J.C. asks from Pittsburgh, PA on July 09, 2009
Having Trouble Getting 2 Yr Old to Bed
I adopted a child from Guatemala she is 2+ years old. We have a very difficult time with the quite time before she goes to sleep. She seems to be over tiered and cranky and fights going to bed... hitting and kicking. She also sleeps in the bed with her mother and some times finds her way in to sleep with me (dad). We have rearranged her crib to be a day bed and she wont have anything to do with it. We have tried to read her books and even have played some light music for her to relax... need some advise and sleep.
More Answers
L.H. answers from Philadelphia on July 10, 2009
I'm confused as to when she was adopted- birth? two yrs old? That makes a difference in the advice...
Anyway, I agree with others-- that she may just be overtired. But I would cut her some slack. Like was mentioned before, she is dealing with MAJOR culture shock (if she was old enough to remember). Western culture is the ONLY culture that does not sleep with their children, and this has only been happening for a few hundred years. Thousands of years of evolution cannot catch up with a few hundred years of isolated cultural change.
If she was adopted more recently, she may also be trying to develop trust and intimacy with her new caregiver (as well as dealing with grief and loss family of origin/familiar surroundings). Cuddle time and skin to skin contact is the best way to develop these things (very primally human. she's 2- thats "where she is"). It may be that the fights around bedtime are due to fear or mistrust and lack of control over her personal safety (again, if it was a more recent adoption). Remember, you are most likely having to start over in regards to emotional bonding/development with her. Be patient, firm but caring. I promise-- she will not be 10 and still giving you bedtime troubles. This too shall pass!
A good quick and interesting read for understanding some early human physical/social/emotional development:
"Our Babies, Ourselves"
2 moms found this helpful
B.K. answers from Pittsburgh on July 10, 2009
Hi J.! Wow do you have your hands full! There is nothing worse than a tired, cranky 2yr old! First off is she still taking good naps (without Mom) durring the day? If she is then you may want to start off moving her bedtime to an earier time. Then you need her to give up Mom. Independant sleeping is one of the first life-long gifts we give to our children. Take a weekend (don't make any plans and don't count on much sleep) and bite the bullet. Expect the screaming, crying, etc. First put her to bed saying firmly and sweetly Goodnight. Leave the room. When she starts fussing go in, pat her back put her back into her bed and leave. Don't talk to her, don't get her water or anykind of interaction...and just keep on repeating til she falls asleep (this is the Nanny 911 method and it works!). It will take a couple of fussy nights and long days, but if you stick to it you will all win. It will be harder because she is older but it is something you have to deal with sooner rather than later! Best wishes and good luck.
1 mom found this helpful
L.T. answers from Pittsburgh on July 09, 2009
Congratulations on your adoption! The first thing I would try is putting her to bed earlier. Try to take note of any signals she gives before she gets to the cranky stage. For example, my niece used to start sucking in on hand or arm. If you don't pick up on any signals watch the clock to see what time she becomes cranky. Chances are it is close to the same time every night.
If you don't have a bedtime routine, establish one. Do the same things every night before bedtime. Be sure to include activities that will soothe her such as giving her a bath, reading a bedtime story, snuggling before going to the bedroom, etc.
Many of the parenting books and nanny shows will tell you that you need to be consistent with putting your children to bed and taking them back to bed if they get out of bed. No discussions. I know that is easier said than done, but it does seem to be effective. My kids didn't give us too may problems at bedtime and have always been good about staying in their beds at bedtime, so I can't give too much help there. Staying in bed was a rule we established when we put them in their big beds and they didn't test it. For a variety of reasons we kept them in their cribs until age 3, so when we told them the rule of staying in their big beds they were able to understand and comply. Sometimes at naptime they will ask to sleep on the floor. We allow that. If your daughter sleeping on the floor is acceptable to you, maybe put a sleeping bag on the floor and give her the choice of the sleeping bag or her bed. Giving her a little bit of control might help. By the way, we have gates at the bedrooms doorways to keep the kids safe in their rooms (don't want them to fall down the stairs). Even though they are now able to open them, the gates seems to have helped the kids understand they really did have to stay in their rooms/beds. Good luck to you.
1 mom found this helpful
J.C. answers from Philadelphia on July 10, 2009
hi J.-
you seem to have answered teh question yourself if you re-read what you wrote. she seems over-tired and cranky. you may try to put her to bed earlier before she gets over-tired. adults have the same problem with sleeping when over-tired. so try putting her to bed 30 minutes earlier adn see if that helps.
J.
1 mom found this helpful
D.P. answers from Pittsburgh on July 09, 2009
J.,
I don't know what's going on...maybe she IS over tired. You know how that works like, the opposite--you think they'll zonk out but it turns out to be a nightmare....
Maybe put her to bed earlier each night til it's working better. Start the routine earlier and earlier every night til you're at about 8:00 (depending on her naps--does she nap?) Did you ever see the Supernanny technique where one parent (whichever she has LESS wrapped around her finger!) sits on the floor of the room (NO eye contact, no talking) and moves a little more to the door every 15-20 minutes til you're out the door? Maybe that would work.
PLUS you're dealing with the daybed issue which means she can just get out & walk around. Was she crawling out of the crib? If not, I'd consider putting the crib back til you get the bedtime thing straightened out. Just a thought.
1 mom found this helpful
D.W. answers from Philadelphia on July 10, 2009
I would see about putting her in the bed once she falls asleep. The longer she stays in bed with your wife the harder it will be to get her to sleep in her bed. I would try seeing if you put her in the bed once she goes to sleep and see if that helps. I may even put her bed back as a crib until she gets used to sleeping on her own and so she does not get out of the bed. The bed should be for you and your wife. Let her cry it out so she learns how to self soothe and go to sleep. You need your rest and should be able to sleep in your own bed.
1 mom found this helpful
J.W. answers from Philadelphia on July 10, 2009
hey there i can relate.my son ryan was GREAT at bedtime.8 would come and he was in bed sound asleep for 12 hours.he tunred 2 in february and i noticed bedtime getting a little later but we just had a baby so i figured no big deal.i would say in the past month or two bedtime is a nightmare for me.its a fight he refuses to go down he screams and kicks.i've tried the supernanny techniques and nothing seems to work.his new thing is if we do get him to bed he will sleep for about an hour in his bed then come into ours.the sad thing is he is so tired you can just see he is beat but he does not want to sleep.i don't have much advice for you but i can say that my son is going through the same thing so maybe its just a phase....hopefully it's just a phase.try the techiniques supernanny uses for bedtime they may work for you!
good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
L.M. answers from Philadelphia on July 10, 2009
Hi J.,
I agree with some of the others, I think she is overtired, and perhaps you should move up the bed time. Ideally, you would be starting the routine before she's "acting" tired. My daughter (same age) gets like that when its too late. I also think, that if its not too much trouble, and depending on her height, I would be really tempted to put the crib back together.
If you don't want her co-sleeping with you/your wife, put a gate on her door and accept that she might sleep on the floor sometimes. If your wife doesn't mind her co-sleeping, go with it! In other cultures children sleep with their parents much, much longer. Don't be worried about what other people will think, its your family decision. (It did sound from your post, though, that you do NOT want to co-sleep. Also totally fine!)
If the decision is for her to stay in her bed, be firm and do NOT give in. Once she knows that if she screams enough you'll come in and get her, its all over. Make sure you have a clear and consistent bed time routine, if its books and music, that's fine, just stick to it.
With my daughter, I was surprised how quickly she adapted to her routine. Its true she is still in her crib, so she can't get out... but 98% of the time she just lays down nicely with all her stuffed animals and goes to bed without fussing. The other 2%, though, there is much screaming and crying, until I leave the room. Then she knows its time for bed!
Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
Email