32 answers

Children Are Wanting a Dog

I have three children 14 yr old son and twin 8yr olds b/g. They are asking for a dog and have been for maybe a year. I really dont want the extra's that are involved with a dog like walking them, cleaning up after them and ect. We are just not home enough to give the attenion to a dog. We tried getting a cat and the boys think its just not the same. However i think my husband is ready to give in to them and let them have one. We are not sure what kind of dog? Any suggestions? I think a medium size dog, but what breed?

What can I do next?

So What Happened?â„¢

Thank you for all of the advise. We have decided to get a dog but, it will be after football and basketball season is over. This way we can spend more time with the new dog. Thanks again!

Featured Answers

They "can" be hard to train but a basset is a great family dog. They aren't as active as a lab or beagle, very mellow usualy good with kids. If you are worried about training a puppy go to the humane society and adopt an older dog who is already house broken. Some have even been through obedience school. The Iowa City Humane Society is also good about posting if the dogs are good with kids and other pets.

We have a bull mastiff which is a huge dog. She is great and their breed is great with kids and wonderful protectors of their homes. I thought her size would bother me but she is so big that is makes her so mellow. She does not need a lot of exersize and really just likes to be loved on.

If you aren't home enough to give the dog attention then don't get one right now. Dogs are like kids they need attention. And if you get a puppy you have to give it LOTS of attention to do stuff like potty train. I've had a dog all my life and when my husband and I both started working full-time again, we both agreed we couldn't take care of one, even though I want one REAL BAD!

More Answers

Do some searches on the internet...I think it is the Iam's dogfood website that has a questioneer on it where you answer about 30 questions about what you want in a dog and your family lifestyle, then they recommend a couple of breeds for you. Another thought would be to look into shelters and the new "hybred" breeds. Like they are now mixing a poodle (no shedding) with retreivers (loyalty / good with kids).
Whatever you decide, make sure you realize what a long term decision getting a dog is, it will be your BEST friend, probably long after your kids have went off to college!

If you aren't home enough to give the dog attention then don't get one right now. Dogs are like kids they need attention. And if you get a puppy you have to give it LOTS of attention to do stuff like potty train. I've had a dog all my life and when my husband and I both started working full-time again, we both agreed we couldn't take care of one, even though I want one REAL BAD!

golden retrever you will love them and there the best with kids

C.,

Good morning. Well, wht kind of dog is the hardest question. I wish I would have done my homework like you are doing. I would say definately research the breed, so you know what it's temperment, full size and upkeep is going to be, ie..shedding etc...ours is long haired, which means I took up grooming him due to the extreme expense, though he does not shed as some may say about long hair on a dog. We went to the pet store, and fell in love with a male Lhasa Apso. Although he is a good boy- other than his constant chewing ,even a year old, he is tempermental, and has snapped at my daughter. He does have behavioral issues...plus weighs 10 pounds more than I expected (turned out medium instead of a small dog). If I could turn back time......
So I recommend that you go to petfinders.com. They are supposed to have the ins and outs, dos and don't and provide all the answers to your questions. I believe they even have you fill out something, then recommend which is best for your lifestyle and family.

Also, I have the same problem with not being home as much as I thing the dog may need, so I have a few suggestions. First, whether you have a fenced in yard or not, you may want to get a "run". This is just a line that runs from point A to point B (ours is 100 ft.) so the dog can get the excercise it needs, without you walking it. Also, it limits how far it can go either way, 15 ft each way (30 ft side to side...so that he gets plenty of the yard, without you having to watch your step EVERYWHERE in the yard) Typically it sucks getting a dog this time of year, due to potty training in the cold. Have you considered the Humane Society or the pound? That is the route I wish we would have went. You get a dog who has already been through it all...and you see thier natural full grown temperment, or at the age, while saving an animal....not to mention the hundreds of dollars you will have already saved with the purchasing price (about 500+), spaying or neutering(300+) initial shots etc......They come with all of that done at these places for under 100 bucks. How wonderful! Oh yeah, and make sure the dog you choose it YOUR choice, because you will almost certainly get left with it after the kids have moved out!!

Good luck!

If you have a fenced in yard you can put in a doggy door. When I sarted working 12hr shifts and my husband was out of town, it saved my carpets. The only dog I want to worn you about is Labradors. They are wonderful with kids (I had one growing up), but until they are about two they LOVE to chew. Ours completely shredded a plastic pool even though he had toys. Ours was a black lab and I don't know if that makes a difference. If it will be an outside dog only, I would say give a Lab a try. Ours would play nonstop and never once growled or tried to bite me or my two sisters.

If you are not prepared for the extras that are involved then a dog is not for your family. The kids will take intrest for awhile and then loose it and the dog will be your responsibility. Are your children helping with the care of the cat? If your answer is no then you are most definately not ready dogs are alot of care. I would reconsider this for the dogs sake.

I have 4 dogs, 3 large and 1 small. My large dogs are a Roteweiler and 2 pit bull mixes. My small dog is a Jack Russell mix, and they all love my 8 month old twins. It's a lot easier to handle the Jack Russell. I've heard that any kind of terrier mix is good for kids, but the large ones love them just as much. Just thought I'd let you know.

Whatever dog you get, be ready for taking on the majority of the responsibility because for kids, especially so young, it's just the idea of having a dog that attracts them. But, I think labradors are good family dogs. I've had a few myself (including right now) and two of my siblings have 4 labs amongst them. We all have black labs. They have a good reputation for being good family dogs.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.