49 answers

Do Your Kids Eat What You Eat?

My husband and I had the age-old argument last night about me catering to my kids and their eating habits. The way they eat is our fault and I realize that. They are 4, 7 and 9. When they were toddlers I made all of their food plain, with just some garlic and salt because I didn't want them to be the "I won't eat veggies unless they are smothered in ranch or cheese" kids. Well it has bit us in the a** because the older ones still hate anything with any kind of sauce (even spaghetti) and want plain meat or fish, plain veggies, plain starch. Salt and garlic only, maybe some butter. So I often find myself making 2 separate dinners, one for us and one for them. This doesn't happen all of the time, but does probably occur at least 3 times a week. My hubby was not raised that way, he ate what they family ate or he didn't eat. I admit that life would be much easier if we put this into play in our own home but a part of me feels bad because I know that they truly don't like the food and that it is our fault. I really want to transition to "everyone eats the same dinner," I'm just not sure how to at this point. Do your kids eat what the grown-ups eat or do you play short-order cook?

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

My kids have always ate what we ate. I don't cater. It isn't like I cook gross foods, just a normal variety.

Have you let them add spices? Like have the spices you would normally put in sitting there and they do it. I have found when giving my kids control of the spices they add a lot more flavor than I thought they would and eat it without complaint.

4 moms found this helpful

I do not cook separate meals or offer an alternative. I do occasionally "alter" what I am serving for them. For example: I know my oldest doesn't like mushrooms (he has tried to like them!) so I will dish his dinner up before adding the mushrooms. I offer a variety of foods at each meal and I always feed them at least 1 or 2 things I know they will eat so if they only eat the 3 required bites of what they don't think they like (and usually end up liking after trying) they still have plenty of other food to eat. My boys are 8 and 4 and it has never been a battle for us.

3 moms found this helpful

My kids USUALLY eat what we eat. But when it's something I know they won't like, they get something easy like leftovers, a sandwich or eggs. Also if they tell me they do not like what I'm serving, I tell them they can have a pb sandwich.

2 moms found this helpful

More Answers

Well I disagree that it's "your fault". Everyone's tastes are different. Young children have extremely sensitive taste buds and other struggle with textures, smells, and flavors. My kids are now 15-20 and eat pretty much everything. But all ALL went through various food strikes over the years.

I feel eating should be a pleasant, stress free thing. In fact it involves 4 senses, it is not just plain fuel.

But then I'm a major foodie, I love cooking, I love knowing history of food, I love the sociology of food. And through most of it, I was not working all day then coming home to the task of coming up with several different things so everyone eats.

People should eat what they like. Food phases kids have will come and go, and your household philosophy about food and meals and family time will reflect how long that takes.

ALL food has merit. There is only TOO MUCH of one thing and not enough of another.

When they got a little older and I was able to involve them more in the process, they were actually excited to try different things. Sometimes they liked it sometimes they didn't. But it was cool watching Alton Brown as a family (oh! let's try that!), then shopping for it and KNOWING things about it before sitting down together to TRY it.

I can personally guarantee a 3 year old who only currently eats THREE THINGS will grow up big and strong in spite of it, and will (down the road) be WANTING to be a part of the process if it's presented in a positive light.

I've answered a zillion questions like this with my, um, unpopular philosophy. But it has worked very well for US. And now 2 are away at college and the youngest cooks full meals from a recipe by herself, I am VERY glad to have used even FOOD as a positive learning experience for my kids.

Bon Appetit!

:)

8 moms found this helpful

We had 8 kids. If we had catered to them we (mostly my wife when the kids were young) would have had to fix 9 meals. NO WAY ! ! !

We raised our family like your husband feels. Eat what we eat or don't eat. You will have lots of weeping and wailing to put up with, but learning is part of life. And learning to like something different (food) is also part of life. Picky eaters are only picky if they are allowed to be picky.

Now is the time to change. We had a man at work that did excellent work. He was a very picky eater. The bosses always had a hard time finding a restaurant to have a dinner meeting because he was so picky. I know he was passed over for at least one promotion because they figured if he wouldn't try a new food, he might not be willing to try a new idea or a new innovation.

Good luck to you and yours.

5 moms found this helpful

emmy eats what we eat. the only exception is if I make a spicy dish like tacos then I'll put a little meat aside with a tad less spice. she pretty much likes everything except very spicy foods and raw tomatoes .
Although in your circumstance in regards to the veggies I dont see why you have to make them eat more flavored veggies filled with butter and such. Emmy likes steamed veggies with no butter or sauce and I try not to encourage her to pick up my bad habits of adding butter although if i'm making veggies and not J. throwing a steamer pack in the microwave she eats what we serve

4 moms found this helpful

I have only one child and I know it sounds a little crazy, but several times a week I make a different meal for him, my husband, and me!! I grew up with all of us eating the same meal too but that is not the way it is here. My son is picky eater and my husband can't eat any dairy. Don't feel bad, your situation is much more common than you realize. I think it's one of those dirty little secrets. Sorry, I have no suggestions...at least all 3 kids eat the same thing!

I just wanted to add that I am assuming your children do not have any sensory issues? There is no reason why at their age they can't be eating more like you guys. But it really annoys me (Yeah, 8kidsdad, I'm talking to you!) blanket statements about picky eaters. Many so called picky eaters have sensory issues that the parents may or may not be aware of. So easy to judge...

4 moms found this helpful

My kids have always ate what we ate. I don't cater. It isn't like I cook gross foods, just a normal variety.

Have you let them add spices? Like have the spices you would normally put in sitting there and they do it. I have found when giving my kids control of the spices they add a lot more flavor than I thought they would and eat it without complaint.

4 moms found this helpful

Our home is not a restaurant and I'm definitely not a short order cook. The only exception to this rule is allergies. We have 1 kid that is allergic to shell fish we make provisions for that kid only.

All children in my world eat what I'm eating or choose not to eat at all. Most kids opt to eat and gain an adventurous side.

My husband would accuse you of letting the inmates run the assylum.

4 moms found this helpful

My MIL had an infamous battle of the wills when my hubs was pre-school aged. She asked him if he wanted his egg scrambled or fried. She cooked it to his liking, then he threw a tantrum. He dug in his heels and refused to eat it. She dug in harder, and refused to serve him anything else. That same egg came out for lunch, dinner and breakfast again, until he finally relented. He was allowed water and saltines until he came round. He has never again been picky about food ever.

My mom, on the other hand, played the role of short order cook.

I'm going to follow the route of my MIL on this one.

Good luck to you and yours,
F. B.

4 moms found this helpful

I do not cook separate meals or offer an alternative. I do occasionally "alter" what I am serving for them. For example: I know my oldest doesn't like mushrooms (he has tried to like them!) so I will dish his dinner up before adding the mushrooms. I offer a variety of foods at each meal and I always feed them at least 1 or 2 things I know they will eat so if they only eat the 3 required bites of what they don't think they like (and usually end up liking after trying) they still have plenty of other food to eat. My boys are 8 and 4 and it has never been a battle for us.

3 moms found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.