P.O. asks from Christiana, TN on November 10, 2009
Booster Seat - What Is the Purpose
I am going to have a 4yr old next week and have been hearing I will soon need a booster seat. What is the purpose of a booster seat versus just sitting in the car and putting on the seat belt. He is getting big for the regular seat so I was thinking what to do. Is this booster seat just to be able to let them see out the window or is there some safety rule involved. Let me know.
So What Happened?™
THank you moms for your input. My son is already 43 pounds and is a big 3yr old to be 4 soon. As for the adult belt not fitting properly around waist in the event of an accident, that makes sense. I just didn't want to buy an unnecessary gadget. I am practical, so I wanted to make sure it was serving a purpose.
Featured Answers
L.H. answers from Miami on November 11, 2009
chiming in late but would like this on record, in case anyone else finds this post later on:
It you MUST get a booster, get a HIGH BACK BOOSTER.
or, go for a 5-pt harness booster, the Safeguard Go seat.
Little ones are too LITTLE for backless boosters!
read here:
http://www.mountnittany.org/wellness-library/healthsheets...
J.R. answers from Tampa on November 11, 2009
Here is a link to a website that explains a bit more about safety and car seats / booster seats (from the Florida Highway Patrol):
http://www.flhsmv.gov/fhp/CPS/4Steps.htm
Hope this helps!
More Answers
K.G. answers from Tampa on November 11, 2009
Honestly at just 4yrs old he needs to be harnessed. He may be a big boy but he doesn't have the maturity to sit properly in a booster seat. That means no playing with the seat belts, leaning over to get a toy, moving the belt behind his head, etc. It means sitting up completely straight and still. My 7yr old still has problems with that sometimes in dh's car. He still is harnessed in my car as is my 4.5yr old.
Have you thought about getting him a different harnessed seat that turns into a booster later on? Like a Graco Nautilus or Britax Fronier? Check out what car seat techs have to say online. You can find them at http://www.car-seat.org/ or on Babycenters car seat board. HTH!
L.G. answers from Tampa on November 10, 2009
A booster seat is a safety device and there are guidelines that need to be met other than age to determine if the child is ready for a booster or should still be harnessed. The child should be at least 40 lbs and 40 in.
Also, for a child that young, you should use a decent quality high back booster like a Graco Turbobooster. The Turbobooster is relatively inexpensive. I paid around $50 for one.
IMO, a four year old is too young and small to just sit in the seat with a seat belt. The seat belt will not fit them or protect them properly. A high back booster will position the seat belt correctly.
J.J. answers from Orlando on November 11, 2009
The law is that they must use a car seat or booster seat until age three. At that time, it is not requred as long as the shoulder belt fits properly with no "adjustments". The shoulder part must lay over the should and not across the neck. It can not have the little strap adjuster you can put on for use with booster seats.
J.T. answers from Tampa on November 11, 2009
My 4.5 yo is 50 lbs and 48", so we moved her to the Graco Turbobooster, with seatbelt adjusting harness/tether. It was only $22 at Walmart. It's perfect becuase it keeps the seat belt positioned over her hips (where it should be) and the seat-belt strap keeps the upper strap over her shoulder (where it should be and not her neck). Just make sure you re-install the car's headrest if you took it out.
Also, the Graco Turbobooster was rated #1 booster seat by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety:
http://www.parenting.com/gear-gallery/Gear/10-Safest-Boos...
D.K. answers from Port St. Lucie on November 11, 2009
All booster seats do is raise them higher so that the seatbelt fits. I (and many other moms out there) feel strongly that at 4 years old, they should still be harnessed. There are a lot of newer seats out there that allow bigger kids to stay safely harnessed up to 80 pounds. We have the Britax Frontier for my almost 5 year old. He will use it as a harness seat for another year, or two or three if I can keep him in! Then it converts to a booset up to 100 pounds. Graco makes a similar seatthat is a little less expensive too, called the Nautilus. If you are interested, check out elitecarseats.com for many in depth reviews about the other non-booster options.
T.O. answers from Sarasota on November 10, 2009
C.W. answers from Miami on November 11, 2009
i know this wasn't part of the question, but if he doesn't come with the seat, you can find great deals for them on craigslist. (i'm sure you know but...
K.D. answers from Tampa on November 11, 2009
for safety of course. it helps prevent getting choked by the seat belt. ( it puts his neck/head at the proper level. it also helps keep them seated better when traveling in the car.
Email