M.D. asks from Chicago, IL on April 22, 2007
General Anaesthesia for Filling a Cavity?
Dear Moms,
Our reputed pediatric dentist strongly recommends putting my 3 year old under general anaesthesia for 2-3 hours to fill his cavities. I strongly feel there has to be a better way, and maybe a better place. I don't remember having to go under for a cavity as a kid. I'd be so grateful if anyone had a similar experience and dealt with it, or for any suggestions and recommendations of alternatives.
Featured Answers
C.W. answers from Chicago on April 24, 2007
I have NEVER heard of this. At the most, seems like they would sedate slightly. I see huge red flags here. You are right to question this. Please get a second opinion.
Is this child brushing her/his teeth regularly? Seems odd for a 3 year to have cavities.
A.K. answers from Chicago on April 23, 2007
Im sorry, but I never saw any reason to fill a baby tooth when it is going to fall out anyway. I guess it is just me but it sounds like a waste of money. My step son's mom had cavities filled and not but 2 months later the teeth fell out.
More Answers
C.T. answers from Chicago on April 23, 2007
Hello Concern Mom, I understand what you going thought, but the only difference is that my daughter Micah had 2 cavities and she didn't need anaesthesia. I do know what your going thought because her dentist wanted to but her under but she would but the mask on her face, so she didn't get anaesthesia, she did really while, andI then you son or daughter will do good also. I will keep you in my pray and don't worry everything will be ok M. D. If you believe in God and have faith in ask him to watch over and help you child there this, because without him where would we be. If you want to talk more just let me know Take care and have a happy Monday.
C.
A.F. answers from Chicago on April 24, 2007
My son had 3 or 4 cavities when he was three years old, and I want to share with you our amazing experience! My son apparently has a tooth condition that makes him much more likely to get cavities than an average child, despite brushing and flossing. So, our dentist has said that as long as we monitor him well and catch the cavities when they are little, he should be fine.
I was referred to Dr. Michael Perper, and to date he is the only dentist I have found that takes this unique approach. When kids go there, they are encouraged to play in the playroom, and then build repoir and play games with the dental hygenist and the dentist, so that the appointment is not anxiety provoking, but is a mix of a check-up and fun and games. My son REALLY looks forward to going to the dentist, and he always gets covered in stickers all over his shirt when he leaves which he also loves.
In addition to their "play" approach of working with children, he also is able to fill most cavities without any local anesthesia, shots, or laughing gas. He uses a slow drill, which does not cause any pain. He explained that normal drills create heat which heats the tooth and causes pain and sensitivity, but this slow drill technique does not. The child just hears the noise and some pressure and it kind of tickles them.
Since my son had 3 cavities he had them filled during two visits instead of one. And he actually enjoyed the visit and had no pain. The only caveat is that there are some cavities that are large or close to the root that do need to have anesthesia given. But, I would not agree to put my child under general anesthesia for a cavity, as it is more for the convenience of the dentist. Dr. Perper is a bit of a drive for us, but well worth it.
Dr. Michael Perper
400 W. Dundee Rd
Buffalo Grove, IL
847-541-KIDS (5437)
S. answers from Chicago on April 24, 2007
Dr. Perper, in Buffalo Grove, is excellent. I highly recommend his practice. The hygenist's are great. They really take there time with the kids and move slowly. If your child has multiple cavities, he will do it in several sessions not just one. For my son, the best part is getting all the stickers and he's able to pick out a toy from the drawer. Hope this helps.
V.M. answers from Chicago on May 01, 2007
I also am having a similar experience. My son is also 3 and they recommended putting him under. I am determined to find a better way! I am hopeful that there is a dentist out there who specializes in these cases- someone who can help him through this and actually have a positive experience. I think, if the dentist does a good job, that our children can come away from this learning that they can handle tough things and be proud of themselves. I will let you know what I find!
N.P. answers from Chicago on April 23, 2007
It is still important to fill baby teeth if there are cavities but going under general is a bit odd to me. What is his reasoning for it? How many cavities does she have? It really shouldn't take 2 hours and local novacaine should do the trick. Would they allow you in the room with her to help calm her? Or split up the # of sessions? I to think a 2nd opinion would be best.
T. answers from Chicago on July 17, 2007
Hi M.,
I am going thru the same dental problem (general anesthesia) with my 3 year old. Do you mind telling me what you decided to do, and how it went. My son had his first checkup this morning and he has several cavities.
Thanks,
T.
L.H. answers from Chicago on May 03, 2007
I worked at a Pediatric Dental office for a few years. The doctor would not put children under for cavities. He would give them a little nitrous or a little pink mixture that would just relax them. I forget now what it was called. From my experience the only reason children would even get "put under" was if they had a behavioral problem. Other then that their should be no reason for your child to be put under general anastasia.
Also, I see a few posters don't understand why baby teeth need to be filled. Well it depends. If you let a cavity go for too long it can end up going into the nerve and your child could end up in extreme pain. Also, it could do damage to the adult tooth budding underneath the baby tooth. I have been in the Dental field a long time and I have seen so many of these cases. But if the tooth is going to fall out within the next year or so, most dentists will not fill the tooth.
D.S. answers from Chicago on April 23, 2007
Just wanted to let you know that I was put under general anesthesia by my pediatric dentist, for dental work when I was 3 years old. The dentist performed the work at Children's Memorial, where I stayed overnight after the procedure.
Being so young, all I remember is feeling scared when they put the mask over my face to put me under, then waking up with the IV in my arm, which I wasn't thrilled about. But I'm sure my mom was in the room.
I haven't had any dental issues with my son yet, so I don't know what common procedure is for children now, but my experience nearly 30 years ago seems consistent with what you are having done with your child now. Hope my experience eases your mind.
Email