22 answers

Baby Wearing Advice

I have been researching different baby carriers for my 3rd baby due next month. I had a Baby Bjorn with the first two, and rarely ever used it. I am leaning toward a wrap, but was curious as to whether moms preferred a stretchy wrap like the Moby or a woven wrap. If you use any kind of sling or wrap, I'd love to hear what works for you.

S.

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

I know I am getting in on this really late, but I use a Maya Wrap Ring Sling and my son (2 months old) loves it, plus it has made it soooo easy to be exclusively breastfeeding because I can breastfeed in the grocery store and no one can see anything. Another thing I like about it is my hubby can wear it, and if I need to, I can carry my 2 year old on my hip with it.

HI S., I have the Moby Wrap and I love it. It is really easy to use once you follow the directions and remember how to use it for different positions. I found that my little girl enjoyed it. My little girl is 9 months old and I am looking forward to using it outside this S.. Good luck with you new baby!

More Answers

Hi, S.! (Love that name, by the way.) I went to a natural baby store in Asheville, NC, and one of the owners was the mother to a 1-year old. She said she had had the opportunity to try every wrap they sold, and even ones they decided not to sell, and her favorite was a non-stretchy wrap (because unlike the stretchy ones, it's supportive and doesn't sag down, which ends up straining the back, and gets worse over time). It's German, and it's called the Storchen Wiege Ihr Babytragetuch. You could order it from The Nest in Asheville, and they'll tell you what size to get and answer your questions. She showed us her favorite way to wrap it, which takes about 30 seconds when you practice a couple of times, and we tried it with a stuffed animal about the size and weight of a med-big baby. It was SO CUDDLY. I felt like I was getting one long hug, and thought, wow, that's how my baby will feel. I can't wait for our baby to be born so I can carry her this way!!! My husband loved it, too, and we joke that we'll fight over baby-carrying rights. It's also *very* secure, even for a newborn. She went line dancing or some kind of dancing with her son in it 6 weeks after he was born. But for some less vigorous uses (!), it comes with a CD and pamphlet that show some of the other ways of tying the wrap that look simpler and quicker, too.

We've heard from several sources that we should get a couple of different kinds of slings/wraps so that we can use them for different occasions/needs. For example, this wrap that we got, which takes some finagling, is not good for driving around on errands (into the wrap, run errand; out of the wrap, in the carseat; drive; out and wrap again...out of the wrap, into the carseat...) but it will be great for gardening, long walks/hikes/exercise, being around the house, etc. For walking around town, basic slings are great because it keeps strangers' hands off of the baby, whose immune system isn't up and running yet. They're also great for those quick errands - no tying and wrapping; just pop the baby in and go.

Hope this helps!

L.

1 mom found this helpful

I have a hotsling and my two month old LOVES it! As soon as I put him in it he calms immediately and goes to sleep! My husband bought a Karmababy sling for himself and the material is too stretchy. The baby hangs down to his stomach, not supportive at all!
I've heard that slings or wraps are better on baby's spine than the carriers because the baby's legs don't hang down.
Good luck!

My little one is about 6 1/2 months old. I've used a ring sling with her for most of that time. I had an Ellaroo wrap (nonstretchy) that I used sometimes (mostly for longer outings) with her. I preferred the ring sling, especially when she was younger because it made breastfeeding easier. With the Ellaroo I had to remember to bring along a blanket or something to cover up whereas with the ring sling I just used the tail.

I just bought an Ergo that I think I'm going to love (only tried it on just last night but as soon as I put E in it she was all smiles). The other advantage to the Ergo is that DH will probably use it. The wrap was just way too much for him. He wore it once, but only because I was there to put him in it.

The only problem that I've heard with the Moby (strechy) wraps is that they aren't as good for back carries. So it wouldn't last you as long.

Just my thoughts/ observations on the subject.

Good luck and congratulations,
A.

I had an over the shoulder baby holder for my son and wore him in it until he was about a year old (when he started walking he didn't want to be carried any more) I will definately use it with the next one. I had a baby bjorn as well but sold it after only a few uses I couldn't stand it.

I completely understand the baby bijorn carrier...it just isn't comfortable. With my second daughter I bought a sling from Kangaroo Korner online. It is so comfortable and the nice thing is you can put a newborn in it. I LOVE my sling. It's the adjustable fleece pouch from Kangarookorner.com Good luck!

I have a Mamas Milk sling. I love it. It goes from newborn to toddler. When I first got it I was pregnant with my third and my second was 20 months or so and he loved it! It was so much easier to carry him that way being so PG. My baby has loved it since she was born. I use it mainly when I drop my 4 year old of to school. I need 2 hands to hold on to the 2 boys and yet carry her. It is quick and easy to use. East to nurse in also. I found it much easier than my stroller just to pop her into it. Go to http://www.mammasmilk.com. They have all kinds of colors and they match the size nicely. I loved it because I didn't have a bunch of extra fabric hanging around.

I would go for a woven over a stretchy. The stretchy wraps are great for newborns, but once your baby is bigger than about 15 pounds they can stretch and sag and then become less comfortable. A woven will be supportive until 30+ pounds.

You should check out www.magiccitysligners.com and try to hit one of their meetings. They should have some wraps you can feel and try and they could offer advice as well as help sizing.

I wanted to add that I used a woven wrap even for quick in/out trips/errands using the Pocket Wrap Cross Carry when my little one was a newborn without difficulty. I have a Storchenweige stripe, a Storchenwiege Leo and a Didymos waves. I have also used a Vatanai and a Moby. My favorites are the Storches.

I have both a Hotsling and a Moby Wrap for "wearing" our 3 1/2 month old and I like them both for different reasons.

Since we bought a non-stretchy Hotsling sized for me, my husband hasn't been able to use it with our baby since she got to be more than 9 pounds. The Hotsling is certainly easy to put on because you just slip it over one shoulder, then position it into a number of ways depending on the size/age of baby, put baby in and go. My little one sleeps in best in this sling. Hotslings include a DVD on how to use it.

The Moby Wrap comes with an instruction booklet for using it in the various positions. Our baby girl loves to face out in this one and see the world all around her when she is awake. Because this is made from the knit jersey type cloth and is super long, both my husband and I can use this one. I do feel like the fabric stretches allowing our baby to ride a bit lower as we walk so I'm cinching it tighter when I initially put it on now.

I believe we ordered both of them while on sale from www.babycenterstore.com

Enjoy the closeness of your baby wearing~

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.