N.O. asks from Canton, MI on January 23, 2009
Getting My Child to Stay Positive About School Work
My son is in pre-k. He loves going to school very much. About twice a week the pre-k teacher sends them home with worksheets. She stresses, however, that these are not mandatory and to only have them turn it in if they want to do the work. My son is behind in fine and gross motor development. He is of average intelligence, but does need some brushing up on writing and drawing and cutting (all things that they are teaching children at that age). He was diagnosed back in october with having mild attention deficit disorder and is at great risk of having a learning disability.
Now even though he know's the work that needs to be done, he has a very sour attitude about it. If I dont push at least trying these worksheets or just practicing cutting or anything of the like, he wont try at all. So I push a little to encourage him to try. What breaks my heart to pieces is that he gets so frustrated with these tasks. somedays are great but others will turn into crying fits. He say things like "I hate homework" or "i cant do it, it's not good for me"
He is awfully young to already be hating homework. When most of the children in his class LOVE doing this work because they get a sticker on the page after it's done, my son would rather eat beans all night. I worry that this is going to be an ongoing battle for years to come. I mean, gosh if he's alreayd got a sour attitude about schoolwork now, what are in for in a few years? Especially with the cirriculum today.
Has anyone had to deal with this? Any good tips? should I just not let him do the work? maybe it's too much for him right now. But I feel that if I dont, I dont want him to think he doesn't have to try. I feel bad for these kids. I feel like they arn't allowed to be kids anymore and play. they are pushed to the extreme.
Featured Answers
S.S. answers from Detroit on January 24, 2009
My son is taking OPC-3 (which contains pycnogenol in an isotonic formula) and I am noticing waaay better attention to his studies and much less trouble getting him to do his homework. He's 10 and I used to want to jump off a cliff when it was homework time!
View the science behind it at my web site ~ www.marketamerica.com/thevoiceoftruth . I can answer any questions that you have on it too! It has changed my son's life and helped with his allergies too!
S.
N.W. answers from Detroit on January 23, 2009
I would not force the worksheets, but try to find something similar instead. My son likes to draw a shape and then cut it out. They make great workbooks for practicing shapes and letters. The etch a sketch type gadgets are great for practicing letters. I would try something like that and don't call it work. Call it a game.
Good lukc.
More Answers
L.M. answers from Detroit on January 24, 2009
N., Good for you fro wanting to help your child and at the same time being concerned with his view on school. That said, I am a little disappointed that a pre-k would be sending home worksheets to work on those skills. I have over 5 years of special needs pre-school experience and there are so many other ways to work on the areas of fine motor and cutting your son can joy.
Take a trip to a hardware store and buy a variety of nuts and bolts (wide range of sizes) let him 'play' with screwing them on and off of each other. Get some playdough (or even better make your own and have him roll snakes with his whole hand and peas with his thumb and index finger. Have him cut the snakles up with scissors and pound it back again.
Look at the dollar store in the health and beauty aisle for tweezers, the cooking aisle for strawberry leaves hullers, and the hardware aisle for other types of tweezer type of tools and let him find things he can pick up and put down with these tools. (cheerios, cotton balls, beads, small blocks etc.)
All of these types of activities will build his fine motor, cutting, and in turn his writing skills. To incorporate more actually pencil paper time, have him write part of your grocery list, or create his list of the things he 'wants/wishes' you would buy. Spend a week working together creating an ABC book on a topic of his favorite things (animals, video games etc) He writes the name of an animal for every letter of the alphabet only doing 2 -3 a day. You can then look up pictures online, print them and he can cut them out to glue together into a book.
Ok I am rambling on, but I hopw you can see there are many fun ways that you can work on those skills without calling them "homework" and turning him off on school at such a young age. Feel free to email me if you want more info.
Good Luck!!
2 moms found this helpful
T.A. answers from Grand Rapids on January 23, 2009
N.,
I would not push him to do the worksheets. Preschool is waayy to early to start stressing about schoolwork! If you think or want your child to have an extra year for maturing and mastering these skills, you can put him in a Young-5's program or just do Kindergarten twice. My son is in a Young-5's program this year (I have 5 boys) He is #4, sons #1 #2 only did preschool, son #3 also did the Y-5 program. I am so impressed with giving them that extra year! Especially boys, and I agree that so much is expected from them at younger and younger ages now.
Something that might help with the motor skills is playing with playdough- you can even get playdough scissors let him form the playdough and then cut it. I have kitchen scissors and I let my little boys cut thier own pieces of pizza into bites, maybe you could "trick" him to use scissors in this way? Or maybe let him cut up a hershey bar with some scissors? He can eat his homework when he is done.
You can also make a sewing card for him to practice on. Take a file folder and use a hole punch to punch holes about every half inch all the way around the edge of the folder. Take a piece of yarn and put some masking tape over the end and let him "sew" the cardboard. Or take the yarn and put masking tape over the end and use it to thread cherrios or fruit loops and make his own necklace, you can even maybe let him cut the yarn himself. You could also take this one step farther by sorting the colors of the fruit loops or make patterns before you string them, or do 5 of each color, then you can introduce counting by 5's. There are so many ways for children to learn that don't involve worksheets! The writing and cutting will come to him, I would advise you not to push him, my concern is that he could become frustrated and give up.
Good luck to you!
1 mom found this helpful
F.W. answers from Detroit on January 24, 2009
Hi N.,
A couple of things in your request stood out to me: 1), if he has been diagnosed with a defecit in fine/gross motor skills, he should be having an occupational therapist work with him, and he/she can help with the isues you are having. The I can/can't ssue and try/not trying is an ongoing balance, one that you will have to pay attention to so you know on a daily basis when to encourage and when to back off. IF you don't have an O.T. working with him, push the school to provide services or go privately. I suggest you log on to www.wrightslaw.com, to start your education. 2) For the very reasons you stated, your son's teacher should not be sending home worksheets. Turning kids off to homework at this young age is detrimental to their future education. Watching other kids get rewards while he can't must be so hard for him. I suggest you talk to the director of the school. It is not fair that your son has to be frustrated, and not get a reward at this young age. Do not underestimate what he is feeling right now, I believe that teacher is wrong and does not know how to work with children that have these minor special needs. Move him to another class or another school, he needs a positive environment while he overcomes these obstacles. I realize that may think I am coming on a little head strong, but this advice comes from the 20/20 of hindsight! Good luck.
1 mom found this helpful
S.R. answers from Detroit on January 24, 2009
You've gotten excellent advice here re: ways to develop motor skills at home that are age appropriate. I'm no expert, but I've read enough to think that to be diagnosed with "mild add" at 4 sounds like nonsense. I wonder who it is that's making the "diagnosis" and what's their credentials and advice? Regardless, get more than 1 opinion if you're concerned, because there will be many different ones. Especially if it's preschool teachers making the diagnosis'. Milestones in development are 1 thing, learning disabilities another. You're right that his feelings about school can be developed now. Could be a mismatched preschool for him. Every child is different and the early academic push is not wrong, just not right for every child. For the immediate situation, I'd drop the homework subject altogether. He can bring it home, but unless he moves to do it himself, recycle it. Take the teachers comments to heart. If he's upset at not getting a reward, simply explain that he can earn one, too, if he wants. (He gets a sticker for doing it, not getting it perfect, correct?) Let him be distressed about that dilemma. Give him the choices and room to make them. I try not to assist my kids with homework unless they ask for it. It never seems to work. I did stand behind my oldest to get projects done, but I'm not sure that was a good idea. I couldn't bear to let him fail. Back then, the grades didn't matter like they do now that he's in High School, so the failures could have been lessons in themselves. At age 4, the failure factor is not even present re: homework sheets. He needs to learn how to behave in a group, listen, etc. Good luck! Your attention to this detail shows that you're a great mom!
S.M. answers from Saginaw on January 27, 2009
Hello N., The best way to get your son excited is to model the behavior. Get excited yourself. When you see the work and he shows no intrest in it, then offer to do it for him, and do it with great excitement. If your husband is on board also this will work very well. Do not pay attention to David while you are doing any of this. Do not talk to him. Just focus on doing the assignment. I bet he will be trying to take it away from you within minutes, if not then do it again with the next assignment. Don't push him if he wants to join in, just allow him to help you with what you are doing, even if he "helps" for a minute or two. Making it seem like it is his idea to do the work is the key. The more you push, the more you are pushing him away. That is what you have been modeling so far. By turning it around and making it a fun thing to do with mom and dad, he will look forward to doing his homework with both of you. The schools do this to prepare the entire family for future years in school. This pattern in the home will allow for home work assignment to be an every day event, because believe me, when they hit Jr High, there will be LOTS of home work. It also sets them up for good work ethics for their grown up years. Good luck.
P.H. answers from Detroit on January 24, 2009
My b/g twins are in 5th grade this year, and my son is the one who used to hate homework. I've learned my #1 offensive to tackle the work is to first lay it out, and break it into smaller tasks. He tends to get overwhelmed easily so seeing it in smaller pieces makes it much more managable for him.
I agree - if it's optional work, don't stress about it; yet don't throw it away either. Keep the sheets in a binder - you'll be glad to have them to work with later.
Right now, it's more about the routine of having homework. Pre-K seems a bit early, but you can use this as an opportunity to introduce the "10 minutes of review" after you pick him up from school. Give him as many choices as possible, "Do you want to open your backpack first, or hang up your coat?" type options "Should we put away your shoes first or pick out a snack?" -except for the time and location of this meeting. When you get home, go to a designated place within the house (for us, we use our dining room as a central place for homework) and casually say to him, "How was your day today?" "What kinds of things did Mrs. Smith have you work on?" "Did you play with Mary and Johnny again?", etc... as you are going through whatever he brings home. He needs to know that you're truly interested in him and his work, and will thrive on your attention. Be sure to use words like excited, proud, fantastic, great job, etc as much as possible. Ask questions about the art project, or craft project- have him tell you about how he did it or what it represents.
When you come to the "homework", tell him that you remember working on this as a kid and how much fun it was. Ask if he wants to show you how his teacher does it in his class. If he says no, then say it's OK and you'll just save it for another day.
When/if he shows interest, be sure to give a time limit too - ask if the two of you can spend 3 minutes working on it to see how it's done. Sometimes an entire sheet of expected work is ovewhelming and it can be more effective to say "Let's take 3 minutes to do 5 problems, then we can have a snack" or go and play with the blocks, or whatever he likes to do. A little reward can sometimes be a motivator.
I learned the "time limit" trick early on - it's amazing the difference in response from "Go pick up the toys before dinner" to "Hey- could you spend 5 minutes and pick up what you can before dad gets home for dinner" It's amazing how much can get done with a time limit. It gives the task a difinitive end and feels less daunting. Sometimes it has to be OK that some of the toys are still left out, but even having 90% of them put away is an accomplishment. The rest can be put away in another 5 minute attack before bedtime.
All in all, kids will respond better without stress, frustration and the negativity. Try making it a game - "I bet you can't do 3 problems in 5 minutes" - which gives a definitive goal that's within their reach. This also made potty training a breeze for us because I let them be in control and make some non essential choices.
Sorry, I tend to ramble on a bit! Hope there's some tid-bits that you can use!
L.J. answers from Detroit on January 24, 2009
this may not be the answer your looking for but my daughter had a family fitness night at her school and they had a bunch of people from gymnastics karate jazzercise and such, anyway we did the karate session and she loved it, we got a bussiness card to look into signing her up and the website expalins that karate can help with everything you just mentioned your son needs help with, i would look into it if i were you it might help.
S.C. answers from Detroit on January 24, 2009
Hi N. -
You've gotten a lot of good advice here from many different angles. You have to find what works for you and your son. I have three ADHD boys (other disabilities as well) and what I've found is that it makes it a lot easier if they have a little bit of scheduled time at school to actually do the "homework". That way school stuff stays at school and home stuff stays at home. My youngest is in first grade now and his daily homework is to read for 15 minutes and on Monday's he has spelling pages come home. (2 pages of 5 words each they have to copy 4 times each, no big deal.) When I know this work is coming I let him come in from the bus and have a 10 minute break with a snack then we dive right into the homework and get it done. It never takes more than 15 minutes. Maybe you could compromise with your son, tell him 'we'll work on it for 5 minutes then take a 10 minute break, then work on it for another 5 minutes then another 10 minute break...' until it gets done. Then you can break down the assignment for him. ie: just do the cutting first, take a break then do the gluing, take a break then color it, etc. Consistency is key. Keep the same schedule everyday that homework comes home (hopefully his teacher has him on a weekly homework schedule and doesn't just send it here and there) and on the days he doesn't have homework fill that 10 - 15 minutes with reading. That way he will have something school related fit into his daily schedule and he will be expecting it. Eventually he won't give you a had time anymore if he figures out you are expecting it everyday and the "I can't" excuses aren't accepted. It's all about keeping a schedule when it comes to a special needs child and adhd is special needs.
Good luck - S.
Email