luck!
4 moms found this helpful
G.W. answers from Chattanooga on August 25, 2009
I think you've handled the situation really well so far. I've got a 2-year-old who goes to daycare and we routinely get or see incident reports where someone has bitten someone else. It's super-common, mainly because it WORKS! My suspicion is that since this is this mom's 1st child, she may not have had enough exposure to other kids to know just how common biting is and how it eventually goes away for everyone (they have much more sophisticated and annoying ways of getting their way as they get older :)
My suggestion is to say exactly what you mentioned as your gut reaction. You ARE sorry she got so upset, and you appear to truly want the kids to stay friends (although you may want to keep in mind that this will probably not be the last time you child angers her in some weird way). I don't think that's a harsh response at all and it totally leaves the ball in her court. You can just say your piece and leave it at that. Whatever her reaction, just know that you've done the best you can.
Good work, Mom!
3 moms found this helpful
T.C. answers from Lexington on August 25, 2009
Just drop it! Obviously the other woman has. If you want more drama in your life then just keep picking at this. You are trying to force your opinion of how children behave to a woman that does not agree with you. You are acting self righteous. I do NOT agre with you that mostly all children bite. I do agree with your friend that a biter should not be in school. I don't think your child is a social reject in regards to this behavior, but I would consider her a threat to my child and you as a threat as well in trying to convince me that this is normal.
You're forcing yourself on someone who has had enough of it. Back off or it will be considered harrassement. It's not as if your life depends on her being your friend. You 2 are at separate phases in your lives and it doesn't mesh. Accept that, be curteous and find new friends.
2 moms found this helpful
S.D. answers from Nashville on August 25, 2009
I think you have done everything that you can do. At some point you just have to let it go. Some parents never figure it out that kids are going to make mistakes and you just have to talk to them about what they did wrong and move on.
2 moms found this helpful
R.F. answers from Raleigh on August 25, 2009
From your description, it sounds like things will either be ok or they won't. Any amount of discussion/explanation on your part would be effort without resolution. A final apology is probably all that I would suggest. Trying to explain your thoughts on why the behavior was expressed is probably wasted breath. Until people experience things like this from their own child, I don't think they can begin to understand it. I know you want to save a friendship (yours and your daughter's), but sometimes relationships change and there isn't much you can do about it. It sounds like your relationship was fading before this. It may be the final straw, or it may blow over. Either way, know that you have done what you could (apologize and punished appropriately). Best of luck, I hope you can get past this and don't let it eat at you.
2 moms found this helpful
K.S. answers from Raleigh on August 25, 2009
Well, I am 64, raised 3 children and a niece, so, 4. No one ever bit anyone's face. I think if one had been bitten, it would take a long time for me to get over it. Biting is very serious. Obviously, with the children so close, she is getting, and probably has to be, more aggressive. Has he bitten her? It is usually something they do as a last resort, because they don't know what else to do. I would give this relationship awhile to cool off. It may be severed, if so, move on. Many times that is when you change friends, has to do with your children. If you really care about keeping this up. I would take your daughter to the toy store, buy a gift for the child and both of you take it to her. Have your dd make a verbal apology to her and give her the gift. I would talk to dd everyday, and tell her no biting, that hurts sooo badly.
Good luck.
2 moms found this helpful
D.B. answers from Charlotte on August 24, 2009
Hi M.,
I think you handled it pretty well, though what you said to her really won't give her any perspective. Your description of her really explains the reason why what you say won't make much difference. She is protective, doesn't provide opportunities for her daughter to socialize outside of preschool, and thinks other parents can "make" their kids behave. This is unfortunately the end of your real friendship. Just be willing to accept that, stop apologizing, and move on. She will find out at some point with either her daughter or son that they aren't perfect, though she may never admit it.
My children were "victims" of biters. I always understood the difficulties involved. What was important to my daycares and to me was that the parents 1) cared about the fact that my child was hurt 2) sought help from their pediatrician or some professional to help them work with the daycare to help their child get past this phase and 3) didn't try to turn the tables on my son as if it were his fault he got bit. You certainly care, and you haven't tried to blame her child. But I urge you to talk to your pediatrician to get some advice on how to help your child. You need to know what helps, because you probably will have this happen again. I would proactively go talk to the director of the preschool about the incident and ask her to explain to you how the teachers help their children who bite. Then you know the school's policy. I've written in my posts before about what one of my daycares did to help the kids. There are several threads here in Mamasource that talk about this problem, so perhaps if you look through them you might find some ideas.
This woman will throw away more friendships than just yours over the years, M.. I learned a long time ago that no one's kids are perfect, and parents should just try to be kind to each other. For parents who can't be kind and are mean to me over my kids' mistakes, well, I can't worry myself to death about it.
All my best to you,
D.
2 moms found this helpful
M.B. answers from Charlotte on August 25, 2009
It's hard these days, connecting with people and forming quality friendships, because there is so much involved. You need to connect on so many different levels. Sometimes your kids get along, but you don't or vis versa, or sometimes the husbands dislike each other, or your mothering techniques differ, which makes things hard. I've learned that you can't force these connections. Either you'll fit naturally along side each other--or you won't. I wouldn't worry about it too much. The best friendships just fall into place naturally :)
Unfortunately, biting is considered a pretty serious thing these days, what with all the vaccinations and concern over infection and disease causing bacteria. Mouths carry a host of germs that, though harmless to us, can make others very sick if the skin is broken. Biting is taken so seriously in some schools, that kids have been expelled and parent's sued over it. Almost every kid gives biting a try a time or two. That is completely normal. But it should be handled as very serious offence. Your daughter is very intelligent and will understand if you make it clear how you feel about biting :)
2 moms found this helpful
Email