J.C. asks from Berwyn, IL on September 05, 2007
Baby Water
I'm a first time mom to a beautiful 5 1/2 month old baby girl. I'm breastfeeding so the doctor says I don't need to give her water. However, I'm also making homemade babyfood for her & am in need of advice on what type of water I could use or if I could just purify it myself at home. I discovered that the "Nursery" water for babies sold in stores has added Flouride which I see no use for in babies & I've also read that Flouride is a slow-cancer causing agent...SO, can I just boil bottled water like natural spring water or can I just give the bottled water to her without boiling? I will mainly be using it to thin out the babyfood I make for her.
So What Happened?™
Thank you all for your responses. I would use breastmilk to thin the babyfood if I were able to produce enough but i don't. When I pump it has to be while she's feeding from the opposite side, only then will I get atleast 2 ounces but I could only pump when she has her solid food meal because then she will only feed from the one side leaving the other with milk I can pump. I usually do use the water that I boil the squash in to thin it out when I puree but I need water for when I make the sweet potato because I bake it.
Thank you all for your suggestions & responses, they were very helpful! :o)
Featured Answers
M.H. answers from Chicago on September 06, 2007
I made my own baby food too and my doctor said to just use filtered tap water. I would use either breast milk or the water that I oiled or steamed the veggies in to thin it.
K. answers from Chicago on September 05, 2007
We always used experessed breast milk to thin the food (but I was also working FT so we had a lot of milk on hand). If you don't have a pump or don't want to mess with it, I think any filtered tap water is fine.
More Answers
D.R. answers from Chicago on September 06, 2007
I am a dental hygienist and from my experience it would be beneficial to give her the nursery water. We have unfortunately seen the effects of kids not getting enough fluoride as the teeth are developing---weak and mottled enamel with white spots on the teeth and a higher incidence of decay. Fluoride is also important for bone strength and we all know how critical that is especially for females.
I certainly understand your concerns with cancer, however the doses of ingested fluoride that have been shown with any link with cancer are extremely high---there was a generation of kids that was given fluoride tablets as a supplement and their incidence of cancer is no higher than anyone else's. I am also a very health conscious mom of 2 boys (low sugar, no dairy, both breastfed for a year) but I do give my boys nursery water because the benefits FAR outweigh any slight risk.
Good luck to you!
K. answers from Chicago on September 05, 2007
We always used experessed breast milk to thin the food (but I was also working FT so we had a lot of milk on hand). If you don't have a pump or don't want to mess with it, I think any filtered tap water is fine.
C.L. answers from Chicago on September 06, 2007
It might also be a good idea to use your own breast milk to mix with it-thats what my sister does and it works well.
P.D. answers from Chicago on September 05, 2007
J.:
why not express and use some of your breast milk?
P., RLC, IBCLC
Pres. Lactation Support Group, Inc
www.lactationsupportgroup.com
J.S. answers from Chicago on September 06, 2007
Tap water or bottle water is fine or you can even mix it with your milk. I pumped at first and mixed with my milk and then I eventually just switched to using tap water, which my daughter drinks now. In fact, tap water does contain small amounts of flouride in it that they say is suppose to be sufficient for kids. I haven't heard anything about the cancer causing but I did hear that too much flouride can cause some discoloring of the teeth. However, since you are nursing and only using the water to mix with food you should be fine with whatever type of water you decide to use.
S.G. answers from Chicago on September 05, 2007
what about tap water?? My Pedi said tap water is fine (as long as we don't live in an area that solely uses well water)
T.B. answers from Chicago on September 06, 2007
The experts also say drinking a cold drink with a hot meal will give you stomach cancer.
The added Flouride helps make their teeth stronger when they come in---and I can tell the difference in my children. As for the long term effects, I was given added flouride when I was younger (we had to drink a cup at school every week), and I have yet to see an bad long-term effects.
D.R. answers from Chicago on September 06, 2007
By all means make your own nursery water by boiling the water for 15 minutes to rid the impurities. Let the water sit and cool. I nursed and made my own baby food too. After a year, I used regular tap water.
Email