12 answers

Buying a Couch

Hi, although this is a question unrelated to parenting, since I've learned that there are many knowledgeable parents on this site, I wonder if I could get your input.

We're looking to buy a couch for our new house. We plan to live in this house for a long time, so we want to buy a solid one, but at an affordable price.

My understanding is that furniture stores go in the order of IKEA-Crates and Barrels --Pottery Barn in terms of price/quality (with PB being highest). Where do stores like Hom Furniture and Slumberland fall in this continuum? Any ideas on other stores worth looking into?

Also, those of you in St. Paul, MN area, do any of above stores have outlets in the St. Paul area?

I appreciate your input!

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

Also consider Room and Board and they do have a great outlet in Golden Valley in addition to their regular store in Edina.

More Answers

Also consider Room and Board and they do have a great outlet in Golden Valley in addition to their regular store in Edina.

We currently have 3 sofas, 2 were purchased at Costco and 1 from a local furniture store.
I agree with the poster who said no way to microfiber. My parents have a microfiber set and I hate it, I would never buy it myself. One of the sofas from Costco is leather, the other upholstered, and the third, from the local store, is an upholstered sectional made by England. The leather is really easy to keep clean, but I'm not wild about how cold it feels in the winter and how bare skin can stick to it in the warmer months. It looks great though.
The sectional (England) has held up really well, and I think that the construction is excellent. We have 3 German Shepherds who sleep on the furniture, and we entertain a lot, so our sofas get a lot of use. We've had the sectional 7 years and it's still in very good shape, no sagging or anything like that.
I would start at your local stores and see what they have. Pay attention to construction, for example, more frequent support beams in the sofa means less chance of drooping or sagging down the road.
I love Crate & Barrel's furniture, it is high quality, but you definitely pay for it.

Try the Marshall Fields Home Store in Roseville (Hamline, between B and B2). I think if you comparison shop you'll find the prices aren't too bad and the quality is generally very good, and you won't be paying the markup for the Pottery Barn brand name.

If you have time & the ability to pick up the furniture, you should seriously consider looking on Craigslist. I bought a huge sofa sectional for 1/3 the price & it was almost brandnew (tags still on) & we love it! The seller bought the sofa at HOM & even gave us the cleaning supplies. In fact, he showed us his receipt, proving it was only a year old. A lot of people have great furniture they need to sell b/c either they're moving or remodeling a room & the current furniture no longer will work for the space.

Since you'll have an opportunity to see it in person, you'll be able to tell if it's something in good condition & what you were hoping for. If it has stains, smells or is in an otherwise unkept home, obviously you might want to look elsewhere. Maybe we lucked out since this sofa was in a finished basement & the older couple (no kids, no pets) were looking to downsize into a condo. It can't hurt to look & you might get an idea of what certain materials will look like after a couple years of wear & tear. Just an option!

Keep in mind that you get what you pay for.

That said..........we have a leather set we purchased from Dillards (Natuzzi I believe) that has been a fantastic set for a living area. We have a second Natuzzi sofa in the game room.

For our formal living area, we went higher grade with Leather Sofa Company and they make the pieces per your specifications. We are happy with all our purchases.

Shop well, know what you are looking for before you shop and you can find something you like. Always remember.... you get what you pay for.. go cheap...get cheap

wherever you decide to get a couch from make sure you get the protection plan (scotchgaurding or whatever) it is worth the extra $$. For Christmas last year my in laws bought us new couches (we got to pick them) and we were very excited. We ended up getting microfiber dark brown couch and loveseat from American Signature. They don't do scotchgaurding, but they put their own thing on them and gaurentee the couches for 7 years (2 years longer than most other places) if these couches ever get stained or torn for any reason they will be replaced for no charge to us at all, if they can't fix them. We have a 19 month old and a pomerian dog, and the couches still look brand new. If anything spills on them we take a dry paper towel, push it on, and the spot is gone instantly.

Good luck!!

We bought a couch three years ago and loved it...for three days. It was our first try with microfiber. And it was awful!! We wanted to get rid of it almost immediately. I swore off microfiber forever and insisted we'd only get upholstery. We put up with the couch for a year and then started looking. We started writing down designer names and models. A simple google search got us all kinds of reviews. I was a little surprised. Of course you can run in to a bad review on anything, but it really helped us sort through what we were considering (the couch we bought had awful, horrible reviews). We bought the new couch and it's microsuede (even after swearing never again...this one got great reviews) and we love it!!! It acts just like I thought microfiber should. It looks great and it's comfortable.I will never shop for furniture again without reading some reviews.

We got our first sofa and love seat set from JCPenney about 5 1/2 years ago And besides being dirty from our dog and our 18 month old daughter, they are in great shape. We paid around $800 for the set. Also, we got a set from the Room Store for around $1100 about 2 years ago, and they look brand new. Both sets we use everyday.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.