12 answers

Flu Vaccinations. Do You Believe?

I know the topic of vaccinations is controversial and parents on both sides feel strongly. I'm wondering about opinions/viewpoints on flu vaccines, most specifically this year when two regular flu shots plus the swine flu vaccine equal three added shots for my sixteen month old, who in my opinion, is already rather overloaded with shots. I had the first flu vaccine done at his fifteen month check-up and could go back anytime for the second. Last year my son had the flu TWICE after being vaccinated and while my pediatrician pointed out the vaccine protects kids against more serious flu strains, I have to say he was quite a sick little boy with one bout. Who knows he might have been even more ill without the shot.

I believe in vaccines and while I'm not in the parent category of go along with everything medical professionals recommend, I tend to acquiesce to expert opinions. I'm not about to discount a physicians knowledge for the twenty minutes I spent online researching something. That said, I really think we pump little tiny kids with way too much "protection" and it worries me a little the long term effects of twenty shots in a twelve month period.

So, what say you about the added vaccines like flu shots? Am I putting my child and others at risk if I choose not to do flu vaccines? Are you doing them? My son doesn't go to daycare, but he's around other children at story times and playgrounds.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

You are right. I did not correctly label my son's "flu-like symptoms" last winter. They were stomach viruses not upper respiratory. Still, I know very few people who call vomiting with diarrhea and a fever anything other than the flu. I'm sure no medical professionals would categorize it as such, but it's interesting that my doctor saw my son with both bouts of virus and if memory serves me correctly just pointed out the flu shot protects against more serious strains of the flu when I grumbled about my child having it twice after the shot. It would have been helpful had she educated me on what exactly more serious strains mean.

Thank you for the responses. While I feel a little preached at - I did ask for it after all. I will get his second flu shot and will continue to consider the H1N1 vaccine.

Featured Answers

We have two pediatricians (one very conservative) and both have strongly recommended getting the vaccine once it is available. On the news last night they said there would not have been any worry about the H1N1 vaccine on the public's part had H1N1 shown up a few months earlier as the strain would have just been added to seasonal flu shots and no one would have been the wiser. I've done shots each year since I was 18 (I am now 41) because at 18 I got the flu so bad I was out of commission for 3 weeks and in and out of the hospital. We're doing the vaccine.

More Answers

The flu shot is intended for the "influenza flu" not the stomach bug, stomach flu. The influenza flu is upper respitory (big problem for kids with asthma), high fever,chills,sweats, body aches, you name it, it sucks and it lasts like 7days. Are you sure your son had that TWICE last year?

My kids maybe be overloaded with vaccines but I'm very pro-vaccine. Can't wait to get my kids the H1N1 vaccine will be first in line if I can.

My daughter got the real influenza flu at age2 it knocked her on her butt hard. We were in the ER 3x I am still paying hospital bills, She slept for 17hours straight I couldn't wake her, she was a zombie for an entire week. She had problems breathing it was so scary. Did I mention I missed an entire week of work unpaid. I didn't get it that year b/c I had my shot. I should have gotten my dd her shot. I didn't think it was a big deal.

Well she's now 8 and she's had a shot every year since and hasn't gotten the flu since. I just did my baby's 12mo.vaccines 2days ago and demanded she get a flu shot as well. She got poked 4x and I feel relief she is protected. She has to go back for her 2nd flu booster in a month. Then if the darn H1N1 vaccine comes in she's gonna have to do that too. Whatever to keep my kids safe.

1 mom found this helpful

I have gotten my daughter the flu vaccine every year. The very first year that she got it, she also got sick and I was quite upset. My doctor told me the same thing yours told you. Since then however, she has not gotten the flu. I'm not sure if it is from the vaccine, or maybe just because she is a little older...I say go for it. I believe that there are also flu shots out there that are mercury free, if you request them. A lot of the worry behind vaccines is that people think the mercury is what was causing autism and other things. That might be a good compromise to look into as well. I've heard you can request mercury free for most of your vaccines as well (if they aren't already).

Hi N., I'd recommend checking out the Dr. Sears website (you can search for vaccine articles). He discusses how the flu vaccine is made and how multidose vials differ from single dose. I believe he said multidose vials have mercury and single don't. In my opinion giving 3or 4 flu shots within a few month period is too many, especially if they contain any amount of mercury or aluminum.
Anyway, it's a difficult decision for parents. Best of luck with your research.

We have two pediatricians (one very conservative) and both have strongly recommended getting the vaccine once it is available. On the news last night they said there would not have been any worry about the H1N1 vaccine on the public's part had H1N1 shown up a few months earlier as the strain would have just been added to seasonal flu shots and no one would have been the wiser. I've done shots each year since I was 18 (I am now 41) because at 18 I got the flu so bad I was out of commission for 3 weeks and in and out of the hospital. We're doing the vaccine.

I'm also interested in everyone's input. I also get vaccines, although my pediatrician has backed off a couple and he's kind of conservative when it comes to getting EVERY vaccination so I have followed his lead.
I had the same experience as Jess. At 30 I got the actual FLU for the first and only time in my life. I was living alone at the time and I swear my boyfriend (now husband) stopping by everyday with groceries and literally feeding me kept me alive. Plus my friend's 36 year old healthy brother died from the flu a couple of years ago. So, my family gets the flu shot.

H1N1 on the other hand...well, I must admit I am a little nervous getting a shot that seems rushed to market. This might make me sound uneducated, but I wonder if in this particular case if it might be safer in the long run to just risk getting the h1n1 virus. I am aware a healthy 6 year old MN boy died the other day. I'm very conflicted about this particular shot and would love to know what other moms are doing.

CDC recommends both seasonal flu shot as well as H1N1 so yes we will be getting both. So many people are already getting sick it's not worth the risk to us.

Also, consider that the seasonal flu shot has different flu strains in it every year so it's actually about the same testing process length as the H1N1 has been.

This year I am highly against the H1N1 flu shot, and although I've had the seasonal flu shot in the past, I'm a bit concerned about that as well. The H1N1 'vaccine' that will be given out IS NOT the same that was approved by the FDA. It's a long read, but well worth it:

http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2009/1...

Good luck! It's going to be a controversial winter.

Vaccines are a very difficult issue. I have done a lot of research on them and am SHOCKED by what I have learned (contrary to what I was taught in college to become a registered nurse). I would recommend people read this article on the H1N1 vaccine and its use of squalene. Squalene is a chemical used to make your body hyper-react to the vaccine, causing auto-immune diseases in the end. The article also gives additional ways to protect yourself from the flu, without injecting harmful chemicals (antifreeze, formeldahyde, aluminum, etc.) into yourselves and your children.

http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2009/0...

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.