B.C. asks from Madison, WI on July 17, 2008
Autism:how Do You Know If a Child Is Autistic?
i have a dear friend, my best friend of ten+years who has a 23 mo old who doesnt talk unless told to say words. i have noticed he is very sensitive to sensory things like holding and bathing. my friend is not aware of the symptoms of autism. I am sooooo concerned for them both. how do i talk to her about this or do i just sit back and ignore it? i hope that he just needs a speech therapist but im afraid there is more. i have had my concerns and sat back for the last year. I feel like i am not helping but how do i say something without offending her. I have mentioned if she talks to her doctor and she said that her child just doesnt talk and has issues because of an older sibling. i hope to god that i am wrong, but what if im not. the sooner the diagnosis the better the child will be. the child does not interact and has no interest in any task, little to no eye contact. maybe for a second or two. i dont think that a child has to be reaching every milestone exactly as other children but the child does not wave good bye or say hi even when you say it over and over. i have such mixed emotions, if i sit back and ignore it i am not being a good friend. but if i say something and i am wrong i look like a jerk
1 mom found this helpful
Featured Answers
D.T. answers from Madison on July 21, 2008
maybe you could suggest she contact her birth - 3 agency to have speech issues looked at. They are more than willing to come out and they will actually look at everything as far as developmental milestones, etc. This might be a way for her to get help or you to bring it up in a less threatening way - speech issues vs. autism which is very scary for many parents to even think about.
H.A. answers from Waterloo on July 18, 2008
I think you may want to take the approach of "better safe than sorry" and mention something to her. I agree that not all kids develope at the same rate (both of my boys didn't walk til they were 17 mths!) but as a non-family member you may have a better insight if something is a little "off" with the boy. Things that his mom has just chalked up to normal (for him) at this point.
Just let her know how much you care about her and that you're only trying to help.
L.K. answers from Des Moines on July 18, 2008
I think you should say something. To me is sounds like something is going on with the child. For the age of the child they should be able to wave, make eye contact and tend to a task for a few minutes. All of those things that you have listed are big red flags for autism.
More Answers
S.B. answers from Cedar Rapids on July 18, 2008
The way you approach it can make a difference. 2 of my 6 kids were "on the autism spectrum," (Asperger's) but now you'd never know it (well, most people wouldn't). I'm so grateful for a friend who told me that she saw some signs in my toddler that she'd recommend getting him checked out by a local early access program (that specializes in early intervention for all sorts of childhood issues.) My pediatrician didn't see anything out of the ordinary, but my gut told me to follow through on her advise.
It helped that she told me, not out of fear, but out of a sincere knowledge that early intervention can make such a difference for so many children, and IF he needed it, it'd be good to know. That's all. It was a "maybe it's nothing, but I'd recommend you look into it, just in case it could be helpful" type of thing. And boy, was it helpful!
When he was younger, he would often seem to be looking right through me (but not always, just a lot of the time), and he was SO particular about things, had some sensory issues (couldn't stand to walk on grass bare foot, or be outside if it was windy, be in loud places, swing, or ride in a shopping cart), was obsessed with cars and mechanical things and would shake his head and shoulders back and forth (as if simulating rocking) to fall asleep. The terror in his eyes when he was in a shopping cart or in the wind made me know his tantruming was because he sincerely couldn't handle it. There were just a lot of little things.
Now, he'll be entering a regular kindergarten class next month and he's doing great. Would he be doing as well without the little changes and therapies we provided for him? Maybe. But I SAW how deep pressure would immediately calm him down in the shopping cart and at times he was overloaded. I SAW how working with him on the trampoline helped him develop a better sense of being grounded. I SAW him overcome him obstacles with guidance and I'm so glad we were able to provide him with that while he was so maleable.
Talk to her. Just be optimistic. It may be autism, it may be less severe, it may be nothing. No need for fear. Just get checked out so you have options, IF needed.
I think what upsets people is when parents "freak out," insisting that something is wrong with their child when they think it's just normal growing up. I'd say, there is no need to be fearful and overly anxious. Knowledge is power, though. It is GOOD to get honest evaluations, listen to your gut and be proactive. It is not good to suppress feelings or reason them away out of fear. If it's nothing, great. It's nothing. Although, I'd also say to encourage the mother to consider getting him checked out, but then to listen to her gut no matter what. (Not all doctors are as convinced of the prevelance of autism-related disorders or the impact of early intervention.)
As mothers, we are blessed to have other mothers who help support us with our children. Kudos to you for caring for them.
1 mom found this helpful
P.Y. answers from Rochester on July 18, 2008
I am a mother of four boys. My third child was a lot like the child you speak of. My family doctor also said that my child was just a "late talker" when I went to him with concerns about speech, behavior, and autism at age 2. (He hated haircuts, baths, attention from others, avoided eye contact, would line up his toys, threw a lot of tantrums) I went along with this advice until almost 36 months of age, and there was no improvement. I then took my child to the Mayo Clinic for evaluation and also called early childhood intervention. He was found to have speech/language and some minor developmental delays. Now, after almost 4 years of intensive (3-4 days a week, 30 min. one on one sessions, plus a lot of work at home) speech and developmental therapy, he has successfully completed all-day kindergarten and no longer needs additional services. He is a completely normal 7 year old! His behavior is great, he is a hard worker, and he loves school. His speech is as good as anyone else's his age.
It is so important to start intervention early! And to be safe rather than sorry down the line. Your school district should have an Early Intervention phone number to call about concerns. I found this to be the most helpful. It's a long process, but the rewards are great!
J.H. answers from Appleton on July 18, 2008
Dear B.,
Is your friend willing to get a speech evaluation for her son? You mentioned that he does seem delayed with talking. It is possible that if your friend went in for a speech evaluation and the speech therapist saw other problems she/he may recommend to your friend that they go for further developmental evaluations. This may be an easier approach for her to swallow.
My 4 yr old son has autism and was diagnosed when he was 21 months old. I would not have caught it that early, but my mom said something to me after hearing me describe our daily lives to her over the phone to her. (We lived 1500 miles away at the time.) I was defensive and told her that I told that he was just "quirky." But sometime nagged my mind after that and I mentioned something to his pediatrician at our next appointment. She didn't see anything wrong either, but sent us for speech and hearing evaluations. Both of these trained people saw something in my son that inspired them to refer me for a developmental evaluation, at which he was diagnosed. So for as much as I was upset with my mom at the moment for thinking there was something wrong with MY son, I am grateful that she did open her mouth and put that nagging question in my mind that I just could get rid of.
I would be happy to share an additional information with you (or your friend) if you need/want. Our son has made some HUGE improvement since the start of his therapies. (speech, behavioral, and occupational(which is great for sensory problems of which our son has MANY)). There is hope.
J.G. answers from Milwaukee on July 17, 2008
Hi B.,
If she is your friend, just ask her.
Sometimes we as parents tend to not notice these things because they are with the child all the time and it seems "normal".
Juts simply say, "___________, can I ask you a personal question without you being upset with me? You're my friend and I love you to pieces, but something has been on my mind and I don't want to offended." Get her feedback.
Then ask her...
S.S. answers from Milwaukee on July 18, 2008
Tread carefully. I had a close friend, and I watched her child for close to a year. So many people questioned me about her child's odd behavior, and I didnt' interfere for so long. Even though, I am a speech pathologist and worked with autistic children. Finally, after a year, I mentioned that it wouldn't hurt to have her son evaluated by a speech pathologist ...that way, they could not lose anymore critical speech development time. I explained that the sooner the diagnosis,the better for the child. She stopped talking to me. I heard, through the grapevine, about a year later, that, indeed, her son had been diagnosed with autism. Why she was angered with me, I'm not sure. I never did say the word autism, I just suggested early intervention for speech delay. That was almost 8 yrs ago, and she still doeosn't speak to me. Who knows. So, think hard, and be willing to accept any backlash. SOrry, I can't tell you definitely what to do. I can only relay what happened to me.
S.S. answers from Davenport on July 18, 2008
I have not read all of the many responses to your question, and I am sure you have gotten alot of good insights from others. I will share my experience though.
I noticed some of the things you have mentioned in my nephew (my husband's brother's son) when he was about 18 months old. He did alot of things very repetitively that did not seem normal to me, he paid very little attention to other people and no attention to other kids, he would not eat many foods, didn't talk, but he seemed to be very happy--always smiling, hardly ever cried, even if he fell down and looked like he would have been hurt. I did some research online and found that these were characteristics of autism.
I told my husband about it and we decided it would be best to say something because of all the signs we could see. It was a difficult decision, because we were afraid of offending them or being wrong, but we felt it was better to say something than let it go. We (like you) were concerned and only wanted what was best for the little guy.
We felt it was better to share our concerns, so that if he needed help he could get it as soon as possible. If they had been mad, at least we didn't just ignore the issue.
I think that most of us do not want to see if there is something odd or different about our own children. When you are with them every day, you don't see that there is anything unusual about their behavior.
Any way, my husband talked with his brother and they did have it checked out. He has been diagnosed as autistic and has come a long way with therapy. He is 3 1/2 now. I don't know a lot about it, but have been told that early detection and treatment are critical. I think that you should talk to your friend. Let her know that you care and want what is best for her son, and that you are not trying to be mean. Tell her that you have done some research and what behaviors concern you. If she has him tested and needs treatment, she will thank you in the long run.
Good luck, I know this is a tough subject to approach.
H.A. answers from Waterloo on July 18, 2008
I think you may want to take the approach of "better safe than sorry" and mention something to her. I agree that not all kids develope at the same rate (both of my boys didn't walk til they were 17 mths!) but as a non-family member you may have a better insight if something is a little "off" with the boy. Things that his mom has just chalked up to normal (for him) at this point.
Just let her know how much you care about her and that you're only trying to help.
A.B. answers from Minneapolis on July 18, 2008
Check out "Raising a Sensory Smart Child." It's more about Sensory Integration, which is on the Autism Spectrum. If speech is the only issue, there may not be an issue. If there are other things, then you (your friend) will see the interconnections. I would educate yourself (and your friend if you find other things) before going to other doctors. My ped just racks it up to normal development issues. In this day and age, we need to be better educated about our own children because the professionals can only specialize in so much.
Email