41 answers

Behavior or Actually a Medical Problem

How do I get my 4 1/2 year old to stop pooping in his pants. He will not tell me he needs to go. We have had a problem with constipation and he takes miralax everyday. I have tried everything rewards and discipline. He thinks it will hurt when he goes on the potty, after I make him sit there for how ever long he decideds to stop holding it and go, he says that didn't hurt I say I told you. We have been to Gastro about this. Please Help, any other ideas. I am at my wits end. He will go in his pants and not tell me, I am constantly asking him if he needs to go. I have told him I am tired of cleaning up poop. I have told him were gonna go to the Dr. to scare him. i have said everything and done everything. I don't know how to get it through his head to stop. I have wondered if it was a behavior thing and if I should take him to a Psychologist just for them to talk to him. Please Help Thanks

3 moms found this helpful

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

I want to Thank everyone for responding. It was nice to hear all the different opinions. Last night I watched him and knew he had to go, we were out at dinner and he wanted to stand up and not sit down, when we got home I made him sit on the potty and he went aboout 10 min later. He has pooped in his pants twice now and I have made himself clean up. He didn't like it, but we will see how it goes. Thanks

Featured Answers

When I tell you this, you may think that I am a terrible mother and terribly mean but this is what I did with my now 22 yr old. When he was 3 he was doing the same thing. He would hold it so long it would get hard and then he was scared to go. I did, like you, everything that I knew. Finally I just got tired of cleaning poop. He caught me on a really bad day and I didn't have time for that and when he pooped I made him take them off by himself, I made him wipe himself the best he could, and best of all, I made him put his training pants in the commode and wash them out with his hands; he did everything all by himself. I was so angry at him because it was at the most UNconvenient time. I yelled at him and told him that he could do this everytime he pooped in his pants because I was tired of doing it and it was his poop not mine so he should have to clean it up.
Do you know that child did not do that one other time. He pooped in the potty from them on.
It sounds mean but Hey....... IT WORKED.

1 mom found this helpful

J.,
I would not use the dr. to scare him b/c when he does go to the dr. he will think it's a scary place. However I can only tell yo what I did as a nanny, I went and got a white board (the kind for science projects ) and I took a marker, their fav. color and make the month calender on it. For every day they use the potty correctly and no accidents they got a sticker and with every sister they got a quarter. @ the end of the week we would cash in the quarters for candy or save to add next weeks with and go get a toy. It worked for me and the child. I was teaching potty rules along with what money can and can;t buy and even @ 3 she was able to see that saving for a bigger item was better and would last longer than candy. I don't know if this will help you but I do wish you a lot of luck.
T.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi J.,

You've gotten good advice, and I hope all the info helps you with the problem. I just thought I'd mention that perhaps he's taking a little too much Miralax. If it makes his poop very soft, he might not be able to make it to the toilet in time, and so he soils his pants. Certainly this doesn't take away the complication of the other parts of the equation, but I just wondered if you might want to lower the amount of the Miralax and see if it helps a little.

All my best,
D.

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

Look up the word Encoparesis on the web - your son might have this. This is a learned response (they learn to hold in their stool) very common in boys up to 10% have this. Miralax is not the solution!! (I think some of the ladies who responded previously may have kids who also have this very common disorder) My son had encoparesis and the long term use of laxatives do not work (may need them temporarily until he is retrained). Use the web and check out different websites on Encoparesis for solutions that work for you - I used: dump diapers.com
Children eating healthy diets with plenty of fruit and veggies should not have constipation and should not need to be on laxatives! Dump diapers.com
Has an excellent bowel retraining program that works -Laxatives just cover up the problem and cause the children to have accidents.
I am also a Registered Nurse - but didn't learn about encoparesis in Nursing School. If you can't find the bowel retraining program e-mail me back I will send it to you.

4 moms found this helpful

Hi, felt compelled to respond to your situation. My son went through this during Kindergarted. I was beside myself. I would try rewards if he'd stop pooping in his pants. I tried discipline. Nothing worked. I just couldn't understand how he was doing this. If he could poop in his pants he could poop in the potty. How wrong I was! One night I sad down on the internet and learned about Encoparesis. My son had all this symptoms and he couldn't help himself. He was so backed up that he couldn't even feel when he was going in his pants. I felt like the worse Mom. I had been so hard on him, as if he were doing this to me on purpose. We went to the doctor, I explained what had been happening. He prescribed a fiber powder. I apologize, I don't remember what it is called. This was 2 years ago. This powder can be put in water, juice, anything. He couldn't taste it. Within a couple days he was back to normal. What started all this was him having hard stools and being afraid to poop. He didn't want it to hurt so he made himself not poop. When he finally starting going normal again. I explained to him that he can never hold back again or he will go through all this again. He was so happy to have it taken care of. He was no longer embarrassed anymore. I hope this helps!

3 moms found this helpful

Sounds Like a Control issue.

Offer him more control in his own life. Examine your family life to see if there is stress. (Kids know, even if you think they dont)

I agree with another person, benefiber! And be sure he is drinking lots of water. The benefiber is tasteless & no texture. I slip it into my 3 yo's drink when needed.

The laxative will screw him up pretty good.

SUGGESTIONS FOR OFFERING MORE CONTROL:
Set out 3 outfits (you approve) and let him choose the one he wants

Let him choose of he wants to brush his teeth before or after bath time.

Let him pour his own water to drink & stir in the fiber!

You can turn almost anything that is a struggle into a controlled "choice". With new-found control in his own life he will not have to create situations.

best of luck

3 moms found this helpful

We had the exact same problem with our daughter. With her it started at age 4 and even taking the Miralax the doctor recommended, it was still a problem as she was going into 1st grade. We tried everything that has been mentioned in all the responses you've gotten and nothing worked. She is very well behaved and this had been the only problem we had ever had with her, so we were at our wit's end until I searched the internet for some explanation. What we came up with was a condition called Encopresis. Basically, it starts out with the constipation and the fear that it will hurt when they poop, so they hold it in, but then it does turn into a medical issue that they can't control. Being a pediatric nurse you may have already checked this out, but if not, it could make a world of difference. I took the information I gathered to our pediatrician and they agreed and we started on a course of action that did finally resolve the issue. Here's a webpage that describes it, or just Google it.

http://kidshealth.org/parent/general/sick/encopresis.html

Good luck. I hope this helps, I do understand the frustration.

2 moms found this helpful

We had a problem with our son afraid to poop on the potty also
he too was getting a little big I thought to have such a problem.
Our doctor said some kids are afraid of certain things and so we just had to keep working at it so we decided to put a sticker sheet on the wall in the bathroom and when he went on the potty he got a special sticker to put up there and after he went for a week on the potty he received a special reward.

It didn't take him long to catch on and once he received his special reward we took the sticker sheet down and let him have it to keep in a special place

1 mom found this helpful

J.,
I would not use the dr. to scare him b/c when he does go to the dr. he will think it's a scary place. However I can only tell yo what I did as a nanny, I went and got a white board (the kind for science projects ) and I took a marker, their fav. color and make the month calender on it. For every day they use the potty correctly and no accidents they got a sticker and with every sister they got a quarter. @ the end of the week we would cash in the quarters for candy or save to add next weeks with and go get a toy. It worked for me and the child. I was teaching potty rules along with what money can and can;t buy and even @ 3 she was able to see that saving for a bigger item was better and would last longer than candy. I don't know if this will help you but I do wish you a lot of luck.
T.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi there-- I found this thread very interesting. I have an 8 year old daughter who has struggled with daytime wetting for many years. Most recently, we were told it's due to constipation and she should be on Miralax daily for the next year.

A lot of children struggle with this sort of thing-- in fact so much so that the Children's Hospital of Denver puts on a twice monthly free seminar about this very issue. That's a good place to get some professional advice.

After making many errors and having many people tell me that it's psychological we found out that it was indeed a medical issue. I know how frustrating this all is-- it's very hard. But please be very careful about instituing any form of punishment for this problem. Just like punishing or rewarding your child with food can cause eating disorders later in life and, so can punishing your child regarding elimination issues can cause continued problems in that area. I'm off to look up some links from this thread. Best wishes to you.

1 mom found this helpful

I have a cousin that has 3 boys under the age of 6. The oldest child was still messing his pants and they were so agrivated that one day they told him to get to the bathroom and clean it up himself. They told him they were tired of cleaning it up. That he made the mess and dont come out till it was cleaned up. He quit after cleaning up the mess a few times. I can tell you that I did make my 3 yr old boy change himself completely and take care of his undies when he made messes and finally he has caught on that it is easier to just go to the potty. I was never mean about it. I just told him "you made the mess so you have to clean it up." Trouble with constipation may be some of the issue but if he has went and realizes it does not hurt now he should be ok.

1 mom found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.