C.K. asks from Saint Paul, MN on April 26, 2009
Friend Lives in a "Garbage House"
I have a dear friend and neighbor, "Bonnie", who lives in a "garbage house" . I know everyone has a different idea about what "clean" means, but we are talking health issues here: overflowing trash; cat vomit and urine left for weeks on end; overflowing litterboxes.
She lives alone w/her two cats, and very rarely lets anyone come over. The only time I've ever said anything about her apartment is to offer help--IF she starts complaining about how overwhelmed she is--I never bring it up on my own. In the past, she has paid me to clean. She doesn't seem to like "free" help. It has been a few years since I've cleaned for her, and probably a year since I've been in her apartment.
She has clinical depression and has been seeing a therapist for years, although I don't think her depression has ever been handled well. When things are going good in her life, her house stays cleaner. When things are not going so well, her house deteriorates. Right now, she is on a performance improvement plan at her job, her mom is very ill, and one of her cats is sick. I can only imagine what her apartment looks like.
I am especially concerned now because she said her sink/garbage disposal is not working properly, and she is afraid to call maintenance because her apartment is in such a state. She has been reprimanded before by both the apartment management and the city fire inspectors, and is afraid she will get in trouble when they see her apartment. We live in the same complex so I know that the plumbing is old--I am afraid that her faulty sink will overflow, or will affect the sinks in the apartments above and below her, and maintenance will have to come in during an "emergency" situation when she isn't home. I can not even imagine dealing with a flood in her apartment!
Also, one of her cats has some ongoing health issues (urinating everywhere) that I think stem from the state of her house. I think the cat does not like to use the raunchy litterbox and thus is peeing everywhere, and now it thinks the whole apartment is its own litterbox. Also, she has talked about her cats having tangles and clumps in their fur to the point of having to cut big chunks of fur off with scissors. I also have a long-haired cat, and feel this bordering on unacceptable pet care .
My question is-- Beyond offering her help, is there really anything I can do? I am concerned for both her health, and for the health of her 2 pet cats. Are there any agencies that help mentally ill people keep their apartments clean? She is in St. Paul, MN. If I was a real friend, would I report her to someone? I am torn between minding my own business, and thinking I need to step in. Her immediate family (siblings and nieces/nephews) are all dismissive of her and it has probably been years since any of them have been at her house. Quite frankly I am surprised that people living next to her do not complain about the litterbox smells. Thanks for any advice you can offer.
Featured Answers
C.H. answers from Minneapolis on April 27, 2009
I went through a similar problem when I was dealing with severe clinical depression. I wouldn't report her to someone, but maybe suggest she try some different meds. I remember wanting help, and wanting my house to be clean, but feeling so embarrased at how it was. Effexor xr was the first med that was able to really help me, I was on it for a year and then slowly taken off the drug. I havn't had to be on anything since it really did change my life. Has she talked with her dr's about how severe her depression really is or does she mask her true feelings to them? Maybe if she gets on something a little more suited for her illness she will be able to take the help you offer her. good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
N.B. answers from Duluth on April 27, 2009
I would call the dept of social services and talk to them they can lead you in the right direction. If you don't do anything all the apartments in the building will become infected with fleas or anything that happens to be running in there. It is unhealthy for anyone who lives in that building. Good luck!
More Answers
S.P. answers from Minneapolis on April 27, 2009
It sounds like you have been a good friend to her - and that is exactly what your friend needs.
Speaking as someone who also struggles with mental illness and also doesn't allow people to come to my house because of the state of messiness -
Offer to help her clean her apartment so that maintenance can come over. You can offer to just help her pick up, and then she can do the cleaning part. Often, it's the picking up part that feels so overwhelming. You could offer to pay for her house to be professionally cleaned the first time, and help her hire someone (she pays after the first time) to come in and clean on a regular basis.
Just in googling "St. Paul Mental Health Advocates," I found this non-profit:
(651) 224–0614 • ____@____.com
They might be a good resource to call.
Also, the Mental Health Association of Minnesota, (http://www.mentalhealthmn.org/) might also have some ideas of resources that you can contact on behalf of your friend. They have individual advocates that can help her locate resources and navigate the system.
I would definitely help your friend find resources that she can contact and use on her own before you contact someone and "report" her. If you do so, it will not only potentially damage your friendship, but it will also potentially damage her future. Once reported, it will go one her record.
Good luck.
1 mom found this helpful
C.H. answers from Minneapolis on April 27, 2009
I went through a similar problem when I was dealing with severe clinical depression. I wouldn't report her to someone, but maybe suggest she try some different meds. I remember wanting help, and wanting my house to be clean, but feeling so embarrased at how it was. Effexor xr was the first med that was able to really help me, I was on it for a year and then slowly taken off the drug. I havn't had to be on anything since it really did change my life. Has she talked with her dr's about how severe her depression really is or does she mask her true feelings to them? Maybe if she gets on something a little more suited for her illness she will be able to take the help you offer her. good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
K.R. answers from Minneapolis on April 27, 2009
All the other advice was good -- but if she can afford it, she needs professional help to get the apartment cleaned up. I highly recommend Nook and Cranny (you can google them and find their website). They are a concierge/home service that does everything, and they know how to help people with organizing and cleaning. At least have her hire them to do a full day's work getting rid of junk and cleaning, and then you can help her after that.
M.T. answers from Minneapolis on April 27, 2009
C.-
I know that it must be terrible frustrating and heartbreaking to see your friend go through such hard times. But, she obviously needs help and so do her cats. You need to make an anonymous call to the humane society and file a complaint--all of your contact info is confidential. The people there have the resources that you don't in helping this woman properly take care of her cats.
As for herself, does she have any family that you could contact? Sometimes, doing what is best for her will be harder than letting her continue in her the state that she is in.
Best of luck to you...
V.E. answers from Minneapolis on April 27, 2009
I would call someone and report her. Do it for her sake and the cats!
P.W. answers from Minneapolis on April 27, 2009
The Mental Health Assoc. of Minnesota provides advocacy and support for people with mental health issues. They can help your friend with her housing issues. (www.mentalhealthmn.org)
Another option is calling Adult Protection in Ramsey County; ###-###-#### (http://www.co.ramsey.mn.us/hs/aped/AdultProtectiveService.... Based on your post, your friend appears to meet the definition of a vulunerable adult and she is neglecting herself.
I wish you both well.
C.C. answers from Des Moines on April 27, 2009
I'm not sure what the solution is but I just wanted to praise you for being a caring concerned friend. Too often friends like yours are considered too high maintenence and dismissed and forgotten. So good for you for looking into ways to help your friend. It doesn't sound like she's capable of coming up with a solution on her own right now so she really does need your help. Good luck to you both!!!
L.M. answers from Madison on April 28, 2009
C. -- Please step in. It's not just your friends and her pets who are in jeopardy but your whole building. You could call the ASPCA about the cats, and if they came to check on them I'm sure they'd get something going for the cats and for Bonnie. Or the fire department or the health department. Don't call the landlord, because that would probably get her thrown out without the help she obviously needs. Is there any way you could get her to consider a different shrink? Also, is there a favor she could do for you in exchange for you doing some cleaning for her? It can be hard to accept help without giving some in return. (If you do do some cleaning, wear a face mask!) Bonnie is lucky to have a friend like you!
Good luck! L.
Email