S.D. asks from Tinley Park, IL on February 13, 2009
Has anyone had any experience with neocate formula?
Hi,
My 4 1/2 mo old daughter has an exczema like rash that comes and goes. My husband too her to the Dr. for her 4 mo checkup & asked him about it. Dr. said it could possibly be a milk allergy. He said that I could try Neocate formula, and see how it goes.
I read up on Neocate, and to me this seems like an extreme step. My concerns are 1. the cost (i can't believe how expensive it is!) 2. she has no other health problems that is seems are common with other babies on this formula (seems other babies had severe intestinal problems or respitory problems) 3. If it is a milk allergy, wouldn't soy formula work?
Has anyone had any experience with this formula or with skin problems & possible milk allergies?
Thanks!
Summary
Some moms suggest try soy formula first, while some parents suggest don't switch formulas so quickly, it can mess up a babies tummy. Go to a pediatric allergist if you really question it. Children who are allergic to milk with have a more severe reaction.
Featured Answers
K.H. answers from Chicago on February 21, 2009
We self-diagnosed my son's milk allergy when he was 6 weeks. He had nasal congestion and excema that had started at the top of his head and was spreading down his body. No other health issues. I stopped eating dairy (breast feeding) and we started giving him soy formula as a suppliment. He has been perfectly fine on just switching to soy. Now he's a happy 4 month old. Good luck!
K.R. answers from Chicago on February 14, 2009
My son who is 19months has eczema and so does my daughter who is 51/2 months. My son hasn't had milk because I believe he has a milk allergy, has of my daughter she just came down with eczema. For my kids I think its just the season. Its hard becuase I think different things work for different people... so good luck!
More Answers
K.R. answers from Chicago on February 14, 2009
My son who is 19months has eczema and so does my daughter who is 51/2 months. My son hasn't had milk because I believe he has a milk allergy, has of my daughter she just came down with eczema. For my kids I think its just the season. Its hard becuase I think different things work for different people... so good luck!
A.A. answers from Chicago on February 14, 2009
Just for your own piece of mind, you may want to get a second opinion on the eczema. I know milk allergies can cause eczema type symptoms, but, without an official diagnosis, Neocate seems like a drastic measure...My son was diagnosed with a milk protein allergy within his first few weeks of life, but, this was confirmed by a blood test. He was also on Neocate for his first 7 months and recently switched to Nutramigen, which you can buy at Osco, walgreens, etc. Both are expensive, but, if your child truly needs them, they work! (You can also find Neocate discounts on-line).
My son has really dry skin (esp in the winter) and I use Eucerin and Aquaphor. I also found a great baby lotion at L'Occitane. Good luck.
K.S. answers from Chicago on February 14, 2009
Just to tack on the others here...
My breastfed girl has eczema as well. The doc suggested (like another mom here) to cut down on soaps--I was using Aveeno products only as that is what I can use (I don't have eczema, just extreme dryness). He also suggested emollient lotions.
It got worse for her once winter hit and the radiators came on every day.
So! We have quit Aveeno for her. For her once-a-week only bath, we use just a teaspoon or so of Little Twig baby wash soap in the water -- I had it as a baby gift and don't know where to get more. So, switching to California Baby that I got at Target. More money, but we use soooo little of it!
For lotion, we use a tub of Aquafor and slather it all over her after a bath, then use it for her butt as well. It's been 3 months, and we've only used half the $17 tub, so it spreads pretty far.
This has cleaned it up pretty much. I run the humidifier at night and some days, and we haven't had to worry about what she's eating.
For laundry: we use 7th generation, and not that much. Any stains I pre-treat rather than increase the soap in the laundry.
A first step, as long as you child's allergy doesn't progress maybe you won't need to change your formula.
good luck!
J.K. answers from Chicago on February 14, 2009
S., our son (now 12 mos) has eczema. It happens he's allergic to eggs, though at first I stopped dairy (he nurses) because I know a lot of eczema is due to dairy allergies. But the other thing that made it worse was soap and shampoo. Now we rarely use soap and never use shampoo, and only a couple baths a week. It has made me realize shampoo is overrated. And use a good quality lotion two times a day over all her body. When we did all these things he cleared up nicely in the summer time. It clears up slower or only with hydrocortisone in the winter because of the dryness.
E.Z. answers from Chicago on February 14, 2009
Neocate is the best formula for kids with allergy. I star when my son was 3 mounts and by his first birthday the allergy was almost gone.
I know is very very expensive .I bay eBay, and sometimes insurance help .
Good luck.
S.D. answers from Chicago on February 14, 2009
I am a mom of children with severe allergies, a lawyer, and an owner of a store that sells allergen free food and other products. I hope this helps.
If the eczema is caused by milk, then it is an allergic reaction (immune system response), not an intolerance. Soy formula may work. Both of my daughters were on soy formula when I was not breastfeeding because my first daughter has a severe milk allergy.
Soy is also one of the top 8 allergens, so it is possible your child could be allergic to it, but you won't know until you try. In Illinois, 2 years ago, our legislature passed a bill that requires insurance companies to pay for formula prescribed because of a food allergy. Cost should not be an issue in determining what is best for your baby and that is the purpose of the statute. Call your insurance company and follow your gut.
L.A. answers from Chicago on February 14, 2009
S.,
I have a 3 month old that had a similar problem. It looked absolutely horrible. I thought it was exczema based on my internet research, but when I took her to her the rx, it was diagnosed as dermatitis something. The important part is the treatment is the same. I am nursing, so first, I eliminated any dairy/processed food from my diet to address a possible dairy allergy. I took orally flaxseed oil and evening primrose oil and it came out beautifully in the breastmilk. On her skin she had olive oil and water baths only. This worked so well, that now the whole family no longer uses soap (except on private parts). Her skin was super dry and cracking, so I kept her constantly in castor oil, because of its many healing properties (google those). I used selson blue in her hair and around the edges, and again oiled her up after washing. Now her skin is beautiful and smooth, and I am so happy with the results. My skin is beautiful and healthy. It was quite a commitment to do this ritual daily, but it was worth the results. I am open to answering more questions offline if you like. Don't commit to this exzema diagnosis just yet. Get a 2nd opinion.
Best,
Ofie, Mommy of 15yr, 8yr, 6yr, 3month old
A.E. answers from Chicago on February 14, 2009
All I can say is don't wait too late! My son also seemed fine and one night while getting ready for bed he almost stopped breathing and come to find out he was severely allergic to cow milk and soy. Neocate was the formula he was given after that and he didn't have any problems after that. He grew out of the allergy at 12mths and he's 2 1/2 now and loves milk! For his eczema I use Eucerin or Aquafor on his skin. Also see if there is another option instead of Neocate such as Nutragamine and there's another that starts with a P(sorry can't think of the name but they are both sold in Walgreens). Those two formulas are ones my sons specialist said he could use in case I ever ran out of Neocate. The cost of Neocate was expensive($200 a case!) but I would not want anyone to go through the experience I went through when he got sick. Good Luck!
Email