D.E. asks from Romulus, MI on September 25, 2008
Help... My 1 Yr Old Will Not Sleep Through the Night!!
Hello all, I am the proud mother of a beautiful 1 ye old daughter (9/13/08) the only issue I have is she is still not sleeping through the night, occassionally she does but she doesn't more than she does. The dr tells me there is nothing physically wrong with her and that she should not be needing a bottle throughout the night anymore. I have been told to let her cry it out, well that is easier said than done when your child is crying and I personally can not sleep if I know she is awake in her room, my instinct tells me to comfort her, however nothing works. Sometimes all she wants is a bottle and other times she won't even take the bottle she just throws it out and cries. I work full time and the lack of sleep is definitely taking it's toll on my day to day life. Unfortunately my 3 yr old also suffers because myself and my husband take turns tending to her and then we are so tired from being up most times for the better part of the night and working all day we do not have the energy to paly with him for hours like he'd like when we get home. It makes me so sad, I'm on the verge of crying as I write this. If anyone has any kind of suggestion that we can try please share with me we are desperate to help her get to sleep through the night alittle more consistently.
So What Happened?™
I wanted to thank everyone who responded to my request for advice on getting my daughter to sleep thru the night. She has been and it has been great, I had to try a few different methods until we found one that worked but I am going with it. My only comment to some of the mothers who repsonded is, lets try and remember that we all parent differently and that sometimes we may come across very judgemental and when mothers ask for advice on here they are not wanting to read messages that make them feel as if they are failures, they are already having a problem and seeking help. I appreciated all the advice I was given and thank all of you had great information and I took alittle from everyone, however, I was so sensitive to the issue that some of them comments as helpful as they were made me feel as tho, I was not doing anything right with my daughter. Again thanks to all of you
More Answers
J.T. answers from Grand Rapids on September 25, 2008
D. -
As hard as it is, you need to let her learn to self-soothe and put herself back to sleep. She definately should not need the bottle anymore during the night - she should be down to 3-4 meals a day at this point. It's hard sometimes, but she needs to learn.
Here are some of the things that we started practically from day 1 - and the Ped. also recommended them later.
- have attachment/soothing items - pacifier, blankie, small animal, some sort of lovie that they can use to help regulate themselves
- always put them in their beds awake and let them fall alseep by themselves. This doesn't mean that you can't rock them, just don't rock them to sleep and then lay them down.
- we play music (CD, iPod, etc) all night long. Usually classical, sometimes kids music - but something soothing. Nothing too up beat that would get them 'energized'. You need something relaxing.
-keep bedtime the same every night
- if they wake up crying in the night, get up, give them their pacifier and/or lovie and you leave and go back to bed. If they continue to cry for excessive (20+ minutes) - not just wimpering or wining but really crying. Get them up, rock/hold them until they are calmed down but not asleep and but them back in their bed.
- this is a biggy ---- be consistant.
I know it's hard some times. You want so bad to go and get them, rock them to sleep, let them sleep with you - I've been there. It's so tempting just to bring them back to snuggle with you knowing that everyone will sleep then, but it will only make it worse in the long run. The older they are, the harder it will be to break them of habits like this.
Good luck -
J.
Working mom of 2; daughter 3, son almost 1. Up until 6 months or so ago, I was working full time out of the home, now I am 3 days out and 2 days working from my home.
2 moms found this helpful
N.G. answers from Detroit on September 26, 2008
Oh, How I have felt your pain and sleepless nights! When I was in your position, my sister in law, referred a book to me that provided me with the best information to get your child to sleep. Her sister in law gave it to her and my pediatrician referred me the same book and it is one that I give to all my friends to help them put their baby on a schedule and get them sleeping through the night. It is filled with other parent testimonials who have been in the same or similar situations with sleep deprevation. The author is the head of Chicago Children's Hospital Sleep clinic. It does require a few nights of letting them cry it out, not more than five, ususally it works within three nights, but hang in there and don't give in. It does work. Iknow it is hard to listen to your baby cry, but he touches on this many times in the book that it does not hurt them. He does note that it is hard, but to stick to his advice because it works.
hope you find this book useful and it gets you and your family the much needed rest you need. The name of the book is Happy sleep Habits, Healthy Child by Dr. Weisinbluth (sp on the last name, sorry). But again, this book was a life savior for my husband and I with our first and helped us wonderfully with our second child as well. Best of luck to you and your family.
N.
2 moms found this helpful
S.C. answers from Lansing on September 25, 2008
D.,
I worked full-time while raising my sons too and know just what you are talking about. Although most doctors and other mothers will advise against putting a child in your own bed I found that getting my sleep was far more important than our sleeping arrangements. Our older son slept in our bed off and on for quite awhile, then by two years old was sleeping in his own bed. You sound like you are on the brink of a meltdown and getting some relief for that is probably more important than anything. If you don't start getting some much needed rest you could fall asleep driving to work, or just take it out on your children or husband. My sons are both young adults now and we had many issues over their growing up years. One thing I know for certain is that whatever "bad habit" (i.e. sleeping in your bed, etc} they may have does not last forever. They all eventually give up their binkies, bottles and want their own rooms in their own time. Believe me, the day will come soon enough when you won't be able to roust them from their beds for love nor money, just make sure YOU survive until that day comes.
My best to you,
S.
1 mom found this helpful
J.H. answers from Lansing on September 26, 2008
Hi D.
I have read through the previous posts with interest and there are some very strong opinions on this subject! I thought I would just add my own experience with the matter, and hopefully you will get a litle something out of it. I have three girls - 5, 3, and 10mo. All of them have co-slept with me. They have also all grown out of it. Some would suggest that it will get harder to break the habit later if you don't stop it early. I can't speak for other kids, but with mine this was not the case. I don't know if this is something you would try, but it is what worked for me. I am a much better mom with a good night's sleep!
Although I am sure she doesn't NEED the bottle, I am sure that it is hard to not give it to her if she seems to want it. I would probably not bring it to her, though, if she has been tossing it. I think the suggestion of making sure she has plenty to eat including a snack before bed, is a good one. Also a good bedtime routine could be helpful, if you don't have one already - bath, books, spend a little time in her room with her before leaving her to sleep in there. Also, I liked the previous suggestion of getting her a special toy or something to snuggle.
I just know that as a parent, despite all of the books you may read and advice you get, you just have to go with what FEELS right for you. I figure if something makes both my baby and myself miserable why do it?
Good luck and let us know how it goes!
1 mom found this helpful
S.J. answers from Detroit on September 26, 2008
I also disagree with the "cry it out" method. I just wouldn't feel comfortable letting my child scream in the other room, scared and alone while I just ignore it and try to sleep. I have an almost five year old son and when he was a baby I actually had his crib in my room until he was almost two years old. When I moved it back into his room he of course liked sleeping in my room better than his own but a little after a week (JUST ONE WEEK) he was totally fine. Sleeps in his room every night all by himself. You will get through it, you doing the best you can. You just need to find what it is that will work for you and your family. Good luck
1 mom found this helpful
C.L. answers from Detroit on September 25, 2008
I agree with Sue... you have to do what works for YOU. If it's easier and works better for you, then let her sleep with you in your room or in your bed.
I don't agree that habits are formed at this age if you tend to their needs and hold them instead of letting them cry it out.
For example, my son didn't want to be put down really ever or for naps until he was about 12 months, then he was fine for naps and at night... no issue. I think we have to do what FEELS right for us.. to me it wouldn't feel right to let my son cry it out.
Everyone at all ages form new habits as needed. Check out Dr. Sears's books.. it might be helpful. Maybe your daugther is going through a growth spurt, teething or just feels like she wants you at night.
1 mom found this helpful
D.S. answers from Detroit on September 26, 2008
A wonderful book: The Sleep Lady's Gentle Guide to Getting Your Child to Fall Asleep, Stay Asleep and Wake Up Happy. You can google the sleep lady in case I got the title wrong.
dana
1 mom found this helpful
R.H. answers from Cincinnati on September 26, 2008
Hi D..
I have to disagree with many moms who have commented here. Every baby is different, and to say that ANY baby should not need a bottle in the night is ridiculous.
I am not a CIO mamma. I'm sure you guessed that already. Even at 1, I do not believe you can comfort your child too much. I can tell when my daughter is fussing just because she thinks it should not be bedtime and when she is in need of something else. I'm sure you can tell the difference in the cry as well.
First, I would make sure she is not hungry going to bed. Fill her up at dinner time. Depending on your bedtime routine, maybe give her a snack before bed.
Second, make sure she isn't sleeping too much during the day. Check and see what the nap schedule is at daycare. That may need to be adjusted.
Third, offer some kind of lovey for her to have in the crib at night. Maybe YOU sleep with it for a couple of nights so it smells like you.
Fourth, try anything and everything. Maybe sleeping with you will do the trick. Maybe sleeping in a packnplay in your room will do the trick. She may just be going through a phase where she needs to know you are near. Seperation anxiety is pretty strong around this age, you need to reinforce the fact that you ARE there and you ARE near and WILL be there for her.
Letting her CIO in my opinion is not good. 1) it doesn't giver her any tools to self soothe. They CIO'ers say they need to learn to self-soothe. Well, by letting baby lie in the crib what tools are you giving them so they can learn to self-soothe. I don't like to fall asleep crying, why would my baby. 2) If they are in need of something all it teaches them is you won't be there to help them. So...that's not good.
You need to find what works best for you. I know its tough when you have to get up and work. Every baby goes through phases. She also could be teething. Check her gums... see if they are swollen. Often times a teething baby will wake at night because they have slowed down and now realized 'hey! that hurts!' During the day they might be too busy playing to notice.
I hope you can find something that works for both of you.
1 mom found this helpful
Email