N.C. asks from San Pedro, CA on February 25, 2008
Attitude Adjustment
I just had this big fight with daughter over her sassy rude attitude. I guess part of my frustration is that as a kid I was never allowed to speak to my parents rudely or disrespectfully and I guess I am expecting the same treatment. It seems that's part of the problem is my EXPECTATIONS. I am expecting a certain behavior and when I don't get it or I am getting the exact opposite (the sass and disrespectful attitude), I freak. I have taken away her privileges, i.e.phone, friends etc. in the hopes her attitude will improve but of course now she is just more upset than ever. Got any ideas of what might help?
So What Happened?™
Thank you to everyone for your ideas and advice. You all offered me some great insight and I am very appreciative of your support. We had a good long talk (my daughter, husband and I) and I think things are improving. I know she's just starting down the path of adolescence and I want to/need to keep the communication open. Your suggestions gave me many things to think about and I am grateful for your community of support. Best regards, N.
Featured Answers
S.D. answers from Los Angeles on February 27, 2008
I know this will sound harsh, but watch and listen to how you talk to her. If she is simply doing exactly what you do when you "freak out," then you'll have to change how you speak to her, because she is learning it from you. It's one of the hardest things as a parent to realize. If that is not the case, then tell her if she continues to act like this, you'll take the door off the hinges in her room. She will have no privacy, and she will HATE it. Tell her she can say whatever she wants about you to her friends and she can "vent" to them too. But as far as you're concerned, she had better bite her tongue when she's speaking directly to you. You're on the right track to "nip it in the bud" now. She is 12 and it will only get worse if it's not addressed.
1 mom found this helpful
H.S. answers from Los Angeles on February 27, 2008
Hi N.
I have six daughters ranging in ages 1 - 16 years old. I do not accept rude, unkind or sassy language. I have one daughter (almost 10) that slips into making these types of bad choices. I remind her that it is my job to raise herto be a respectful, compassionate part of society. I tell her I treat her as I want to be treated - ask her if she wants me to treat her the way that she is treating me (no) remind her that I can be the best at being rude (even if thats not true) and if she chooses not to treat me as I like - I do not reward her behavior with my attention - I have her do an unpleasant chore. Pick up dg poop, scrub the bathroom floor, do her sisters chore of taking the laundry outside - or stand in the corner - There is no compromise. There is no "shes just going thru a stage"
1 mom found this helpful
C.B. answers from San Luis Obispo on February 27, 2008
We are right there with you and my 9 year old in her sassy pants. I call her on it every time. 'That is back talk, try again.' 'Watch the attitude when you speak to a grown up.' I can't say it is helping, but she at least knows what is going on, and it serves as a warning.
A friend came over for dinner, and she recalled having to get her mouth washed out with soap when she said things as a child. WOW! I remember the same thing. Sometimes I was just too rude and paid the price. I'm thinking that we may have to buy that bar of soap together and put the fear in her. LOL!
Good luck.
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
T.P. answers from Los Angeles on February 27, 2008
As soon as you start arguing with your daughter, you've lost the battle. You must choose to NOT react, but lovingly , yet sternly, continue to discipline her with taking away the things she loves. When you show consistency with disciplinary action w/o reacting to her behavior, AND when she learns she will not win when she chooses disrespect and a bad attitude, she will start to change. The most important part on your behalf is to encourage the good things that she does.....and not in a patronizing way but a genuine loving way. Love heals all.....and our children need to know they're loved even when they are misbehaving. In this journey of life, there will always be rules....we need to teach our children that disrespect and sour attitudes are a choice.....and they really don't solve anything.
2 moms found this helpful
J.S. answers from Honolulu on February 26, 2008
Aloha N.. Peace to you. Which one is the sassy one? My seven year old daughter is sassing me too. The more time she spends with her friends (one in particular) the worse it gets. I also never was allowed to disrespect my parents. The discipline for disrespect was MUCH worse than messing up in the first place. I teach high school and, frankly, am shocked to be experiencing this attitude so early. That being said, can you imagine that if you do not attempt to correct this now how much worse do you think it will be a year from now? You must find a way to discipline (read: instruct or teach her the consequences)her attitude now. It will only serve her well. So she is somewhat miserable for a while. Better now at home than to be a jerk in public and have others respond to her rudeness the same way. Teach her to be assertive, yes, but only in respect to standing up for her rights. If you don't teach her to respect you and those in authority, who will? I deal with rude sassy high school students EVERY DAY whose parents never took the time to do this and believe me, I often think that I may quit teaching just not to deal with that attitude anymore. I know each child is unique and what you have tried so far has not worked... don't give up! Keep looking for different methods to daily inculcate a proper attitude and eventually she will turn around. With my 7 year old, we came up with a list of her responsibilities and give her $5 in quarters every week. Every time she talks back, questions me or dad, asks the same question more than once to which I already responded NO, etc. she has to go give me a quarter (or two). The list is posted on the fridge and she helped make it. She has so many toys that taking them away didn't work. Limiting time with friends did help somewhat but made us all miserable. I do spend about 20-30 minutes one on one time with her for homework and chatting as many days as possible but it doesn't always happen. I always tuck her with prayers at night and we brush our teeth together too. Eventually she won't want to spend so much time with me so I try to cherish it now. I don't know if this helps... but keep the faith. Something will work and you will all benefit from your diligence as a parent. Best wishes! J. O. Smith
2 moms found this helpful
C.W. answers from Los Angeles on February 26, 2008
I am assuming your talking about your 12 year old.I have a 10 year old going through the same phase. Everyone tells me it's puberty. I too was not allowed to disrespect my parents so the back talk really gets to me. I've been talking to her at the end of the day when things are calmed down and I try to listen to her point of view as long as she is not having attitude. I let her know that when she can speak to me respectfully that I will listen. It is helping but we have a long way to go.
2 moms found this helpful
L.B. answers from Las Vegas on February 26, 2008
Hang in there N.! She is testing to see how far she can go and how long it takes to get you agitated. I always liked a car ride with my kids. One on one, Starbucks or a burger. Just get in the car and drive. No distraction and no one can walk away. It may not happen the first time out, but I promise at some point when it's just the two of you in the car she will feel free to open up, sometimes they just don't know how to communicate how they feel and how to put it into words that make sense. It's a crazy time for kids out there and the only safe place for them to fall is in your ability to listen. Mine are 25, 23 and 20. The car is still our favorite place to talk. God Bless.
1 mom found this helpful
E.M. answers from Los Angeles on February 27, 2008
N.,
Just a few words on the differences from the earlier generation and the one today.
I heard that the children look to the parents relationship and the way they talk to each other in molding their behavior to their parents. In the past there were more set roles and the father was typically the head of the household and thus treated differently than today. I know that my daughter would be worse when I ranted about something her stepdad said or did, not realizing that she was listening to me. I have since kept a check on what comes out of my mouth and have seen a change (over a couple years) with her relationships at the home front.
With that said I also believe that moms and daughters have this struggle once they reach a certain age and more parenting education needs to be taken on for this special time. Your relationship with your daughter can go either way drastically unless you find a class or book. I remember the book "Reviving Ophelia: Saving the Selves of Adolescent Girls." There are others listed on Amazon that might help also. Try to remember that you are in this together whether she realizes it or not. It is not about you. She is trying to navigate prewomanhood and needs your patience and help as the elder woman in the family.
Evelyn
1 mom found this helpful
H.F. answers from Los Angeles on February 27, 2008
Good for you N.! Why should your expectations of her be any less than they are right now? I don't believe this attitude that it's OK for kids to be sassy with their parents. It's not good for kids to get away with being rude to their parents. It's not good for them, their parents, their siblings or society. If you are consistent with the rules and punishments for breaking the rules eventually she will learn to stop being sassy and attitudinal. Keep up the good work, be strong!
H.
1 mom found this helpful
J.L. answers from Los Angeles on February 27, 2008
lead by example, if you freak, it does not have a good impact. provide consistancy, structure and follow through- over time if you are really consistant you will see results. also perhaps focus on your relationship with her- not just getting her to do what you want--
1 mom found this helpful
H.S. answers from Los Angeles on February 27, 2008
Hi N.
I have six daughters ranging in ages 1 - 16 years old. I do not accept rude, unkind or sassy language. I have one daughter (almost 10) that slips into making these types of bad choices. I remind her that it is my job to raise herto be a respectful, compassionate part of society. I tell her I treat her as I want to be treated - ask her if she wants me to treat her the way that she is treating me (no) remind her that I can be the best at being rude (even if thats not true) and if she chooses not to treat me as I like - I do not reward her behavior with my attention - I have her do an unpleasant chore. Pick up dg poop, scrub the bathroom floor, do her sisters chore of taking the laundry outside - or stand in the corner - There is no compromise. There is no "shes just going thru a stage"
1 mom found this helpful
Email