S.G. asks from Fort Eustis, VA on April 25, 2012
Calling Someone Doctor
Let's say you had an appointment with someone who was not a medical doctor, but was a medical professional with a doctorate degree. For example, a psychologist with a PhD, a pharmacist with a PharmD, or a nutritionist with a Doctor of Dietetics degree.
1. Would you feel comfortable calling that person "Doctor"?
2. If that person introduced themselves by their first name only, and not as "Doctor," would you call them by their first name? Would that make them unprofessional in your eyes?
3. If you called them "Mr." or "Mrs." instead of Dr, would it bother you if they corrected you politely?
Thanks for your opinions,
S.
Featured Answers
H.W. answers from Portland on April 25, 2012
First, I have two friends who have their doctorates (non-medical) which I lovingly call Dr. (last name) because they worked really hard to get them.
1. Yes.
2. I would follow their lead when it comes to titles. If someone introduces themselves as "Dr. Brown", that's what I'll call them. If they introduce themselves as "Cynthia", I'll use that. Not unprofessional-- esp. nice in the medical business that someone is trying to build relationships. However, when I call for scheduling, etc. I'll always use the full title (Dr. Brown) or when talking to other medical staff about that doctor.
3. Absolutely not-- but if I knew they were a doctor, I would use that title and not revert to Mr/Mrs/Ms. to begin with.
5 moms found this helpful
S.H. answers from St. Louis on April 25, 2012
I think anyone holding a doctorate deserves the title!
I remember thinking it was soooo cool that my grade school principal was Dr. Phillips!
1. yes!
2. if they choose to use their 1st name, then I would equally feel free to use their 1st name when speaking with them. When referencing the person to mutual friends, I would use the 1st name. When speaking to non-mutual friends, I would use Dr.
.....2nd part of #2. this would not feel unprofessional to me! It's their personal choice, & part of respect is to honor their choices. :)
3. absolutely not! If I made an error, then they are fully-justified in correcting me. How else would I learn of my error?
4 moms found this helpful
T.K. answers from Dallas on April 25, 2012
They earned the right to be called Dr.
1. yes very comfortable
2. if they introduce themselves by first name only, I follow thier lead and call them by thier first name, except when introducing them to others. I would introduce as Dr So&So and let them give the person permission to use 1st name. If they use thier 1st name, I do not consider that unprofessional, just maybe humble.
3. It would not bother me to be corrected politely.
4 moms found this helpful
More Answers
H.W. answers from Portland on April 25, 2012
First, I have two friends who have their doctorates (non-medical) which I lovingly call Dr. (last name) because they worked really hard to get them.
1. Yes.
2. I would follow their lead when it comes to titles. If someone introduces themselves as "Dr. Brown", that's what I'll call them. If they introduce themselves as "Cynthia", I'll use that. Not unprofessional-- esp. nice in the medical business that someone is trying to build relationships. However, when I call for scheduling, etc. I'll always use the full title (Dr. Brown) or when talking to other medical staff about that doctor.
3. Absolutely not-- but if I knew they were a doctor, I would use that title and not revert to Mr/Mrs/Ms. to begin with.
5 moms found this helpful
T.K. answers from Dallas on April 25, 2012
They earned the right to be called Dr.
1. yes very comfortable
2. if they introduce themselves by first name only, I follow thier lead and call them by thier first name, except when introducing them to others. I would introduce as Dr So&So and let them give the person permission to use 1st name. If they use thier 1st name, I do not consider that unprofessional, just maybe humble.
3. It would not bother me to be corrected politely.
4 moms found this helpful
J.✰. answers from San Antonio on April 25, 2012
1. Sure. You got your doctorate. You deserve to be called Dr! I worked for a principal who had her doctorate in education of some sort. She did NOT go by "Mrs. Brown" but rather "Doctor Brown."
2. I guess it would depend on if they are older than me or not, or how they referred to themselves. So I might call Dr. Brown "Mary" the first time I meet her if that's how she introduced herself, but I would listen to how others refer to her "Mary" or "Dr. Brown". Eh MAYBE unprofessional, but someone wants you to call them what makes them COMFORTABLE ..... so they perhaps prefer to be called Mary instead of Dr. Brown.
3. In High School I had a teacher (with a doctorate) who we called "Mrs._" and she corrected us. At the time I thought she was Ms. High and Mighty. But as an adult, I see now that she worked hard and wants to be called Dr, so be it. No I would not be bothered. Depending on the person's personality I may find it odd/pushy. But if the business card said "DR Mary Brown" and the sign on the door said "DR BROWN" then I would likely have never called them Mr./Mrs. to begin with!
Added after reading an answer below: We see a PA (Physicians Assitant) and I do not feel comfortable calling her Andrea even if she is younger than me. I call her "Dr. Andrea" or "Dr. Smith" to my 4 yr old. Because to my son, she is to be respected and I don't think he should call her by her first name.
4 moms found this helpful
S.T. answers from Washington DC on April 25, 2012
i wouldn't feel uncomfortable addressing them by 'doctor.' they've earned it, right? but i'd follow their lead. if they intro-ed themselves by first name, that's what i'd use.
i'd probably do a silent mental eye-roll if i were corrected, but i wouldn't do anything but smile politely and accede.
khairete
S.
4 moms found this helpful
J.B. answers from Boston on April 25, 2012
1. Yes
2. I would probably call that person "Dr. First Name"
3. No, it wouldn't bother me
My husband's psychiatrist (who is our marriage counselor) is "Dr. Last Name" to us. Our family therapist, who is a psychologist, is "Dr. First Name" or just "First Name." The nutritionist is "Dr. First Name" and my chiropractor is "Dr. Last Name." I don't even think about it...it's all in how each practitioner introduces or markets him or herself. For example, the nutritionist is also a chiropractor but her web site and other materials refer to her as Dr. First Name so that's what we use while the other chiropractor's materials use Dr. Last Name so that's what we call him. Same with the two mental health professionals...one refers to himself as Dr. Last Name and the other as First Name.
4 moms found this helpful
M.S. answers from Dallas on April 25, 2012
As my mother said when she got her PhD in clinical psychology...
"I didn't spend this long in school, do this much research and roll this many peanuts across the floor with my nose to be called Mrs. I earned the title!"
If you know someone has a doctorate, always call them Dr. to start. If they correct you and tell you to call them x, then use that.
4 moms found this helpful
S.H. answers from St. Louis on April 25, 2012
I think anyone holding a doctorate deserves the title!
I remember thinking it was soooo cool that my grade school principal was Dr. Phillips!
1. yes!
2. if they choose to use their 1st name, then I would equally feel free to use their 1st name when speaking with them. When referencing the person to mutual friends, I would use the 1st name. When speaking to non-mutual friends, I would use Dr.
.....2nd part of #2. this would not feel unprofessional to me! It's their personal choice, & part of respect is to honor their choices. :)
3. absolutely not! If I made an error, then they are fully-justified in correcting me. How else would I learn of my error?
4 moms found this helpful
K.B. answers from Cincinnati on April 25, 2012
1. Absolutely- they went to school and earned the title.
2. If they introduce themselves by their first name, then that is what they want to be called, so I would call them by their first name. I don't think it makes them unprofessional.
3. If we were in a professional setting, then no, I wouldn't be offended if they corrected me. My last name is easy, but also easily mispronounced, and I have no problem correcting people when they pronounce it wrong-same thing to me.
Both of my parents are PhD's and my mom always uses "Dr." as her title in a professional setting. My dad, on the other hand, never does and half of the people that know him don't have a clue of his education- and he's fine with that. Its all personal preference.
3 moms found this helpful
Email