12 answers

Birthday Cake Alternatives

My little boy is turning 2 in February and I'm looking for an alternative to a typical birthday cake. Have any of you made anything different for your toddler's birthday? I'd love any suggestions that you have!

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

I made rice crispy treats. I colored the marshmellows, grease a Lightning McQueen cake pan really well and pressed the mix in. Once it was set, I flipped it out and decorated it with frosting. It was a hit with the kids. I'd do it again. In fact I have a recipe for a ginger bread house made out of rice crispy treats. You could also make them in a normal cake pan and decorate it just like a cake.

More Answers

Have you maybe thought about a strawberry jello cake ? It is white cake mix, that you cook all the way then you mix up a package of jello and when the cake is cooled you poke random holes in it and pour the jello on top of that.. then you spread cool whip over the top and if youd like you can decorate with strawberries or whatever.. its really good. Maybe even do cupcake .....

I made rice crispy treats. I colored the marshmellows, grease a Lightning McQueen cake pan really well and pressed the mix in. Once it was set, I flipped it out and decorated it with frosting. It was a hit with the kids. I'd do it again. In fact I have a recipe for a ginger bread house made out of rice crispy treats. You could also make them in a normal cake pan and decorate it just like a cake.

I have done all the suggested ideas for parties, and they all have went over well!

I also did a gigantic cookie ordered from a local bakery or made yourself. You can write Happy Birthday on it, even put candles in it, and serve with icecream and chocolate syrup!

Have Fun!!!

GL:)

Pies are good...fruit pies or pudding pies. Rice Krispie treats are fun for kids too and less messy on your floors.

I decorate cakes with all kinds of themes, a Nemo cake and Dora Beach Party were fun ones to do. Fancy decorating pans are easy to do and there are tons of books out there to help you learn to decorate them with the fancy icing tips.

Hi A.,
We bake sugar cookies & let the kids frost & decorate. He might be a little young for that but most kids like to get "dirty". Have fun!
T.

Any cupcakes are great for the younger kids! He might be able to help you pick out the flavor of cake and the frosting he likes! You can also make these ahead of time and freeze them in an airtight container and defrost the night before the party and frost them then. I let my 3 and 5 year olds put sprinkles on two cakes I made for a holiday party, I just put the cakes in a fairly big box and put the box on the floor and they stood over them and had a sprinkling-good time! (And it wasn't messy! :) )

I say you can pretty much do whatever you want for a treat! Pudding, ice cream, rice krispie treats! I have gotten a candle into just about everything...even a frosted cookie!! Have fun planning it, I love that part the most!

since he's a boy he might like the worms in dirt cupcakes.
i think you can find something like that online
recipes.com or allrecipes.com
the 'dirt' is crumbled up oreos i think and then you use gummy worms coming out the top.. not sure what the 'cake' part is made of,, if just cake or something else..

for my daughter's 1st birthday she wasn't on solid foods yet since she was 3 months premature she was behind 3 months in that. so we did jell-o cups and whipped cream. she was a big red mess!! but funny looking..lol
for her 2nd birthday a friend made a castle cake using pink cones for the towers.
this 3rd birthday she had a ice cream cake!! awesome.. because what isn't eaten, you can freeze in an air tight container and nibble on later. as with cake cake leftovers dry up quickly.

my son will probably have an ice cream cake for his 4th birthday next week.. thanks for reminding me..lol lol
good luck.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.