C.T. asks from Grand Forks, ND on January 27, 2009
Getting Baby to Sleep Through the Night
How can I get my baby to sleep through the night? Taking away his pacifier is not an option (crazy, I know) We'd rather he not cry it out for long periods or anything, are there other softer methods that we may try? what has worked best for some of you moms? help!
Thanks for the help so far, everyone: I should add baby is 5 mo. old and wakes almost every 1 1/2..we began waiting longer between middle of the night feedings..if it's been less than 4-5 hrs, we keep giving him the paci, otherwise we feed him, he goes back to sleep, but it's a gamlbe how long he stays that way. He's normally a very good baby, naps well, happy, he's just been waking several times between feedings, and shortly after feedings as well, so I know it's isn't all hungry related cries/fusses.
Featured Answers
L.S. answers from Wausau on January 28, 2009
I have not had a chance to read through the other responses, so this might be a duplicate. But what worked for me was leaving the shirt I was wearing that day in his crib. He just needed my scent, and he needed it to be a fresh scent.
E.O. answers from Appleton on January 27, 2009
Hi C.,
I know you don't what to hear this, but with both my children we did the cry it out and it worked. The first & second night are the worst but then after that it gets so much better and you wonder why you didn't do it sooner.
I wish you all the luck :)
More Answers
E.I. answers from Duluth on January 28, 2009
yeah, dont worry about taking away the pacifier. an unfulfilled need turns into an undesireable habit later - i know a boy who wasnt allowed a pacifier, and he now grits and grinds his teeth.
:D
how old is your baby! i would LOVE to help you out - i never used the cry it out method with my son (whos now 2) and hes the MOST BEAUTIFUL sleeper ive ever known. crying it out breaks down the trust your baby has for you - his crying is a communication, and ignoring it only teaches him that you dont listen when he has a need... however, you are the parent, you have the spacific instincts you need for your child, and at differing ages they will have different cries letting you know if its a need or not quite as important... that doesnt happen until around a year old.
sleeping in the same room as you helps babies sleep. just knowing you are there, hearing you breathe. also it helps because they dont have to get so worked up before you hear them.
i will tell you something too about babies, they DO NOT sleep through the night... they have tiny tiny tummies, about the size of their fist! they cant make it through the whole night sleeping. .. they need food at some point!
theres lots of answers, lots of different situations. its hard to say what to do without more information, how are you feeding? where is he sleeping? is dad involved in the relationship? are you working?
anyway, send me a message, i would LOVE to help you work through this!
2 moms found this helpful
C.D. answers from La Crosse on January 28, 2009
Dear C.,
If you haven't already, re-read Ericka I's advice below. It's the best you've gotten so far on this subject. Then go to http://www.askdrsears.com/html/7/T070200.asp
because gentle, tear-free sleep training is the least convenient method BUT it is the most rewarding on so many important levels.
Good luck, and congratulations on your decision not to make your baby cry it out.
-C..
S.F. answers from Madison on January 27, 2009
When my kids were babies(starting as infants) we used the methods in "Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child" by Marc Weissbluth. It is really a great book and is broken down by age.
T.C. answers from Minneapolis on January 27, 2009
I know a lot of moms out there dont believe in the cry it out method and i dont believe in letting your baby cry for hours but i did the cry it out method and it worked great for us. My son was only getting up once a nite by 4 months and that was just to cuddle not to eat. and i think by aroud 5 - 6 months i let him cry it out when he woke up. He never crided for more than a half hour and he was back to sleep. After about 3 nites he was sleeping thru the nite 90% of the time. Now he is almost 18 months and is a relativly good sleeper. He falls asleep with his nuk but also knows how to put himself back to sleep without it. good luck!
A.R. answers from Madison on January 27, 2009
I was also opposed to the cry it out method, but when my baby was 7 months old, we finally gave it a try after nothing else worked. after a few nights of letting him cry (25 minutes was the longest), he started to sleep so much better. he started falling asleep on his own at night and at 9 months old he started sleeping 12 hour stretches at night! I recommend Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Baby by Dr. Weissbluth. Good luck, I know how difficult this time can be!
L.S. answers from Wausau on January 28, 2009
I have not had a chance to read through the other responses, so this might be a duplicate. But what worked for me was leaving the shirt I was wearing that day in his crib. He just needed my scent, and he needed it to be a fresh scent.
M.N. answers from Eau Claire on January 28, 2009
"Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child" is a great sleep book. I can't recommend it enough.
M.W. answers from St. Cloud on January 28, 2009
How old is your baby? Because young babies are not built to sleep through the night. They only sleep in 2 to 5 hour stretches.
Once kids reach 6 to 7 months they tend to sleep a bit longer. About 4 to 7 hours is pretty typical.
My son (breastfed till 18 months) did not sleep through the night until about 16 months. And he even went through some stretches at about 12 to 14 months where he got up every 2 hours to nurse..... We do not believe in crying it out and now that he is weaned, he sleeps through the night, no problem!
If your child is waking up, it is because he/she needs something. Babies are not mentally able to manipulate their parents. Crying is their only way of communicating that something is wrong.... Hungry, scared, wet/dirty diaper, etc.
Email