71 answers

Dairy Vs. ?

Hi Moms-
I hope someone can help. My 4 1/2 year old son is allergic to milk. We didn't discover this until a few months ago. He had a tiny bit of blood when he'd wipe his bottom. Pediatrician said milk allergies show themselves that way in some kids. Stopped the cow's milk and blood stopped appearing.

Now I have a soon to be weaned 16 month old. I don't want to find out 3 years down the road that she has a milk allergy. Question is, what do I give her while she still needs that calcium? I am giving my son Rice Milk, but I don't know if that is sufficient for a baby? Not a fan of the soy products. Any thoughts?
Thank you!

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

When I quit breastfeeding my daughter, she was just over a year old, I started her with a little rice milk on her oatmeal or cereal for breakfast. I also used black strap molasses in recipes and on her oatmeal to add more calcium. We ate broccoli (trees), spinach, sweet potatoes, carrots & oranges to get more calcium. One of my daughters new favorites is bagged cole slaw sauteed in olive oil for about 10 minutes on medium heat (very sweet). I found a link to non dairy foods that are high in calcium you might like to print out their list
http://www.dfwnetmall.com/veg/plantfoodshighcontentcalciu...
I wish you the best of luck,
J. S- Health Coach

2 moms found this helpful

I know you asked this a while ago, but I don't think anyone mentioned Oat Milk yet? Pacific brand is sold at Whole Foods and Central market, and it's vitamin D/calcium-enriched.

I avoid soy, my children didn't like rice milk, and they're allergic to dairy. I do find I can give them goat milk cheese though.

By the way, oat milk is less watery than rice and less chalky than soy. I was always nervous about almond milk because of my oldest's peanut and walnut allergy.

Hope it helps!

I was in a similar situation and used almond milk. You can buy it almost anywhere and it comes in a couple of flavors. It has more of all the good stuff!

More Answers

When I quit breastfeeding my daughter, she was just over a year old, I started her with a little rice milk on her oatmeal or cereal for breakfast. I also used black strap molasses in recipes and on her oatmeal to add more calcium. We ate broccoli (trees), spinach, sweet potatoes, carrots & oranges to get more calcium. One of my daughters new favorites is bagged cole slaw sauteed in olive oil for about 10 minutes on medium heat (very sweet). I found a link to non dairy foods that are high in calcium you might like to print out their list
http://www.dfwnetmall.com/veg/plantfoodshighcontentcalciu...
I wish you the best of luck,
J. S- Health Coach

2 moms found this helpful

I think you are making a good decision to also avoid cow's milk for your daughter for several reasons:
1. Allergies tend to run in families and cow's milk is one of the top allergens
2. Humans are actually poorly designed to digest cow's milk (i.e., we've only got one stomach) and humans are actually the only mammal that consumes the milk of another mammal.
3. Cow's milk is believed to be a trigger for diseases such as diabetes and Chron's disease - there's lots of recent scientific/medical research on this topic.
4. And, finally and perhaps most importantly, it will be easier for you and your son if both kids get the same kind of milk. It can be hard on kids to deal with allergies and not having the same foods as other kids. But, if the whole family tries to follow a similar diet, life is so much better for everyone. They make decent rice based ice creams (and coconut milk based) and rice milk can be replaced in every recipe that calls for cow's milk.

Most rice milks are fortified with calcium, so that should be more than sufficient for your daughter. If you're worried, they make some fairly healthy gummy vitamins with calcium that you can buy at Costco.

There is also a potato based milk that is also fortified: Vance's Dairy Free (www.vancesfoods.com). Later you could try almond milk which IMHO tastes better and is naturally more nutritious, but they generally recommend you keep kids away from nuts for at least the first 2 (if not 3 years) due to the allergen potential of nuts.

1 mom found this helpful

Definitely use Soy Milk...it has some great benefits and has no dairy products in it.

I have 2 kids that drink Rice Milk. One since 18 months old and the other since a year old. i just make sure to get the Rice Milk that says it is enriched with Vitamins A, D, B12 and Calcium. My Pediatrician said that was fine.

Good morning J.,
My daughter has recently been diagnosed with autism. But every disorder these days seem to all have symptoms of autism. She had a food allergy test so we would know exactly if she was allergic to any foods before her doctor would put her on a gluten/casien free diet. She ended up not being allergic to cows milk but was allergic to 13 other food products that turned out she was eating / drinking since birth like soy , wheat, peas, mustard etc. Her doctor informed her to drink rice, goat or almond milk . Almond is strong so it needs to be watered down. Rice works better for my daughter. It seems to be easier on her stomach and has extremely helped her reflux. I give her flinstone vitamins to give her back what she is not able to take in. I highly recommend a food allergy test b/c it may not be just the milk that is causing your concerns for it may be within what he is eating as well. But if you feel changing the milk is what caused this moms know best + your pediatrican recommend it was the milk :) Hope you have a great day and hope everything goes well with your son :)

try pediasure or Wal-Mart has a generic brand. It comes in different flavors.

If your 4 yr ds has blood in his stool - then the RAST (Immunocap) WILL NOT detect his allergy - if he is having gastrointestinal symptoms, then that is not the right test for him. Reaction trumps test! If you see a reaction - then go w/ that.

I'm in agreement w/ the poster(s) who mentioned looking up why people shouldn't drink cows milk. For convenience sake - it's ok to give both the kids enriched rice milk.

My 6 yr old outgrew his dairy allergy, but he still drinks rice milk since he has been on that for so long that the cows milk tastes "weird" to him. My almost 4 year old is still allergic to milk and has been drinking rice milk since he was 10 months old (which in many ways is too early - but he had allergic reactions to nutramigen).

The enriched rice dream has as much calcium as most cow milks, and honestly it's better for a human body than cows milk. My almost 4 yr old is also allergic to soy, so we don't do soy products either.

If you decide to not give your 16 month old dairy along w/ your 4 year old, make sure you are checking for "whey" and "casein" as well. Lactose free is not the same as dairy free. Also don't be fooled by "non-dairy whipped cream" or things like that - it's dairy!

I actually wish I could get my older two off of cows milk! But they've been drinking it all their lives and are used to it :)

Rice milk is also great in recipes, we make everything w/ it so my youngest can eat it also - breads, muffins, cakes, mashed potatoes, potato soup, etc - all w/ rice milk. The only thing we can't make w/ it is cook and serve pudding and bread/rice pudding (they won't set w/ the rice milk).

Good luck to you!

My son was allergic to milk and soy from birth. When he was about one year old I discovered the wonderful world of accupressure (no needles, no drugs). We did one treatment for milk/dairy/calcium and he has been drinking milk ever since. He's 4 1/2 now and has never had an adverse reaction since we had the treatment. I think it's more efficient to get rid of the problem than keep working around it, but that's me. Most medical doctors (including mine) don't realize or won't admit that accupressure works, but it does.

If you want some references, let me know.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.