Help! Baby Boy Is 9 Months Old and Still Sleeps in Our Bed.

Updated on May 11, 2008
A.P. asks from San Diego, CA
8 answers

I need a break. My baby will only sleep if I am holding him or if he is next to me in bed. I do breast feed and he eats often. I should have started him in his crib when he was only 3 or 4 months, but now it is impossible. I have tried the cry it out, but after an hour I just can't take it. He seems pretty insistent on screaming at the top of his lungs the whole time. I have tried coming in and reassuring him without picking him up, then letting him cry and scream for another 30-40 minutes. How long do I do this? Do really have to let him scream and cry? Is this the only way. He is a big boy and pretty determined to get his way. I need some time with my husband and to get things done around the house. Right now it is 24/7. I don't know what to do. I feel so horrible letting him cry. Everyone tells me that this is the only way. It just breaks my heart.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Thanks everyone! Well, it has only been 2 nights since I started this whole crib thing. It has not been as bad as I thought. I'm sure it will be crazy on some nights and not so bad on others. He had a long day playing in the sand at the beach and then playing with his cousin. He was very, very tired. I nursed him and then put him in his crib at about 9:00. He slept for 2 hours then woke up. My husband went in and rubbed his back, he fell back to sleep, then woke up about 20 minutes later. I went in but he just screamed. My husband went back in with a bottle with water in it. My baby was crying so he choked on the water. That was traumatic. So I nursed him again and he fell asleep at about midnight. He woke up again and cried for a couple minutes, but fell back to sleep and didn't wake up until 5:30 am. I let him sleep with me after that, but tonight I want him to be in the crib even in the morning. We will see. Thanks for all of the advice. It has helped that I do not allow him to fall asleep if he misses his afternoon nap. I just keep him awake until bedtime. Fun times!:) He has definitely done a lot of crying, but not as much as I thought.

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.H.

answers from Honolulu on

Does he nap? Or do you have to lie next to him for that too?

It's best to get him adjusted to a new habit of sleeping in his crib.. if that is what you need to do. Lots of parents co-sleep...but it's not for everyone.

Is he hungry? Or having growth spurts? Sick or anything else? Teething?
Well, you've tried and I know it's hard.

Maybe try some white noise... a fan on low... or a baby crib toy in his crib? My son LOVES his Fisher Price "Ocean Wonders" crib toy http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_gw?url=search-alias%3Da...
... or perhaps a night light? http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_ss_gw/105-###-###-####-###...

Maybe give him a "transition object" to cuddle... my son loves his stuffed cow that he has to have to sleep with.

The thing is to get him to "learn" to self-soothe. Then it will be easier. Some babies are more resistant. But just keep trying things. My son also likes stuffed animals... we have several in his crib with him (when he got old enough that is), and it makes him feel "cozier" and he likes the extra "company" it provides. It also forms a "distraction" for him and allows him to "be" in his crib by himself, and entertain himself as he falls asleep. We also put him in his crib while still "awake" but just before he gets too tired.

Try the book "Secrets Of The Baby Whisperer- how to calm, connect, and communicate with your baby" by Tracy Hogg. It's really great!

Routine is important and consistency. A regular pre-nap and pre-bedtime routine, and doing the SAME exact routine everytime.

He may also be going through "separation anxiety" which is a normal developmental process.

Just some ideas. Hope it helps. You'll get lots of ideas here. Good luck,
~Susan
www.cafepress.com/littlegoogoo

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.K.

answers from Los Angeles on

A.,
That is a tough one. I've been there. I started out with my baby in a basinet next to my bed the first 8 months. Then I tried transitioning to a crib and couldn't bear to hear my baby cry so I put her next to me to go to sleep. He's used to sleeping next to you now and doesn't understand why all of a sudden he's being abandoned. He's not manipulating you, he's just bewildered. If you absolutely want him in his own room, you'll have to tough it out. He will give up eventually, how long that is, I don't know. Each baby is different.
My friend said it took his son 2 days. Another friend said it took her daughter 5 days. And it is a continual process that needs relearning after any change in routine. E.g. baby is sick you need to hold him during the night to help him sleep, teething pains, etc. I hear this from my friend all the time about it.
I, for one, did not have the heart to let my babies cry, so I sleep with them. And still do. As for getting things done, you could put him down to sleep and come back out to get things done for an hour or two then go in and sleep. Move a bed into his room, that way you still have your own room for time with your husband. Each family is different. Co-sleeping is a good arrangement only if all members of the family are on board. Good luck.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.S.

answers from Los Angeles on

Put a mattress on your floor or his floor for you to lay down with him to get him asleep then sneak away. You can go back to the mattress and get him back to sleep when he wakes. This gives you time to get things done, including hubby. LOL

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.M.

answers from San Francisco on

I was there not too long ago. My son is 15 months and I just got him into his crib about 3 weeks ago. He was co-sleeping his whole life and breastfeeding exclusively for the whole first year and still moslty breastfeeding. He would probably nurse 4-6 times throughout the night. I finally got to the point that I realized he wasn't nursing for nutrition at night, just for comfort. I started to cut down on the amount of times I would feed him through the night, and he was fine with only a time or too. The other times he would wimper, I realized he didn't even wake up, he just wanted the comfort so I "sshhhed" him and pat him and he'd stop and go back to deep sleep. 3 weeks ago I decided to let him cry it out in his crib. I started at his naptime so the neighbors weren't sleeping. I waited until he was tired but awake and laid him down, I said "Mommy loves you, it's bedtime" set the music on his crib ocean wonders aquarium and walked out the door. He almost immediately stood up and started crying. I went back in his room every 5 minutes so he was reassured he wasn't abandoned and said nothing but, "Mommy loves you, it's bedtme." The frst time took an hour and a half, but I think it took so long because 30 minutes into it my husband was freaking out (We don't let our son cry, he wasn't used to it) and picked him up took him out the front door and down the street, I had to chase him to get the baby back and explain to my husband that because of what he did the whole first 30 minutes I just let him cry for no reason. Just remind yourself you have to follow through, if you give in then it teaches the baby that if he cries for 10, 20 mintues or how ever long he has cried when you give in then he'll get picked up, next time it takes longer, and that means you let him cry for no reason. Back to the technique, every 5 minutes lay him back down, say "Mommy loves you, it;s bedtime." and leave if he doesn't stop crying. After an hour and a half (just the first time) my son stopped crying and just laid there. I pat his tummy while the music played, but if he started crying I said "Mommy loves you, it's bedtime" and left for another 5 minutes, next time he stops crying I pat him and he was asleep within 5 minutes. You have the repeat this each time he wakes up through the night too. If you make sure he's eaten before bed you can tell yourself, he doesn't need to eat, he just wants the comfort. I've started giving my son milk with rice cereal before bed so I know he's not gonna wake up hungry. The first 2 days were hard. I did this at bedtime and naptime and on the 3rd day in was down to only 15 minutes or so. Within 5 days and to today I now take him in sleepy but awake, lay him down, turn on the music and pat him and he's out within 5 minutes, usually only 1 on 2 minutes, he doesn't cry at all he knows I'm there even when he's asleep now. He still wakes up through the night but the amount of time between the wake ups is getting longer, and he goes right back out it I respond right away. The first week is hard because we love our baby so much, just keep reminding yourself it's better for him in the long run. Good luck, and tough it out, it's worth it. Write me back if you have any more questions. ____@____.com

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B.R.

answers from Los Angeles on

Relax, it is not impossible, but it's not going to be easy, either. He will cry- I don't mean let him cry it out, as they say. But he will cry some, but if you don't get him out of your bed now, when you try later he is going to cry more... so if you go through a few days of misery now you'll save a lot later.

There are a lot of things you can do. Of course, you can just let him cry, and go in and check on him periodically, but I don't like that and a lot of moms can't handle it. You can also try the Baby Whisperer method- for more in depth I recommend the book, but basically you train him to sleep on his own without letting him cry- start out by laying him in his crib when he is calm and sleepy and starting to walk out, but the second he cries (really cries, not fuss or other noises) you go back and comfort him, first just by patting him or leaning way over the crib to put your arms around him and then if that doesn't won't work picking him up. Then lay him back down/ move away the minute he stops again. Repeat this until you can get out of the room and shut the door without him crying- be prepared, this method, while there are less tears, is much more work and takes more time. You may have to pick him up and lay him back down up to 30 times (or more in some cases), so be prepared not to sleep much the first few nights. But eventually he will learn to fall asleep on his own- you just have to realize that, so far, you have taught him to sleep on you or with you. He'll have to relearn on his own. But if you are patient and determined it WILL work- usually in no longer than 3 days. And be prepared for him to eat less at night once he learns. Once he is able to put himself back to sleep he won't need you as much at night- I would be willing to bet that he is nursing a lot at night because he does it to get back to sleep. And speaking of which, it's not a good idea for him to nurse in order to fall asleep, because it will impeed the process (it will be harder for him to learn to fall asleep himself).

I don't know that co-sleeping is good for a family. I think it's helpful in the very very early months (up to 3 months), and I respect the cultural differences of others who do it because it is part of their culture. However, it is difficult for two parents who grew up with their own space and who have had their own space (shared with their spouse) and had freedom to be intimate at will to give that up and for one of them to not resent it. Neither of them may say so, but one of them probably does and feels guilty about it. The parents tend to loose sleep, or they don't even sleep together in the same bed. The entire household becomes very child centered, with all of the needs (of which sleep is one of the most important) of the parents getting pushed to the side. Personally I think that balance is healthier for a family. Balance in which everyone has enough alone time and together time, and in which everyone's needs are met for the most part. Co-sleeping is one of those things that sounds really great in theory, but few parents think it through to conclusion (like "am I still going to want my child in bed with me when he's 5?") However, I am getting preachy and rambly and that's not my point.

Last, at the risk of sounding motherly (but really, I can't help it), take this lesson to heart- it's one I had to learn the hard way too. When making decisions about your child in the future (like you did when you kept him in your bed past 3 months) think it through to conclusion- will it be a hard habit to break? Does this work for my family? Etc. I know, it's hard though. As I said, I made the same mistake and many others- it's like you're in survival mode those first few months. Upcoming possible trials for you- I don't know how you feel about breast feeding, but emotionally it is easier to wean a child around their first birthday than later (same as with bottles). Any longer and it becomes an emotional crutch for the child. I respect the whole bonding thing, but by this age there are lots of other ways to bond with your child, and also by this age they have moved passed the developmental stage when they are bonding and developing trust in their primary caregiver into the stage when they should be developing autonomy. Same with binkies, although it helps to loose only one at a time.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.B.

answers from Los Angeles on

hmm maybe try a walker (if you like to use them) or a saucer to put him in so he can see where you are. as for at night try starting off with him in his crib at nap times. also put him in it just to play as you put his clothes away. crying it out doesnt work fast for all kids and it hard for them to understand why they are left to cry. oh how does your son sleep with you? oh his tummy back or side? try putting him in bed like that. also its good to put them in bed when they are drowsy with him i would wait till he has been sleeping for about 5-10mons. good luck!!!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.M.

answers from Los Angeles on

If you feel it's horrible to let him cry, then it is horrible to let him cry. I believe even Dr. Ferber recanted his "crying it out" method. There is a process and it isn't a baby vs. M., as some have suggested. At your baby's development he is developing his ability to bond and feel secure, crying it out will only reinforce that you have disappeared and abandoned him. You and I know that is not the case, but your little does notany better, he has a very short memory and attention. There are books outthere that support you having your son, close to you and give you strategies to slowly transition him to sleeping on his own, while minimizing his fear of; "M. has abandoned me"
The Sleeping Book, by Sears & Sears
My Baby, My Child, by Penelope Leach
Good luck with your transition, and remember your baby isn't out trying to outsmart you. He simply loves you so much, he wants you near him where he feels safe.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.L.

answers from San Diego on

Hi A., i have been a mom for 24 years, andI don't know everything,but I do know you should never let your baby sleep in the bed with you and your husband, you have know allowed him to form a habit, he screams because he knows sooner or later mom's going to come in, he is manipulating you at nine months. I know about being a mom and can't stand to hear them cry, but crying is part of childhood, the marriage bed in our home is only for the married couple, we slept our babies in bassenets next to our bed for easy access, but only for 6 weeks then we started giving them cereal before bed time and they slept through the night in their cribs, you need to be strong A. and break this cycle, if you don't you will have a one year old in your bed and a frustrated husband. J.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches