12 answers

Enfamil Gentlease Formula Issues Anyone?

My 3 month old is currently on Gentlease. We switched to this from the Lipil with iron last month. Here's the problem: The canisters of powder are not creating a consistent formula - from one canister to the next. Sometimes the formula separates out and it seems to make our daughter very uncomfortable!

A friend suggested Carnation good start, but we were told at the hospital to stick with the brand of formula the baby started on.

Any thoughts? Thanks!

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thanks to everyone who took time to share their experiences. It is really helpful to know others who have been down the same road. At dr's appt. today we were told we could switch. I will be trying good start!

THANKS!

Featured Answers

Hi, J.. I've also heard that you should stick with the brand the baby started on, but I don' think that's for everyone. I mostly breastfeed, but do supplement with one bottle each weekday of formula. At the hospital, my baby was jaundiced when he was born, so we had to give him an ounce a day of formula to help flush out the bilirubin, and the hospital gave us Similac. Once the jaundice cleared up, we didn't have to supplement anymore.

Once I started back to work and pumping for his day care, I realized I would need to supplement with the one bottle a day (just don't get enough when I pump), I read a lot about different ones and really liked the idea of the Carnation/Nestle Good Start. I think it was the "comfort proteins" that got me. In any event, my little boy loves the Good Start and has had no problem switching. Both formula brands we used are milk-based, so I think as long as you are consisntent with the base (milk vs. soy), you should be fine.

Let me know how it goes. Good luck!

N.

More Answers

Hi, J.. I've also heard that you should stick with the brand the baby started on, but I don' think that's for everyone. I mostly breastfeed, but do supplement with one bottle each weekday of formula. At the hospital, my baby was jaundiced when he was born, so we had to give him an ounce a day of formula to help flush out the bilirubin, and the hospital gave us Similac. Once the jaundice cleared up, we didn't have to supplement anymore.

Once I started back to work and pumping for his day care, I realized I would need to supplement with the one bottle a day (just don't get enough when I pump), I read a lot about different ones and really liked the idea of the Carnation/Nestle Good Start. I think it was the "comfort proteins" that got me. In any event, my little boy loves the Good Start and has had no problem switching. Both formula brands we used are milk-based, so I think as long as you are consisntent with the base (milk vs. soy), you should be fine.

Let me know how it goes. Good luck!

N.

It's true, once you find a formula that works well with your child it is best to stick with it, but you need to find one that works for her first. And what is best for one baby is not best for all babys. Your friend's suggestion is worth a try but don't rule out other brands. Get a small can and try your daughter out on it for a week or so. If that doesn't work well for her try something else.

I would talk to your Dr. but I recommoned members mark brand, it is the same as Enfamil Lipil and they also make a Gentlease one... I use the regular members mark, but it is only $20 for a 3lb can, the gentlease is $25 for also a 3lbs can...

Hi Try Good Start. We tried five different formulas before settling on Good Start. There's no reason why you can't experiment a little. The hospital is wrong...you don't need to stick with what they gave your daughter, you need to experiment with different kinds and use the one that's best for your child.

The hospital signs a contract with a particular brand of formula so they are "required" to tell you to use that one. All my kids used Good Start and it was great. Hardly any spitting up. There was a child at my sitters that was on a different formula and spit up all the time!! My sitter tried him on good start and immediately there was hardly any spitting up. I swear by good start.

I switched a few times with my children(i am due any day to have #4) I never had a problem, my girls had an issue with every formula except good statr. It is easier on there stomachs. Good Luck.If you register with them they send you good coupons in the mail too.

First off, I would check with your pediatrician regarding changing. If this is making her uncomfortable, I am sure they will have you try something else. I don't know if Gentlease makes a liquid form (either concentrated or ready to use) but you might try that. Liquid forms are more pricy though. Also, have the pediatrician look to see if she has reflux, sometimes the initial warning signs is uncomfortable during or after a feeding & a key one is arching of the back in discomfort. Good luck. I had to switch formulas a couple of times until I got one that worked for my son.

It's true. All docs and hospitals have contracts with about everything nowadays. Just because they say so; doesn't mean it's right. Obviously, if your LO is uncomfortable; that isn't the right food for her!! I've used many brands. It's what makes her happy. But when changing formulas stick with one for atleast four days. Just to be safe. Don't switch to soy unless it's your last resort. BTW- my last LO was on Good Start. It was the only thing she would take when I weaned her! And she had a sensitive tummy and it worked great! Good luck!
H.
Mom to 4 great kids!

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.