J.W. asks from Lumberton, TX on May 13, 2009
Four Year Old Has Insomnia
My four year old daughter has insomnia and I'm not sure what to do about it. I've tried several different (tons) of things to get her to go to sleep at night, but it just isn't working. She never goes to sleep before 10:00. She takes a two hour nap at school so I'm not really worried about her not getting enough sleep. I just want her to be able to go to bed earlier.
ETA:
I definitely think her nap time at school is too long. I don't think she needs a nap at all. She doesn't take one on the weekends and she is fine. I'm just not sure how to get the daycare to quit giving her a nap.
ETA, again:
Ok, more info. She does not usually sleep well at all. She hasn't been a good sleeper since we brought her home. She has had nightmares (based on her doctor's assessment) since she was about six months old. If she would wake up and we weren't holding her then she would shake uncontrollably until we could get her to calm down. It was terrifying and there really isn't a good way to explain it in writing. She has pretty much always slept with us. At first it was to get her to go to sleep, then it was becuase I was worried about her waking up alone and scared like that, and there have been other things.
Regardless of how you feel about cosleeping, it works for us. We have one that sleeps wonderfully alone and one that needs us at night and we are OK with that.
So after all of that is said, she is not a good sleeper. She wakes often at night. She has dreams and nightmares. She talks in her sleep. When we do try to get her to sleep alone she walks in her sleep and we will find her all over the house. She will sit up in the bed at night and just "stare", but she is asleep the whole time.
I don't mind laying down with her at night to get her to sleep. But right now if she goes to bed with us at 10, she will fidget and squirm for at least 30 minutes because she just can not relax and go to sleep. I've tried putting her to bed earlier with a quite movie, a book, music, etc. to get her to relax before bed, but it just doesn't seem to help.
The daycare, changing is not an option. I would rather her take a nap and work with her at night than change. My daycare is wonderful and if this is the only thing we can't come to terms on then I'll deal with it. I would not send her to an inferior center just to get her to go to bed earlier. Ours is rated very highly and has been chosen by the state as one of five in our area for a special teaching program. And it is not just that, the workers are awesome and genuinely love our kids. They take an interest in their lives, like coming to offsite birthday parties and events, and care about them. I wouldn't trade that for anything.
To be completely honest, I haven't asked them about doing away with her nap time. I guess I'm afraid they will tell me no and that will give me a reason to be upset with the.
Thanks for all the advice so far. It has really given me a lot to think about. I guess I would really like to hear from someone that has had a child with similar sleep issues because if it isn't something you've been through then it is so hard to explain. Before her I would have thought that it was just the parent not being firm enough or something, but I can assure you that is not the issue in our house.
So What Happened?™
I took a little bit of everyone's suggestions. I talked to the Director at the daycare and explained the problem. They really don't have a place to put her while everyone else is napping, but they have shortened her nap time.
I also took her in to see her doctor. He suggested the regular things, bed at the same time every night, story and quiet activities before bed, etc. He did say that I could try the melatonin, but that it hasn't been tested in children and no one knows the right dose. He said to start with a quarter of an adult dose and see what happened. He also said to be sure that she has NO caffiene at all, including chocolate. I actually hadn't thought about that. I'm not sure how much she has been getting, but I'm going to watch closer and try to cut it out all together.
For about the last week I have been taking her to bed a little earlier and we "talk" for a little while (until I get too tired) and then I tell her she can stay awake if she wants, but that she has to be quiet. Within 10 minutes she is usually asleep. I'm going to keep trying this and move it up earlier little by little to see if that helps.
Thanks for all the input.
Featured Answers
J.M. answers from Houston on May 14, 2009
I absolutely disagree with giving a child anything to get them to sleep!! As the others suggested just get rid of the nap and let her adjust to getting all of her sleep at night. No doubt she be tired earlier and sleep great once she her body adjusts to the new schedule!
Good Luck!
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
J.M. answers from Houston on May 14, 2009
I absolutely disagree with giving a child anything to get them to sleep!! As the others suggested just get rid of the nap and let her adjust to getting all of her sleep at night. No doubt she be tired earlier and sleep great once she her body adjusts to the new schedule!
Good Luck!
1 mom found this helpful
C.M. answers from Austin on May 14, 2009
I have a 4 year old girl who started fighting nap time about a year ago. I finally gave it up six months ago because I noticed that when she had a nap (usually 2 hours) she had trouble falling asleep at night. I tried giving shorter naps, but she is very difficult to wake once she is asleep. So we no longer do naps, instead we have "quiet time" in her room in the afternoon. Some day cares will allow children to have quiet time in a separate room from the sleeping children. They can use the time to look at books, color, puzzles any quiet activity. If my daughter has a nap, she will not fall asleep before 10 pm either, so I understand your dilemna. If the day care is not accomodating to your needs as a family (for her to go to bed earlier), then I'd look for another place that is more understanding. Good luck.
1 mom found this helpful
B.K. answers from Austin on May 14, 2009
I agree with some of the others. A two hour nap for a 4 year old is rarely heard of. My 4 year old will nap maybe once every 2 weeks (and that is only because he's fallen asleep in the car). I would definitely insist they not do this anymore and explain it is affecting her sleep at night and affecting your family life. I hate to think this way but the fact that the daycare is trying to nap a 4 year old sounds like they are being a bit lazy. You don't pay them to have her sleep. I think this is probably your biggest issue. Good luck. I hope you all get some rest soon!
1 mom found this helpful
C.W. answers from Waco on May 14, 2009
Hi J.,
you did not mention if your daughter sleeps the nite thru. but I agree that a 2 hr nap during the day is too long for a 4 year old. She should maybe have a 30 or 45 minute nap if needed or no nap at all at that age. Unfortunately most day cares insist that all the children "nap". I would speak with the day care and explain your issue with her at bed time and see if they can make an exception with her- like take her to another room and let her color or play while the others nap..... or give her some task to perform etc- if they don;t want to cooperate I would consider changing day care. Taking naps during the week and not on week end will upset her sleep schedule and if she does good on week ends she does not need to nap during the week.
good luck and blessings
1 mom found this helpful
J.T. answers from Victoria on May 14, 2009
I agree that nap time is super long. Find another daycare that will not give a two hour nap to a four yr old. Good luck.
1 mom found this helpful
L.P. answers from Austin on May 14, 2009
well yes as everyone has stated that her naps are to long my son have been have nightmares, talks in his sleep and gets out of bed sometimes but what do i do just pray for him but it does not happen every night so any way i hear putting Vita Cal under the tongue helps with a better nights sleep my sons has no problem sleeping if he has a bad dream we talk about it he gets it off his chest and falls right back to sleep so you may want to think about the Vata Cal it is calcium which the baby needs anyway kids should get around 600 iu (DV) this has 400 so its a win win to me if the baby sleep threw the night
http://www.shaklee.net/healthydesire/product/20146
read th lable of this natural supplement
I also read in a kids book that Lecithin helps with this also you can read abou it at
http://www.shaklee.net/healthydesire/product/20182
it helps with brain neuro-transmitter production
i wish you all the best I do know pretty much how you feel my son is 8 so have went threw this for the last 6years
Be Blessed
L.B. answers from Houston on May 14, 2009
Hi J.,
I had a similar experience with my oldest daughter, but not to the degree that you have with your daughter. Mine is basically a night owl. When she was 4, she was in preschool at a center that was also a full-time daycare, so they were required by law to have the kids lie down for a certain amount of time. I also didn't want to switch her to another school b/c the one she was at was so wonderful and I didn't want her to experience that trauma. What I worked out with my daughter's teachers was that she would lie down for one hour, and if she wasn't asleep, they would allow her to have a book to look at while she was on her mat, or allow to to get up and do a quiet activity. Unfortunately, very often she would fall asleep right at the one-hour mark, and I would arrive 2 hours later to find her still sleeping. I would then find myself putting her to bed at 8:30pm and spending the next 2-3 hours putting her to bed every 5 minutes or so. It was exhausting and frustrating. It went on until she was finally developmentally able to lie down for that hour at naptime and not fall asleep. It took a long time. Part of the problem was I think the teachers really WANTED her to sleep b/c then they got a break and could get some things done that they couldn't do with kids running around. I had to keep telling them over and over what a hard time I was having at bedtime, and finally they started letting her get up (instead of pushing the hour to an hour and a quarter or an hour and a half to see if she would fall asleep!). But, my daughter never slept with us (none of us got any sleep when we tried it if she was sick or something), and she hasn't ever had nightmares. Is it possible your daughter is having night terrors? Different from nightmares b/c they seem awake during the terrors but in reality they are asleep. From what I understand it is incredibly scary for parents but the children don't remember it and eventually grow out of it. I believe it is important not to wake the child from a night terror but just soothe them until they lay back down and are calm again, which it sounds like you're doing. My youngest is now 4 and I can see her developing into a night owl as well, but she is at a preschool where they only lie down for 30 minutes a day, so she doesn't fall asleep. I've noticed recently that often when I put her to bed at 8 or 8:30, she will stay up and play with her toys for awhile. I just let her. As long as she is staying in her room I'm happy. If she's not ready to fall asleep yet, then she can sit in her bed and talk to her stuffed animals until she's tired enough to close her eyes. Is this something your could try with your daughter? I've always heard/read that TV is stimulating and you shouldn't let your children watch TV for one hour before bedtime. If you have a very sensitive child then music might have the same effect. Have you considered having her evaluated by a child psychologist to make sure there aren't any underlying issues at play? Okay, one last bit of advice, my niece was a terrible sleeper from the time she was a newborn. My SIL let her sleep with them for quite a while, but then when they moved to a new house when she was about 4, they put her in her own bed but my SIL would lie down with her until she was asleep. Once her daughter was asleep she would get up (if she hadn't already fallen asleep herself!) This kinda helped to transition the little girl to her own room/bed, without the scariness of not having mom or dad nearby when she was trying to go to sleep. She started sleeping better at night when she wasn't sleeping with her parents (I think co-sleeping is great, but it can also make for a restless night when the child starts getting bigger and you're all kicking and shoving each other all night long!). She is now 12 and sleeps on her own just fine. I hope this helps, if nothing else to just let you know you're not alone! Good luck to you, I know what you're going thru isn't easy.
L.I. answers from Austin on May 14, 2009
Wow! You sure have an unusual problem there. I'm not sure if this will help, but it may do so here goes.
As a child I barely slept, I would stay awake late into the night and always was the first up. I slept (so my mother tells me) only about 6 hours a night. This changed a bit when I came into my teens. As an adult I suffer from terrible insomnia, sometimes I sleep only 3-4 hours a night and feel sick because of it. My dreams are vivid, and I have a lot of nightmares. It seems this is bought on by any form of stress, I'm just "highly strung" I guess.
As an adult I have discovered 5-HTP to be absolutely fantastic. It's a serotonin precursor, your body needs it to produce serotonin which is required to sleep. My body seems to need this. Its natural, you get it from health stores. It takes about 5 days of taking it daily to build up enough in my system for it to work. If I take it daily my insomnia is gone. There are no side effects, I certainly have noticed none. You cannot take it with alcohol or some prescription medications, but that's probably irrelevant for a 4 year old.
If you wanted to give this a go a naturopath may be able to help with advice and dosage.
I wish your daughter a good nights sleep!
Email