28 answers

Get over It??

I'm considering renting a breast pump instead of buying one. However, I have to admit I'm not completely comfortable with the idea of using a pump that has been used by others - of course I'm aware they are sanitized. My thoughts against outright buying are that I'm not planning on having any more children, renting may be cheaper depending on how my milk production fairs this time around, etc. Any insight on renting vs buying a pump? I breastfed my first one for 10 months and used a hand-held pump, but production slowed in the middle of those 10 months. This time I'll be working full-time and feel like the only way to breastfeed like I'm determined to do is to have a better quality, electric pump. Also any insight re: single or double pumps??

Thanks

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Education is key, I was definitely more concerned about what parts the milk would flow through and how those parts are sanitized...It sounds like renting is the way to go, although I'd like to nurse as long as possible and it sounds like if I go for at least 10mos again, I may need to think harder about buying. Thanks again for your time and responses!

Featured Answers

I wouldn't worry, the ones you rent can't be contamanated like the ones you buy. I have breastfed 2 babies and work full-time. Go for the double and the best thing I ever bought myself was one of those bras you use with the pump so you are hands-free. Looks funny but it well worth it.

10 months is a long time to rent but you have to just do the math to see what will be cheaper. You can always pass the pump on to a shelter or sell it to a friend. New tubing and cups and it's really o.k. to share.

1 mom found this helpful

Like you when my daughter was born I was working full time and insisted on giving what I thought my daughter deserved.... the best she could have - breast milk. So, being tight on money because we were alsoin the process of buying a house at the same time... I opted for a double electric pump that I found on ebay - it came with everything - then when I finally got it to the house, the first thing I did was clean it myself - with alcohol and hot water, boiling what I could.
I would not change a thing if I could go back in time - my nephew was born 3 days after my daughter... My daughter was breastfed, and he was not.... health wise - my daughter is much healthier than my nephew - she does not get sick near as often and she she is sick - it is not as severe as my nephew -
Electric all the way!!!!

1 mom found this helpful

If you plan to pump often, I would definitely rent a hospital grade pump. They are much more comfortable and take less time because they're more efficient. They give you more options for cycling and such. Also, you will not be using the same tubing. The pump, which the milk never touches, is the only part that is reused. The tubing, bottles and cones will all be new. So don't worry about that.

More Answers

A.--
when you rent a breast pump you have to purchase your own pieces (flanges, filters, tubing, bottles, etc). the part that you are renting is essentially the motor. your breast and your milk don't come into contact with anything that anyone else has been in contact with. they are sterilized before they are re-rented, but really there's nothing for you to worry about.

i bought a pump when i was nursing my 1st child (i have 2) and it was worth every penny. i got a high-end brand (ameda) because we were planning more kids and i figured i would need it again. it cost about $250. if you are planning to nurse this baby as long as you did with your 1st one you might save money in the long run by buying one. i agree that you will want an electric vs a handheld pump. a double will save you time too. once you get the hang of it, you will be able to hook up to both sides of the pump, lean against a desk, and eat your lunch over it!!

hope that helps. good luck!

1 mom found this helpful

Like you when my daughter was born I was working full time and insisted on giving what I thought my daughter deserved.... the best she could have - breast milk. So, being tight on money because we were alsoin the process of buying a house at the same time... I opted for a double electric pump that I found on ebay - it came with everything - then when I finally got it to the house, the first thing I did was clean it myself - with alcohol and hot water, boiling what I could.
I would not change a thing if I could go back in time - my nephew was born 3 days after my daughter... My daughter was breastfed, and he was not.... health wise - my daughter is much healthier than my nephew - she does not get sick near as often and she she is sick - it is not as severe as my nephew -
Electric all the way!!!!

1 mom found this helpful

I wouldn't worry, the ones you rent can't be contamanated like the ones you buy. I have breastfed 2 babies and work full-time. Go for the double and the best thing I ever bought myself was one of those bras you use with the pump so you are hands-free. Looks funny but it well worth it.

10 months is a long time to rent but you have to just do the math to see what will be cheaper. You can always pass the pump on to a shelter or sell it to a friend. New tubing and cups and it's really o.k. to share.

1 mom found this helpful

I rented a breast pump and was very pleased with the quality and experience. You will have to purchase the parts that come into contact with your breast and milk in a brand new package so you will be the only one using them. I rented a double pump so that I could get it over with faster. The brand I had was Medela. Good luck!

Hi A.,
I rented a electric breastpump from the hospital. It was a double pump. This was four years ago .The only thing that was in used condidtion was the motorized part of the pump , all the attachments were given to me packaged, and sanitized.
Renting the hospitals heavy duty pump made a huge difference for me. I did not even feel any pain when I was using it, compared to the ones you buy in stores. The store bought ones are torture .It was a breeze.
The cost to rent the pump was only 40$ a month, and let me tell you , it sounds like a lot per month, but your breasts will be forever grateful .
Hope this helps

When I rented a pump in Indiana the pump was used but the tubes and parts that touched me were new- and the milk only went through those parts, not into the pump. This was a hospital grade Medela pump- is that what you are looking at? Even if the tubes and parts are used and then sterilized, there should be no problem- no contamination or anything. The thing I would check is if the milk actually goes through the pump somehow and if so, is that part able to be sterilized. Hope that helps.

I rented one from Special Additions which is a fabulous maternity and nursing boutique down near Seton Central hospital. The ladies there were soooo helpful and knew exactly what I needed and would need. I rented the hospital grade pump and it came out far cheaper than buying one and the quality was so much higher than any of the ones at Babies R Us. You will have to purchase your own tubes and collection bottle - they sanitize the machine but the part that actually touches you or the milk is yours alone! After using that and then in an emergency using a handpump, there's no way I'd use a handpump or single pump ever. Good luck! :)

My daughter was in the hospital for 4 months and I used the hospital breast pump. The parts that touch your breast and milk are only used by you. The pump itself is the part you rent. At least the hospital grade one I used was. I have my own parts that went to the pump. So, renting will be a great option. You can no concern over the sanitary issues, if it is the same kind of pump I used. Good luck!

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.