S.C. asks from Patchogue, NY on October 21, 2011
Baking Without Eggs
Hello Mamas,
Long story short, I am on a dairy free, egg free diet so I can breastfeed my daughter who has allergies (BTW, a big thank you to those moms who helped me make that decision when I asked about it 4 months ago!). A helpful friend recommended that I buy Duncan Hines brownie mix (it's dairy free) so I can get my chocolate fix. But I am having a problem finding a good substitute for the eggs. I tried substituting applesauce and the brownies in the middle part of the pan was mushy. Then I tried substituting a combination of water + cornstarch and applesauce. When I tried to cut the brownies they basically fell apart and had the consistency of bread crumbs. Believe me, it did not go to waste. I stuck it in a tupperware container and ate it with a spoon for the next week. Daily dose of chocolate = happy mommy. :)
So I figured there must be some moms out there more experienced in the allergy / baking with substitutes department. Any advice? I would be thrilled if I could just make a tray of brownies or a box of cake mix and it would turn out to be presentable for company (in case I decide to share!). FYI, a google search turns up many recommendations of using water & cornstarch in place of eggs, but everyone seems to have different measurements.... looking for someone who has used water & cornstarch successfully (baked good didn't fall apart). Any tips? Thank you!!!
More Answers
M.B. answers from Austin on October 21, 2011
I have a wonderful recipe for chocolate cake.... Wacky Chocolate cake!
It is egg free... and very moist!
3 C flour
2 C sugar
6 T cocoa (baking cocoa..dry powder)
2 tsp baking soda
3 T vinegar
2 tsp vanilla
3/4 C veg. oil
2 C cold water
Mix dry ingredients in a 9 x 13 pan, then make 3 holes... in one hole put 3/4 C veg. oil, in one hole put 2 tsp vanilla, in the 3rd hole put 3 T vinegar, then pour 2 C water over the whole thing. Mix well and bake for 45 min at 325 degrees.
If you want a minty flavor, put in about 1/2 capful mint extract... yum!
I don't even bother icing the cake... very moist and delicious! It disappears VERY quickly around this house when I bake it. Also, no bowls to clean.. mix it all in the baking pan.
2 moms found this helpful
C.M. answers from Chicago on October 21, 2011
I am allergic to eggs and there is only one recipe I use for brownies. Nothing else has worked for me. Applesauce works great for cookies and I also use Ener-G Egg replacer but it doesn't work in brownies.
This is called the Mug Brownie, and I call it the PMS brownie! It is a brownie for one and you make it in a mug in the microwave. It absolutely gets my chocolate fix and you can add all sorts of things to it to customize it.
4 Tablespoons flour
4 Tablespoons granulated sugar
2 Tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder
2 Tablespoons vegetable oil (I use canola)
2 Tablespoons water
a dash of salt.
A microwaveable mug
Mix sugar, flour cocoa and salt in a mug with a fork. Then add the oil and water and mix. Be thorough.
Microwave for about a minute, depending on the microwave. It should still be wet in the center when done.
Let it cool and enjoy straight from the mug! I like mine with a scoop of ice cream or some cool whip. I also have been known to add a dollop of caramel or peanut butter!
For a fluffier brownie add only 1 Tbsp of oil and 3 Tbsp of water plus 1/4 tsp vanilla extract and 1/2 tsp baking powder.
You can also put in some chocolate chips, butterscotch chips or use your imagination! Tiny m&ms--the possibilities are endless!
Let me know if you want more egg free, dairy free recipes. I have a cookbook that's specifically for that allergy.
Enjoy!
1 mom found this helpful
K.M. answers from Norfolk on October 22, 2011
Put the box of mix in a bowl & then open a can of cola soda (diet or regular) and take a medium sized sip out of it and pour the rest in the bowl and mix. That's it. Bake as usual.
Did you try playing with the measurement of applesauce? I've used it several times and never had that happen. Maybe you just need to play a little?
You can also use canned pumpkin (not pumpkin pie filling) too, just the mix & pumpkin filling. Doesn't taste like pumpkin either. I don't like pumpkin but can't taste it in these.
M.H. answers from Chicago on October 21, 2011
My friend is on weight watchers.. Take the brownie/cake mix and mix it with pureed black beans(might add a touch of water).. they taste great.. and add protein to your treat.
Good luck
K.C. answers from Los Angeles on October 21, 2011
Here is my substitute for each egg in a recipe:
1.5 TBSP water
1.5 TBSP oil
1 tsp baking powder
(mix all ingredients together, then add as one mixture when you would normally add an egg)
All that said, I find brownies to be the hardest thing to make without eggs. They usually turn out pretty crumbly. The best one I've done is the Ghiradelli chocolate chip mix (also dairy free) and then using the above mixture for eggs. They don't rise as much as regular brownies, but they taste great and they don't fall apart.
I've never loved EnerG replacer and prefer the oil-water-baking powder mix.
If you PM me your email address, I can email you a great chocolate cake recipe that is SO yummy! My friends who aren't dairy- and egg-free all love it and even make it for their parties sometimes.
And, for the record... a handful of ghiradelli chocolate chips can help with your chocolate fix anytime! :D
J.G. answers from Minneapolis on October 21, 2011
I use the Ener-G egg replacer in all my baking too, it works great.
D.D. answers from Phoenix on October 21, 2011
Ener-G egg replacer. Hit up some vegan websites and cookbooks because they are egg free and dairy free and have the best tips for substituting. Of course any recipe that calls for milk, you should be able to sub soy, rice or even coconut.
This is the best recipe for vegan cupcakes and frosting. I made it myself and it is OUTSTANDING!
http://www.marthastewart.com/315948/divvies-chocolate-cup...
http://www.marthastewart.com/319079/divvies-vanilla-frosting
A.G. answers from Houston on October 21, 2011
Ive always liked how yogurt worked but you cant really do that......ive read flax seed meal is a possibility
BTW, im pretty sure the main ingredient in ener g is cornstarch.......i could be wrong though
Email