C.M. asks from Salt Lake City, UT on August 17, 2008
HCG Weight Loss Program
Has anyone heard of or tried this new weight loss diet? It is supposed to help you loose up to 30lbs in 30 days. I am really considering this, but I am kind of scared with trying something new. I have had 3 children and my youngest is 8 months old. We are not having anymore kids and so I really want to get back down to what I was 5 years ago. I tried the salads for every meal diet along with some excercise for almost 6 months and did not drop one pound. Everyday is a struggle for me. If anyone has ideas or knows anything about this diet, please write in. It would help me out so much to hear what other moms have to say. Thanx
Featured Answers
M.K. answers from Denver on August 19, 2008
C.J. answers from Provo on August 19, 2008
I'm not a big fan of crazy diets -- I decided to just eat fruit and veggies for breakfast and lunch and a regular dinner (but no heaping servings or seconds) -- after six weeks I had lost 30 pounds
now I just try and eat less to maintain and if I see the scale going up, I go back to my fruit and veggies for a while
T.S. answers from Fort Collins on August 19, 2008
I agree with everyone else - 30 lbs in 30 days is way too fast and I think you'd gain it back. I did Weight Watchers prior to having my last baby and lost 25 lbs. I liked it because I could still eat what my family was eating - I didn't have to make separate dinners. Now that I have more baby weight to lose again, I still know what Weight Watchers taught me. To lose weight and keep it off, there is no getting around the fact that you have to change the way you eat and exercise.
Good Luck!!!
More Answers
K.J. answers from Salt Lake City on August 19, 2008
I did a study on weightloss, and have found that if you lose weight fast, you'll gain it back. 5 lbs is the most we're supposed to lose in a month. i recommend either the Mediterranean diet, or the diabetes diet. If you do it healthy, and it becomes your lifestyle, you will look and feel great for a very long time. :)
1 mom found this helpful
K.D. answers from Denver on August 19, 2008
I have not heard of the diet you're talking about, but wanted to let you know that I went back to Weight Watchers and lost over 40 lbs. on the Flex Plan and have kept it off for a year now. I have done SO many different things to try to lose weight during my life including WW many years ago. I find now that their program really works for me and the big bonus is that I was/am always eating my own food and not a packaged plan. You may lose 30 pounds in 30 days on the plan that you mentioned, but look into what their maintenance plan is if they have one because the trick is then keeping the weight off. Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
M.R. answers from Provo on August 19, 2008
I'm sure a lot of other people have said this, but any weight loss program that says you can lose that much that fast is way unhealthy. Just ask the people who used Phen-phen before it was taken off the market because it was found to be harmful. I am wondering what sort of exercise program you have tried. In my experience you have to be consistent and it takes a lot of work to really see results from exercise. I have an eight month old too and I started a running program about six months ago. Since then I have lost about 15 pounds.Besides that I have lost a lot of inches, which is awesome. I haven't been on any crazy diets either. I try not to overeat, I do limit sweets a bit but the running has made the difference. I also had good results from spinning classes. You will sweat a ton and work hard, but I believe you have to do some work to lose weight. All the magic fad diets are unhealthy and harmful. And you gain back the weight once you stop. Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
S.L. answers from Fort Collins on August 19, 2008
C.,
This is a touchy subject, for sure! I haven't tried that particular diet, but here is what I have learned about dieting...
If you want to change your body, you have to change your eating habits. Any fad diet might work, but eventually you have to go back to eating regular food. If you don't learn how to eat properly, you will just gain the weight back. My rule of thumb when I look at a diet is to ask myself, "Can I eat this way for the rest of my life?" If I can't, then there isn't any point.
First, do you have emotional issues surrounding eating that you need to address? I know I eat when I get bored, so when I'm bored, I try to do something that keeps my hands busy so I can't eat. (I knit a lot!) Many women eat for comfort. Foods can trigger a hormonal release in our brains, and so they do make us feel better, for a short while. We moms often starve ourselves all day, then wind up gorging on junk food because we are too hungry to prepare a proper meal. All of those "eating triggers" need to be addressed.
Second, I would try to figure out a reasonable eating plan. My understanding is that you should aim to lose no more than a pound a week if you want to keep the weight off. Don't cut out food groups, and don't make certain foods "off limits." If you learn to indulge in moderation, you are less likely to go on a binge of forbidden foods.
Finally, find some time to exercise. Many diets help you lose weight, but what you are losing is your muscle mass. Exercising will help you keep muscle mass. Muscle burns more calories than fat, so the higher your ratio of muscle:fat, the more calories you will use up just walking around doing normal daily stuff. Muscle is also sleek and firm, rather than jiggly and dimply! Places like Curves and Ladies Workout Express are great because they specially tailor their offerings for women.
The best indicator of whether a diet is working is the way you feel and your clothing. Don't obsessively weigh yourself. As I said, muscle weighs more than fat, so you may be slimming down and getting healthy but still keep the same numbers on the scale. Many women get discouraged because the numbers are the same, but if you feel healthier, and your clothes are getting looser, than your health plan is working!
Best of luck,
S.
1 mom found this helpful
D.W. answers from Boise on August 19, 2008
Check out this website:
www.slimbodycoach.com.
I was the Round 1 winner in 2007. It's an awesome program to become healthier, and not just skinnier.
Best wishes, D.
1 mom found this helpful
M.F. answers from Denver on August 19, 2008
C., I am a former personaly trainer, now stay at home mom. Any diet that says you will lose 30lbs in 30 days isn't true and isn't safe. You may lose the weight but that is weight that will be gained back. If you want to get back to your pre baby weight, losing 2lbs a week is safe, it is going to take a while. You need a great diet and exercise program that you will stick with, not sometimes, but all the time. If you cheat on the diet, you have to start again. Start slow by changing a pew eating habits and join a gym. Most gyms now a days has child care, it is a big finacial concern for most, but it is a good investment in your health and well being and therefore will be for your family. Remember, our children watch what we do and will mimic our habits. If you want them to have a healthy lifestyle, it has to start with you. If you need help please contact me.
M.
J.S. answers from Pueblo on August 18, 2008
Anything with Kevin Trudue's name is a scam! go to sparkpeople.com It has so much info and it encourages healthy weight loss, has recipes, a calorie counter and alot of helpful tips for certain areas! I lost 20 pounds in 2 months, without starving or a major amount of exercise ! Good Luck
M.D. answers from Salt Lake City on August 18, 2008
I had a good friend who did the HCG diet and loved it! She lost about 35 pounds under the supervision of her doctor. She did have to follow a very strict eating regimen but she said that with the HCG you have plenty of energy and are not quite as hungry. Before she went on the HCG diet she tried EVERYTHING else to lose weight(exercise, dieting, etc.) and never lost a pound. With the HCG she saw results after the first couple of days. Good luck! Also, the HCG diet has been around LONG before Kevin Trudeau ever wrote about it.
Email