S.C. asks from Dallas, TX on March 15, 2008
Booster Seat Recommendations Needed
My 3 1/2 year old daughter has outgrown her carseat and I am trying to decide on a booster seat. I've done some research online and have seen the Compass and Britax mentioned quite a bit, but I am still not sure which one to get. She uses a Britax carseat now. Safety is the top priority, then price, then ease of use.
Any thoughts on the Compass or Britax models of booster seats (non-harness versions), or any other booster that you love, would be greatly appreciated!!
Thanks,
S.
So What Happened?™
I get the Mamasource digest and don't think all the postings get included (if someone else reads this who gets the digest and did see it, please let me know I'm wrong about this, but I seem to see stuff on the site that I didn't see in the email). I will be looking into a larger 5-pt harness seat after watching that video. Thank you!
Featured Answers
C.P. answers from Dallas on March 16, 2008
Hi S.!
I have a Britax also for my 26 month old son that goes to 65lbs. I also have a 6 month old that will need a new carseat soon. Anyways, I love the Britax Decathlon for the safety ratings and reviews, but I do not love the price. I have actually just recently seen the new Graco Nautilus 3 in 1. It goes from 20lbs to 100lbs. It has the 5 point harness, then is a belt positioner and then a backless booster. Also the cost is $150, which is awesome to me. I love graco products and have used them with both children. We have the pack n play, the infant seat, the full size stroller, and a Comfortsport for the second car. The Comfortsport carseat was highly ranked as well, but as I said, it is for the second car. Anyway, just giving you another option to explore, hope this helps!
More Answers
C.P. answers from Dallas on March 16, 2008
Hi S.!
I have a Britax also for my 26 month old son that goes to 65lbs. I also have a 6 month old that will need a new carseat soon. Anyways, I love the Britax Decathlon for the safety ratings and reviews, but I do not love the price. I have actually just recently seen the new Graco Nautilus 3 in 1. It goes from 20lbs to 100lbs. It has the 5 point harness, then is a belt positioner and then a backless booster. Also the cost is $150, which is awesome to me. I love graco products and have used them with both children. We have the pack n play, the infant seat, the full size stroller, and a Comfortsport for the second car. The Comfortsport carseat was highly ranked as well, but as I said, it is for the second car. Anyway, just giving you another option to explore, hope this helps!
R.C. answers from Dallas on March 16, 2008
We have the Britax Regent and my daughter loves it. I would not get a seat without the harness. My daughter falls asleep in the car a lot and she would be flopping all over in the regular booster.
Good luck with your decision.
D.W. answers from Wichita Falls on March 16, 2008
My personal opinion is at 3 1/2 years old she is too young to be out of a 5 pt harness. I would suggest looking at the graco nautilis. I have been doing research for months on this seat and many car seat tech's recommend this seat. You can find it at Walmart, but they tend to sell out fast. The great thing with this seat is that it goes up to 65 pounds in the 5 pt harness and 100 as a booster. You get a lot of seat for the money. I went to buy my son one yesterday and they were sold out. It sells for $149.95... Good luck in deciding what seat to purchase.
D.
SAHM 3 great kids and proud military spouse.
J.G. answers from Dallas on March 17, 2008
S.,
My daughter started out with a Britax and we decided that when she got older that we would try a more affordable seat instead. We definitely got what we paid for! It was awful and we took it back and spent the extra money on a Britax and it was such a huge difference! Something as important as a carseat or safety seat is worth the extra money knowing that your child is secure in a vehicle!
K.H. answers from Dallas on March 17, 2008
I don't have a specific carseat to recommend, but I do recommend to use a carseat with a five point harness. If you use just a regualar booster your child can unbuckel it eaiser or slip out of the belt while you are driving. I recieved an email about a child whose seat came loose in a wreck because the cars seatbelt malfunctioned. The child didn't survive and it could have been different had the child been in a carseat with ancors versus a booster.
S.H. answers from Dallas on March 15, 2008
I got the Graco TurboBooster SafeSeat (Step 3) 8496SAM in Samantha for my twin girls. So far, we love it!
http://www.albeebaby.com/grtusas384in.html
I got it based on reviews at http://www.consumersearch.com/www/family/booster-seats/in...
C.S. answers from Dallas on March 16, 2008
M.G. answers from Dallas on March 16, 2008
I would not get a booster, I would get another 5pt harness seat. They are much safer and most 3+ year olds do not have the disipline to sit still all the time to make a regular seat belt and booster effective if you were in a crash. You did not say your daughter's weight or which current seat you have. I would get a Britax Regent, if $$ are an issue I would look into the new Graco Natilus it is harnessed up to 65# I have seen it recommended on some other boards that I read by many carseat techs.
Email