21 answers

Car Seat Advice

I need some advice on which carseat is the best and well worth the money. My 5 month old is getting big fast so I am starting my search for the right carseat for him that is safe and sturdy. There weren't this many choices when my 8 and 12 year olds were babies. So any help would be much appreciated. Thank you for your time.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Just wanted to let everyone know first of all I appreciate all the advice and the time you took to answer my request. We went to Babies r us this past weekend and set our baby in and Eddie Bauer Carseat and a Britax and he loved the Eddie Bauer and wanted out of the Britax. So when my husband gets paid we are getting him the Eddie Bauer Carseat. Thank you again to everyone.

Featured Answers

Britax. They are more expensive, but stand the test of time. I love them. My kids, 5 and 7, are still in the 5 point harness.

1 mom found this helpful

I did a lot of research when we switched from the infant seat to a regular seat and everything I found points to the Britax brand. Just about any seat they make is a good choice. We got the Britax Marathon. Britax tends to be more expensive than other brands but when I bought mine, they got much higher safety rating than other seats so it was worth the extra money to me.
Good luck!

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

We went with the Alpha Omega Elite. I check the consumer report testing, and it rated one point below one of the Britax models (I believe it was the Roundabout). And the reason it ranked below was due to way it went in the car with the seatbelt. We use the latch system in our car, so we weren't concerned with that. And by the way, the Britax Marathon, ranked way lower than the Alpha Omega Elite according to consumer reports. The Alpha Omega Elite will go rear facing, front facing, and will become a booster seat, with a weight of up to 100lbs and height of 52". And it's about $160, about $100 less than the Britax. I will say that my only complaint is that it is difficult to adjust the straps rear facing, but the time the child is rear facing is a very short time compared to front facing. If you want to check out consumer reports, they do have a month to month membership for $6 a month.

2 moms found this helpful

Most any seat is safe as long as it is installed properly. It is a good idea to read the owners manual for your car (the child restraint section, of course!) before you purchase a seat. Many cars do not allow for a car seat to be installed in the middle of the seat with the LATCH system because of spacing. Before I go on anymore...what kind of car do you have, where are you thinking of placing his car seat and what price range are you wanting to stay in? I know a ton about car seats but I need some more information before I give ya more!!

Okay...adding more now that I know a bit more...

You probably know that putting a child restraint in the middle of a seat is best option but if you cannot do so then do NOT feel bad or like your child is less safe sitting outboard. Many car seats offer the true side impact foam like the previous poster stated. It is safest to keep your child rear facing for as long as the car seat allows even if the child is three and still rear facing, just as long as they are not over they weight limit and their head still has about an inch to grow to the shell of the seat at the top.

Again, like the previous poster stated, the Britax seats are amazing and offer lots of bells and whistles that many other seats do not. They also offer a rear facing tether that keeps the seat from bouncing around during a crash...can be good or bad, the true benifit of this has not been completely tested for comparison. I do not have a Britax so my seat does not allow for me to use the tether that is on there (that tether is there for forward facing only). We have the Evenflo Triumph Advance LX and that allows my son to rear face till his is 35 lbs and he will remain rear facing till he reaches that point. Many of the seats sold at wal mart or similar do not have the high weight limit, the tall top slots to allow room for growth and the nice safety extras. They do have the Graco ComfortSport and the Cosco Scenera that are great seats for the price. I had the Cosco to start with but it did not fit well in our car and I wanted something a little different. That seat is now in my moms van and I still feel just as safe with him in that one as I do the newer Evenflo.

You also have to make sure that you either use ONLY the LATCH system or ONLY the seatbelt...the two have not been crash tested to work together so just for saftey sake....don't do it. There are several ways to get a nice tight fit without using both. Second, use the locking clip that comes with the seat as a last resort as many people use them wrong and if you are in an accident they can pop off and become a dangerous flying object.
Sometimes a pool noodle is needed to tilt the seat to the required recling if the seat does not have a reclining base. You also need to know what kind of seatbelts your car is equipped with in order to get the best install...your owners manual will help you out with that and the manual to the car seat will help you figure out which way to install to get the fit you need.

Gosh, you are probably overwhelmed with all this...so...
Are you in the Mayfield area? I am NOT a certified tech but I do know what I am doing and if you need help getting a good install I can help out with that.

2 moms found this helpful

I used the Britax Roundabout for two of my children and will use it for my third. I have been very satisfied! I do suggest looking to purchase one online. I found mine much cheaper (even with shipping costs) than in a store.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi Racheal, Both of my kids have ridden in the Evenflo Triumph. It goes great from rear facing to forward and very easy to use. It has a great crash test rating and is very plush with lots of styrofoam shock absorbing around the seat. It has several reclining positions for comfortable car naps. I've bough 2 of them. It is comparable to Britax in the testing and under 150.00.

1 mom found this helpful

i have the britax roundabout and i would reccommend it or any of the other britax seats. they have several to choose from. the are a little pricey but get the best ratings and are easy to use and seem comfortable. a feature i love is the 5 strap harness that has each side closing separately. it seemed a lot easier than the infant seat where you had to line both sides up and click it shut at the same time. hope this helps. M.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi, I have a great car seat for my daughter that is now two. We got it for when she was still in the infant car seat. She just got to big for the baby seat that she was in. This car seat goes from a rear facing to a front facing to a booster seat all in one. It is very padded and looks and feels to be very comfortable. My daughter loves it. She never complains. It is an Eddie Bauer brand. It was about 189.99 at the time at Babies r us. We looked around for a while for a for the right one. This one has the best overall safety rating. I know that almost two hundred dollars is alot to pay but it is pretty much three car seats in one. I hope this helps.

1 mom found this helpful

My husband works in the car business and services polices cars. We asked on of the officers who does car seat saftey events and he said he would recommend the Alpha Omega. Thats been 3 years ago. Not sure if there is something better out know or not.

A. M.

1 mom found this helpful

We have a Britax Marathon and a Britax Roundabout and we LOVE THEM! They have received wonderful safety ratings and are the easiest to use. They are also,unfortunately, among the most expensive. But after doing the research and checking them out, it was well worth it. We will never buy anything else. However, if you have a small vehicle you should definitely go to Babies R Us and try installing it in the vehicle it will be in to be sure it fits.

1 mom found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.