L. asks from Sarasota, FL on September 07, 2006
Dr Jekle/Mr Hyde 3 Yr Old
My son will be 4 years old next month and he is a monster. He constantly has trouble at daycare. The teachers tell me that he does not play well at all with the other kids at group time. He throws toys at them, takes the toys they are playing with, and gets rough with the other kids. He is much bigger that most of the other children. At 44 inches and 65 pounds he topples over most of them. When he is at home I feel like I spend the whole time getting onto him for something or another. I tell him to clean up his toys or change his clothes, or wash his hands, or whatever else and he just flat out tells me NO. I say What did mommy say, he comes back with "What did I say". I try to teach him not to say no and to be respectful but he just says that "He is not ready to talk" and wont listen. My parents even say that I have my hands full with him and that I better straighten him out now before he gets even worse. I've tried putting him in time out, making him go to bed early without TV and only soft music, tried taking toys and treats away, and even tried a few spanks. Nothing seems to work. He rarely cries about anything but sure knows how to scream and throw a temper tantrum. Tells me all the time that I am mean and that he doesn't like me. Says he doesnt like his teachers either. Sometimes I feel like I am mean just trying to keep him in line. I hate being on his care all the time. Now, here is the other side of him. As long as he is doing what he wants and getting what he wants he is a happy go lucky. On a whim he will just yell out "I like you Mommy" or just come up to me and give me a hug. Alothough, when he is really happy he will even go up to a stranger and give them a hug. (Which is another situation in itself that I need to fix with him) All the talking about strangers that I have had with him he will still talk to anyone. The good and the bad mood changes can happen within a few minutes and has been happening for months. I dont know how to teach him to be respectful of others and to stop being so mean to me and other people. I am a single mom (he has never had his father in his life and will not ever have his real father since he passed away in May.)I have a close friend that has taken over as a father figure but he works 7 days a week and doesnt really get to spend as much time with him as he would like. I do want to add that When I am not working, my son is with me the whole time. We do lots of things together and we have some good times. I love taking him out to dinner, just the 2 of us, or to the mall or even theme parks and entertainment places with just the 2 of us. I have singed him up for soccer at the YMCA that will start next week hoping to help him some. The only time he is with someone else is when an old friend wants to take him to a ball game or when I work the occasional Saturday. We are VERY much alike and very stubborn.
So What Happened?™
I want to thank everyone for their responses! They were greatly appreciated! I have spent the l[ast few days really watching him and paying attention to his flare ups to find reasons and such. We have had a few talks the last few days about feelings and why he wants to misbehave all the time. He just crys and says he wants to be good but cant help it. I feel so bad for him because I truley believe that he wants to. I have decided to go ahead and take him to see a child therapist. He has alot of love around him but everyone with the love for him keeps coming and going. The EX, my friend, grandparents, and his father figure. I think this is alot of what is causing him to act up. Changing his school in June again I am sure hasnt helped. Anyways, I am on the lookout for a GOOD child therapist, so if anyone knows a GOOD one in Sarasota I am open for ideas. Again, thanks to everyone for their advice.
Featured Answers
C.C. answers from Orlando on September 07, 2006
I highly recommend the group:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/PositiveParenting-Discipline
The mom's there are SO great at helping with these issues.
C.
More Answers
M.A. answers from Tampa on September 08, 2006
Hi, L.... I can relate to your situation. I pray it gets easier for you. I have a few modest tips that I hope will help in some way, if you havent already tried or thought of.
1. Do "mommy & me" time... Have just you and him time ... pick a time when he's normally in a pleasant mood and do something HE likes such as zoo, park, or just visiting Toys R Us (let him pick a modest toy he can have next week if he's good that week)
2. Try not to be negative in correcting him. Meaning, not saying "no", "don't", etc too much. Instead of "don't throw that chair", try "honey, chairs are for sitting" and repeat it in a nice but firm voice until he places the chair down. Praise him modestly when he complies.
3. Redirect. Instead of "no, no, no" or taking something away, redirect him to something else like a car set or sticker book or chalk board. If he likes to hit, <maybe> get him a plastic hammer set or similar and designate that as his "agression area". Or start a play pillow fight with him. Show him love and kindness instead of "drill seargent". (not that I think you do that)
4. Walks on the beach!! This will help slim him down and burn off extra energy. You don't have to spend all day there... just an hour at sunset. Make a routine of it whether every day or every Wednesday or just every saturday.
5. Routine. Yes!
6. Rewards instead of restrictions. If taking things away doesnt work, try extra rewards when he does do nice things. Give him simple, do-able chores around the house that will allow him to build self-esteem and keep him too busy to act out: putting dirty clothes in hamper, feed pet, put spoons on table for dinner (even if you arent using spoons that night), weed the garden (even if it's just a potted plant on the porch), dusting small areas when you are cleaning house, etc. If my kids don't follow an "order", I repeat it over and over and over in the same mellow tone until they break down and do it! They KNOW I'm stubborn and will NOT give in... they give in just to stop me from repeating myself again like a robot!! Hehehehehe
7. www.nickjr.com has great activities for kids of all ages. Sites like that could be used as rewards as well.
8. And you may want to attend a weekly mom & child play time group together (at church or check local rec centers and libraries) ... where he can play with others if he wants or with you or just by himself. Then you can monitor his behavior with others and see for yourself what, if anything, triggers the behavior his teacher is reporting. Sometimes, a teacher with many kids may exaggerate the situation.
9. Consider changing day care to someone who has less kids and/or more experience. If the day care does not have structured activities and schedules, any child will act out. At this age, he needs to be prepared for the strict schedule of kindergarden.
10. CONSULT WITH YOUR PEDIATRITIAN. Rule out any medical issues such as diabetes, A.D.D., etc.
Does he have neighbors or cousins he could play with on a regular basis? Sometimes simple regularity will dull the bad behavior. My now 3 yr old niece would hit my now 6 yr old daughter every time they saw each other (and pull her hair, and take any toy my daughter had, and, and, and)... so we had them over or we went there almost every day. Soon, the niece was over this behavior and now she adores her older cousin!! The niece was just before and just after turning 2 yrs at that time.
My two older kids of my own now will change bad behavior with a simple "look" from me. I never used "time out" myself. I have simply used love, firmness, and consistency and lots of prayer for patience!! :) I also have an in-home day care and can relate to the day care provider's situation. Don't be shy to go there on your lunch break, if possible, to see for yourself how he is. Ask the teacher if he is like this before snacks? before nap time? Ask her to keep a brief log so you can find what may trigger this. I keep blank sticky labels in my pocket all day and jot down this or that during the day and stick them on the child's daily report just before pick up time.
GOOD LUCK!!
M.
1 mom found this helpful
M.H. answers from Tampa on September 08, 2006
You are not alone and your son is probably just challenging you. However, he will be going into Kindergarten next year and good behavior is expected.
Pinellas County offers a program through the school system called FDLRS. They will do an evaluation on your son, send someone to your home (almost like nanny 911) that gives excellent parenting tips and there is no cost to you. We had some troubles with our son and went through this program and it was wonderful. He has started Kindergarten this year and is doing great. The service is offered up to age 6.
I strongly suggest you contact them and get there help.
My best to you,
M.
1 mom found this helpful
T. answers from Punta Gorda on September 08, 2006
L.,
you have a difficult job being a single mom forsure,but it seems to me that your son is acting out for some reasons that you may not know try talking with him ,and I would seek out the help of a professional child councelor..there are many things it could probably be maybe he is adhd? maybe he has anger issues because of something else? you r not going to get different results until you seek help , I feel for you I really do my mom was a single mom for alot of years and my brother was real handful! but never think of your child as a monster..he just may be confused as to how to get attention the right way so he will take negative attention to get it. I will pray for you guys ! it will get better if you & your son get counceling there are plenty of places in the health dept. that will help single mothers, and give you plenty of resources
this isnt just pertaining t oyou in perticular but in this day and age single moms in general have it rough trying to seek out a family when the fathers arent involved and are gone by choice or by cirumstances, I see it alot in the papers and on radio/t.v. the moms go out and the boyfreind who seemed so great molested or kills the babies/children I dont know if there is any way of really knowing that that could never happen
but please if you see signs of your children acting out or having bruises etc. look into it dont just explain it away, like I said before I am not saying there arent genuine guys out there who want a family just be careful, I know because a family friend molested me as a child although I never acted out I did other self distructive things and never told my mother because I felt like a burden as it was...I am not trying to come down on you I just want you to think about these things..
D.H. answers from Miami on September 08, 2006
Hi, L. I can understand your frustration, esp as a single mother myself. It sounds like your son-as much attention as you might be giving him does not seem to feel as if he's receiving it. I had this problem with my daughter and she is now only 18 mos. I suggest to take clear and keen note of when he is reacting positively. He is old enough to know what he is doing and I believe he is doing it simply to get your attention. I think what he would really want to say but doesn't know how is he needs you more at his level. Now obviously as parents that is just impossible to do all the time. But you should sit with him and ask him what would he like to do that would make him behave. Make him feel like he plays a roll in his choices. Try taking time out with him( I read that somewhere) and no matter how old they are sometimes you have to go to the basics. Tell him he'll be on time out for a small amount of time. Hence you are disciplining and he knows that but what he also sees is that mommy is taking time out with him and for him. When his time out is up you hug him and tell him he was a good boy- even if you had to tell him over and over to stay still. You praise him with hugs then you distract him into a new activity for him. The lesson is that you won't reward bad behavior- bad behavior gets disciplined but that you do understand that he is trying to get attention and time with you and when you interact with him at his level he will learn to connect that he gets what he wants from mommy when he participates with what mommy wants as well.
Hope this helps. You got also get more suggestions from the babycenter.com and click on preschooler- ages 2-4. There are loads of disciplining suggetions on there.
The soccer will also help esp if you participate as well.
T.C. answers from Lakeland on September 08, 2006
I recently discovered a book called Parenting with Love & Logic: Teaching Children Responsibility. It's a very good book and it gives you real situations and how to handle them. You can check out their website at www.loveandlogic.com.
C.C. answers from Orlando on September 07, 2006
I highly recommend the group:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/PositiveParenting-Discipline
The mom's there are SO great at helping with these issues.
C.
M. answers from Orlando on September 08, 2006
Hey L.,
Chin up......You must first find a discipline that suites your purpose of discipline and use it over and over. Be consistant.
But I would recommend for having a man to be involved with him to look into a church. Most churches will have children programs much like boy scout or something along those lines. Men head up the class and they learn manly things along with learning how to serve our awesome God.
Plus too it will give you a break from him while he is in a class to have your strength renewed also.
It is tough going through life at times, but the saying is true.
When you do your best, God will do the rest......
I will be keeping you in prayer and hope you find time for him.
L.B. answers from Port St. Lucie on October 30, 2007
Hi L., I am also a single parent. The best advise I can give you is pretty much what the other parents suggested. Instead of being negative try positive response for good behavior. My son's favorite besides "I hate you" was "I want a new mommy", I always tell him that no matter what, or how angry I can get I will always love him and send him to bed at night with that reminder.
If you choose to have your son tested which is not a bad idea, please get a diagnosis from at least 2 different testing facilities, DO NOT GO WITH ONE DIAGNOSIS - I learn't this from experience. I went with two, if you need help finding testing call the universities, I had my son tested where my pediatricin recommended and the results were dead wrong, had him retested at NOVA university and he is now doing fine.
There are very few places that test children at the age of 3, st. Mary's in west palm does but after my experience, I would not recommend them. NOVA University,in Davie, FL does the testing, it is worth the drive. Believe me I called all over FL looking for testing for my son at that age, it was not easy.
I know how difficult it is as a single mom, and my son acted out really badly every time we moved locations. He also did not transition well, it took a lot of work and patience.
If you would like to Email me my email is ____@____.com
Email