D.L. asks from Longview, WA on January 21, 2009
Coming of Age for Learning Disabled Son
I am stressing about my oldest son who is 19 and wanting his freedom. With his learning disability, he does not always act responsibly nor make the best decisions. I have kept him close, but he is now wanting to make more of his own decisions. He is attending a local Jr College, but has not been able to find a job so does not yet have his own income. He has had his driver's licnese for 6 months and has already wrecked his car, and gotten a traffic ticket. I know that he needs to make his own mistakes, but I am struggling with cutting the apron strings. Any advice would be appreciated.
So What Happened?™
Thanks everyone for your thoughtful and helpful comments! Please forgive me if I didn't get a chance to respond to each of you individually, but please know that your advice and encouragement were taken to heart. A special THANK YOU for helping me realize that I am not alone, and helping me realize ....this too shall pass. =)
Featured Answers
F.C. answers from Seattle on January 21, 2009
Unfortunately, he does need to be allowed to make some mistakes so that he can learn but....not ones that are going to change/wreck his life forever. Start out with small things and build trust. Have him run small errands for you and maybe have him set up a bank account (with you as the co-signer) and have him earn money at home by doing chores. If he makes mistakes, they will at least be small ones and it will give you an opportunity to teach him better ways of living. As he makes good choices, you will learn to trust him more and it will be easier to let go because you will know he has at least some basic skills in life. It also might not be a bad idea to get him some counseling or hooked up with a life coach who might better explain to him why he needs to be patient with you (and himself), as well as how to live with a learning disability as an adult.
Hope this helps!!
3 moms found this helpful
More Answers
F.C. answers from Seattle on January 21, 2009
Unfortunately, he does need to be allowed to make some mistakes so that he can learn but....not ones that are going to change/wreck his life forever. Start out with small things and build trust. Have him run small errands for you and maybe have him set up a bank account (with you as the co-signer) and have him earn money at home by doing chores. If he makes mistakes, they will at least be small ones and it will give you an opportunity to teach him better ways of living. As he makes good choices, you will learn to trust him more and it will be easier to let go because you will know he has at least some basic skills in life. It also might not be a bad idea to get him some counseling or hooked up with a life coach who might better explain to him why he needs to be patient with you (and himself), as well as how to live with a learning disability as an adult.
Hope this helps!!
3 moms found this helpful
D.D. answers from Seattle on January 22, 2009
I have the same problem. My son also had a terrible accident where people got injured and his car was totalled. He wouldn't listen to advice. He kept saying, "I need to make my own mistakes". And it's cost him. Now he is struggling to pay of debts on a small income, living at home. However, he is cooperative, and as hard as it is to watch him grow up, you just have to stick by them. Our culture teaches children to NOT grow up - but to stay children. As a result, their mistakes are much larger when they are first adults, than they used to be when I was in my 20's (30 years ago).
Watching this age group make their mistakes can be very painful for the parents.
Encourage him to get any job that he can get. Places like JC Penny, Staples, pizza place are hiring. Then when he gets a job if he can afford it, ask him to pay rent (it can be $100 per month) just to get used to being responsible. Mine pays for his own stuff, his own car, insurance, etc. If he has a learning disability, he should probably get a trade, instead of going for the academics. In Europe when people aren't good at academics, they are automatically funneled into a trade, which can be just as lucrative as a college education. Make sure he gets a trade that can give him an adequate income. Often the hands-on a trade gives you can bypass any learning disabilities you may have.
Since your son IS going to college, I would recommend to continue to support him. It's not like he's wasting his time.
1 mom found this helpful
K.G. answers from Seattle on January 22, 2009
D., I have a mentally retarded sister who is 41 and lives on her own, she has the mentality of a 13yo on some things. She can drive and works very part time 8 hours a week at the local hospital where she lives. She gets SSI from Social Security and she wouldn't get any if she got a real job (which she mentally can't handle). I know she had to take a bunch of tests to be eligible but for her and my parents it was a godsend because it allows her to be out of the house and have her own money and they are still in the same town and can help her out. She also qualified for low-income housing so that is where she lives. I don't know what kind of disabilities your son has but you should look into that program on the Social Security website or visit an office. Maybe he can at least get the income without moving out and it might make him feel more independent. Good luck and pat yourself on the back, it takes a special kind of person to raise disabled children.
1 mom found this helpful
M.W. answers from Seattle on January 22, 2009
You didn't say what his specific learning disability is, and as a teacher and person who has worked with those with disabilities in many contexts-- that could be a big factor.
I have seen people who have forced their disabled child to conform to an education system that truly did not meet their needs or abilities when they should have had them in life-skills based programs. On the other hand, I've seen parents blame every shortcoming/misbehavior/bad judgement of their child (and their parenting) on a diagnosis on a piece of paper that a psychologist or psychiatrist drafted. I've also seen many, many extraordinary parents who have worked through, around, and with the systems available to make sure that their child has their needs met to the best possible outcome.
You have to examine what you think your son is able to handle emotionally, financially, and legally. You also need to think about what others have mentioned--is it his disability that is in the way or the attitudes of you (family) and he about the disability?
If he does have some limitations that would qualify him for community resources, you can work with someone at his community college who specializes in placements. If he truly cannot handle the responsibility of driving, then perhaps a next best step is to use public transit.
Just the fact that you're reaching out to best help your son is a big sign of hope! I bet you will get lots of helpful advice here.
1 mom found this helpful
W.C. answers from Seattle on January 22, 2009
I would negotiate with your son which things he can do own. Decide ahead with your husband which items you are willing to negotiate. If he messes up re-negotiate those items. Always be positive.
I do think he needs responsibility along with freedoms. And logical natural consequences if he messes up. You break it, you fix it.
B.P. answers from Seattle on January 22, 2009
I don't know what kind of learning disability he has, but if it severe enough, he may be eligible for social security to help him live on his own. On the other hand, if he does venture out this soon, chances are, he'll be back. They ALWAYS come back. Just support his changes. It's an exciting time for him to think about being an adult and making his own decisions. Even with a disability, it is best to let him mature and grow through his own mistakes. The more you help him, the less he will become a responsible adult. I know how hard it is to let go. I was never one to want to kick them out of the nest.
M.H. answers from Anchorage on January 22, 2009
You don't say what your son's learning disability is, but if he is attending junior college, I assume that he finished high school. The only way for him to learn responsibility is to give him responsibility and suffer the consequences of his mistakes. I am concerned about how he got a car if he doesn't have a job. My son had to earn the money to buy his own car when he was old enough to drive so that he would appreciate what it took to get the car. The longer you keep him tied to your apron strings, the less likely that he will ever learn to make his own responsible decisions. Keep reinforcing the idea that he is responsible for what happens in his life and that you will support his right to make decisions. Also encourage him to discuss decisions with someone else before he acts.
K.R. answers from Portland on January 22, 2009
if you live near a city where PAX workshops are available, a "Celebrating Men" workshop might alleviate some of your general teenage-boy concerns (for all three boys) ... they have a free 3 hour(?) introduction course to try to get you to go to the full weekend one (of course), but even the 3 hour one is full of good stuff, where they lay out all the things American women "know" about men but they put them into a picture that (get this:) *makes sense*(!).
Anyhow, not directly related to learning disabilities, but perhaps a different piece of the puzzle.
PAX is in (as I recall) Seattle, LA, Phoenix, and NYC ...
Email