P.B. asks from Anchorage, AK on April 13, 2008
Family Dog Dies and 13 Month Old Misses Her Terribly...
We have had our dog for literally 13 years and just last week she was taken by cancer. I knew that me and my husband would have a hard time with it as she had been a HUGE part of our lives. What I didn't expect was that our 13 month old daughter would have such a hard time with it too.
I guess I didn't think that far ahead and kinda just figured that my daughter would just forget about Bubbles since she was so young, but she hasn't and in her own little way she is looking for her. Our daughter will open books that have pictures of dogs and say "Woof" and then look to the corner of the living room where Bubbles used to lay. And whenever we say "Good Girl Baby, that's a dog!" when she is pointing to pictures of dogs, she will look over to try and see Bubbles.
I figured that if I got rid of the dog bed and the dog food and watering/food dishes right away that it would, in a sense, erase the memory of the dog for all of us would get on easier and a lot faster. That hasn't happened, including for me and my husband.
We are talking about possibly getting a puppy so that our daughter can 'grow up' with a dog as her best friend as we are huge animal lovers and always have been, but I'm kinda nervous about a few things;
1st, that it will make our daughters memory of Bubbles less and not so remarkable as they had a WONDERFUL relationship
2nd, It's been a while since I've trained a puppy (13 years ago). I'm wondering if the stress of cleaning up little messes will have a negative impact on my daughters’ view of having a dog and my connection with the puppy.
3rd, Is getting a puppy at 13 months really a good idea? We are trying for another child, so I'm not sure if getting a puppy is the smartest idea.
We are planning to go to the Dog Pound later, just so she can see some dogs and puppies, but I'm not sure if she is going to think that Bubbles is there or if we forgot her somewhere and at 13 months she doesn't understand what Heaven is, even after much explanation.
I realize that you can't just erase the memory of a beloved friend so quickly, but does anyone have any suggestions for my 13 month old daughter?
So What Happened?™
Hello All,
Thank you SO MUCH for all the GREAT advice, websites, and resources that you all provided! I assumed that I might get one or two replies but never in a million years would I have thought that other Moms and families had gone through the same or similar situations.
After reading each one of your replies I have come to the conclusion that waiting for a new edition to our family is probably the best. I hadn't thought of all the consicenses of running out and getting a dog would have on myself our my family, as I was stuck in a "box" only with one view. I hadn't thought about so many other possiblities that you were so kind to show me, and I know now that waiting is the best answer.
As for our daughter and how she is going to handle it, time will heal our hearts and get us through the loss of such a wonderful Dog. I now know how to handle any future mishaps with animals, or even the loss of any family members that may and will come with time. Much thanks to each of you for your wonderful responce's and great resources that you have provided to me and our family.
As for a plan, I plan on asking my neighbor if we can walk his puppy on a regular basis. I figure that it will teach my daughter the huge responsiblity of owning a dog without having to actually have the full brunt of cleaning the messes and training the dog. This may help out more than just my family as the man works a lot and has very little time to walk his dog and train him on a leash. Also, I will probably wait at least for a few months to get another dog as my time is already spread so thin with so much responsibilities.
As for Bubbles, I know she is at Rainbow Ridge playing and watching over any future animals that we will get to help protect our lovely little daughter. Thanks again for your thoughts and wonderful insight that you provided. :) P.
More Answers
K.W. answers from Portland on April 18, 2008
Wow, I hope you get lots of good advice. I just wanted to say that you don't have to go to the dog pound (very depressing and perhaps upsetting since they are in cages) to see dogs. We take our little baby girl to the local PetSmart to look at the doggy day care--it's got a big glass wall and you can just sit there and watch the dogs play together. It's like a giant aquarium full of dogs!
We took her from when she was quite little so that she could see movement...animals...and not be afraid of dogs. She loves dogs now.
2 moms found this helpful
L.S. answers from Seattle on April 14, 2008
i know exactly what you are going through - to a point. August 2007 we rescued a senior brother/sister from the humane society. 2 weeks ago, I took Brutus to the vet for a cough and found out he was filled with cancer tumors all over his lungs and body. We tried meds for 1 week and he got worse, not better so I had him put to sleep. I have a 6, 2 1/2 and 22 month old and an 8 month old (who I gave birth to 2 weeks after getting the dogs)... We explained to our 6 year old that Brutus was going to live somewhere else forever so he could be better and happy and play. We said nothing to the younger kids.... they still look for him and call for Brutus to come. Our loss is tempered by the fact that we still have Cleo and she seems to be healthy.
BE CAREFUL... I know the inclination is to go right out and get another dog.... WAIT. I see so many dogs up for adoption or surrendered to shelters because the family no longer had time for it due to a birth or too many other activities....
We should have waited another year or two to get a dog. Cleo and Brutus were dogs that we knew. Their family divorced and the dad dumped the dogs at the pound with no notice. I knew that they would die most likely at the pound due to their age or be seperated. So we adopted them. We are done having kids now... but it has been a little bot of a challnege to keep the dogs included with the family and not neglect them while taking care of 4 kids including a newborn and hubby works nights and sleeps days.
Perhpas wait a year or two. OR - find the breed that is right for you and then rescue a 3 or 4 year old dog from a bereed rescue or shelter.
When we got our dogs, some friends decided they should get a dog for their two boys too.... they first went to the humane society and picked out a dog within 30 min. After having him at home for 3 weeks, the "re-homed" him because he was a big dog, but also a puppy and very energetic... they didnt take him for walks or anything.... a few weeks later, they went to a different shelter and adopted a 3 year old golden retriever. - within 1 month that dog had been re-homed as well.... Then after another month or so, they bought a pure bred puppy golden retriever puppy from a breeder - its been 6 weeks and they are getting frustrated with potty training etc.....
In my opinion, get an older dog from a rescue. or wait a few years until your child can be more actively involved in the dogs care
2 moms found this helpful
E.A. answers from Seattle on April 14, 2008
We're dog lovers in this house and had a 14 year old dog die a few years ago. We all cried, I was thankful however, that Annie died while my daughter was at school (she was 15 at the time). I made the arrangements for Annie (cremation) but saved the collar for my daughter (I really didn't know what else to do). When she came home, I told her about Annie and wouldn't you know she asked if we had Annie's collar! To this day, my daugher still has Annie's collar. About 6 months later we got a boxer from a rescue shelter.
On that note, I wouldn't recommend getting a dog just yet. All of you need time to heal. When you're ready what about a dog (1-2 yrs. old) from a shelter? There are many full breed rescues in the area. They typically know more about their dogs. You don't have the time to housebreak a dog or go thru the puppy stage with your daughter needing so much of your time. A 1-2 yr. old dog can still grow with your daughter.
All things work out in the end. E.
2 moms found this helpful
S.A. answers from Bellingham on April 15, 2008
Hi,
I have been through this also. My son is 5 and during his lifetime I have lost a 17, a 16, and a 15 year old dog and a 13 year old cat. (Yes, I had a geriatric animal thing going) The cat was the hardest one for him in regards to longevity. He was just shy of two y.o. and frequently would burst into tears stating he missed Dufus (yes, funny name, long story!). I would just hold him and we would talk about what a great cat Duf had been. Reminiscing would make him feel better and is a professional therapeutic technique. Draw pics, etc.
Did you have a burial or goodbye ceremony? Kids do well with rituals such as this.
Hang in there, it does get better. It just takes time, especially for the young ones. On the last dog who died just a few weeks ago Jake cried horribly hard, but not for very long. Now he occasionally mentions that he misses Bjorn but we go right into 'reminisce' mode and it helps work through the grief. That is what your child has to do- work through the grief and you can do this by talking about the wonderful times with the dog.
I definitely would NOT get a puppy if you are not ready. That would be a diservice to the dog and its incorporation into your family. It could also imply dogs are replaceable and I don't think that is your impression. I would also probably not go to the dog pound yet. At 13 months your intuition of your child thinking Bubbles may be there is likely correct. When you are ready then think about another dog. Let your child have time to work through the grief. And, when you are ready why don't you check out a rescue organization? Something like petfinder.org? Rescue organizations often have volunteers foster dogs- you would know the temperament and personality from someone who has lived with the animal for an extended length of time. You can also get an adult and not have to deal with housebreaking:)
Good luck! After losing four animals for my son he has gotten better at the grief thing. It does get better!
S
2 moms found this helpful
J.L. answers from Medford on April 15, 2008
Dear P.,
I'm so sorry to hear about your loss. One year ago on Easter Sunday we took our family by the river for a picnic. Not realizing how strong the river was at that time of year, our yellow lab jumped in. She was suddenly caught in a current and swept over a waterfall where she was drown. It was a horrible exprience for my husband and I and our three young boys. It was unexpected and a terrible sight to see.
Our boys were crushed. They loved our dog very much. She was part of the family. At first we didn't know what to do. Our kids were so upset that they didn't even want to sleep in our house for a couple of days. We actually left town for a few days to mourn our loss. It was my idea to get a new puppy. My husband didn't back my on this at first. He didn't think it would help. I decided to go with a different breed this time. I spent lots of time online checking out different breeds that would meet our specific needs especially in potty training because we too didn't want to go through the puppy stage again. After a couple of weeks I found the one I wanted and I made arrangments to get her.
I went to get the new puppy by myself. When I got home with her the responce I got was shocking. My husband came out. Picked her up and was instantly in love. The boys too fell in love with her right away. We have had her for a year now and although we loved our lab, our new goldendoodle has helped us tremendously to let go of the hurt and to move on. She has also proved in many ways to be a much better pet for us.
So my suggestion is to find a new family member. They won't replace the old but they will help fill your heart with love and joy again. Good luck and best wishes.
2 moms found this helpful
D.M. answers from Seattle on April 15, 2008
Losing a family pet is never easy for anyone involved, my heart goes out to you. I was blessed with two litter mates, from the moment I breathed in their little mouths, giving them their first breath, and having the best friends. As a single woman, they offered such companionship, my grandsons often told me how spoiled they were. Unfortunately I lost one at the age of 4 to illness, she went very quickly, a blessing of its own, but did not make it any easier. I still have my other beautiful girl, and in the process of my grief, I forgot she was also grieving. I learned to grieve with her, and I think we both shed days of tears. I am much closer to her now, and we tried a new puppy, infact two new puppies. Now I don't have children at home, but it was a lot of work to try to keep up with those puppies, training, potty breaking, no chewing, no digging, no, no, no. Both puppies were placed in wonderful family homes that had the time to work with them.
I personally will adopt an older dog from a shelter from this day forward. There are so many loving older babies that need good loving homes, and your family definately sounds like a great place to live. I am not sure if that helped you, but I know that is the first thing I will do when I find myself alone.
I am sorry for your loss, and just know she is there with all the babies waiting at the rainbow bridge. Good Luck
1 mom found this helpful
M.J. answers from Portland on April 15, 2008
Dog Heaven (Hardcover)
by Cynthia Rylant is the best book. You can find it online barely used for cheap. My 5 year old still misses "Rocky" who had to be put down suddenly due to illness. This book is comforting and when she misses him we read the book. It will make you feel better too! Check it out online at Amazon.com they let you look into the book.
1 mom found this helpful
M.W. answers from Seattle on April 15, 2008
I too am very sorry for your loss. I experienced the same thing when we lost our dog after being with us for 14 1/2 years. My children at the time were 2 years, and 6 months old. We kept Hoover's memory alive by telling stories about him all the time. While my two year old may not have his own specific memories, he feels as if he does because of the stories we tell, and pictures we share.
With regard to getting a new puppy. I would strongly caution you to wait. It's difficult because there is such a hole in your heart from your loss, but given the age of your daughter, and that you are trying to have a second child, you may experience the same thing that happened to me. I was so distraught I thought a new dog would help ease my grief, so we got a new dog. (I have grown up with dogs my whole life.) Because I was so focused upon my two young children and their constant needs at their ages, I never bonded with the dog. To this day (8 years later) I feel amazing annoyance towards the dog, and just as strong guilt for not having the bond with this truly amazing creature. It really is not fair to everyone concerned, including the dog.
Only you and your husband will truly know when your family is ready to bring a new critter into your home, but wait until the initial grief of your loss has passed, so you are making an objective decision, rather than an emotional one you may regret later. Best wishes!
1 mom found this helpful
Email